Fractional CFO
Is your business model working? A financial check-up
November 19, 2026 · 9 min read

Quick answer
A business model is working when each sale leaves real money after the costs that come with it (contribution margin), that money comfortably covers your fixed costs (break-even), and cash comes back fast enough to fund growth (cash conversion cycle). Check six numbers once a year, or before any big decision: contribution per order, gross margin trend, fixed cost coverage, break-even revenue, cash conversion cycle and customer concentration. If two or more look weak, the model needs work, not just more sales.
Revenue is up 20% on two years ago. You're busier than ever, you've added people, and somehow the bank balance looks the same as it did when you were half the size. Your CPA says you made a small profit. It doesn't feel like it.
That's usually not a bookkeeping problem. It's a business model problem: the way you make money has drifted, and growth is hiding it. The good news is that you can see it in your own numbers in an afternoon, if you know which six to look at.
This post gives you those six numbers, a one-page scorecard to put them on, and a worked example that runs through every calculation.
6
Numbers that tell you whether the model works, not just whether you sold more
1 page
The scorecard. If it doesn't fit on one page, nobody looks at it twice
Once a year
Minimum. Also before a price change, a new channel, a big hire or a loan
What does "the business model is working" actually mean?
Strip away the jargon and a business model is a promise: if we sell this, to these customers, at this price, through this channel, we'll make money and get the cash back in time to do it again.
So the check-up asks three questions:
- Does each sale make money? Not gross revenue. What's left after the costs that only exist because you made that sale.
- Is there enough of it to pay for everything else? Rent, salaries, software, insurance. The costs that show up whether you sell anything or not.
- Does the cash come back fast enough? A profitable model that ties up cash for four months can still run you out of money while you grow.
Your profit and loss answers part of this. It doesn't answer it per order, per channel or per customer, and that's where most broken models hide.
The six numbers to check
1. Contribution margin per order (or customer). Revenue minus every variable cost tied to that sale: product cost, shipping, payment fees, sales commissions, and marketing spend that rises and falls with sales. If you sell through more than one channel, work it out for each one. Contribution margin by channel goes deeper on this.
2. Gross margin trend. One year's gross margin tells you little. Three or four years tell you whether pricing is keeping up with costs. If you're fuzzy on how gross margin differs from net, this explainer sorts it out.
3. Fixed cost coverage. Total contribution divided by fixed costs. At 1.0x you're exactly breaking even. Below it, every month loses money.
4. Break-even revenue. Fixed costs divided by your contribution margin percentage. That's the formula the SBA uses too. Then compare it to what you actually sell: the gap is your margin of safety.
5. Cash conversion cycle. Days of inventory plus days to collect from customers, minus days you take to pay suppliers. It tells you how long each dollar is stuck in the business before it comes back. It's the operating side of working capital.
6. Revenue concentration. Your largest customer, and your top three, as a share of revenue. Not a profit measure, but it tells you how fragile the other five numbers are.
A worked example: a small food brand that feels busy and broke
Say you run a specialty sauce company with $3,000,000 of annual revenue. You sell two ways: wholesale to grocers ($1,800,000) and direct online ($1,200,000). Fixed costs (salaries, rent, kitchen equipment leases, software, insurance) are $720,000 a year, or $60,000 a month.
Here's what each channel really earns.
| Wholesale | Online | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orders a year | 1,200 | 20,000 | 21,200 |
| Average order | $1,500 | $60 | |
| Revenue | $1,800,000 | $1,200,000 | $3,000,000 |
| Product cost (COGS) | $1,116,000 (62%) | $480,000 (40%) | $1,596,000 |
| Freight and broker commission | $198,000 | $198,000 | |
| Shipping, packaging and card fees | $276,000 | $276,000 | |
| Ad spend | $150,000 | $150,000 | |
| Contribution | $486,000 (27%) | $294,000 (24.5%) | $780,000 (26%) |
| Contribution per order | $405 | $14.70 |
Online looks great on gross margin (60% against wholesale's 38%). Once you add shipping at $12 an order, 3% card fees and the ads that bring the orders in, it actually contributes a little less per dollar than wholesale.
Revenue and contribution by channel
Hypothetical sauce company, one year
- Revenue
- Contribution
Hypothetical example. Contribution is revenue minus product cost and every cost that moves with sales.
Show the numbers
| Revenue | Contribution | |
|---|---|---|
| Wholesale | $1,800,000 | $486,000 |
| Online | $1,200,000 | $294,000 |
Now the whole business, from revenue down to operating profit:
Where the $3 million goes
The same company, full year
- Adds profit
- Uses profit
- Total
Hypothetical example: 3,000,000 − 1,596,000 − 198,000 − 276,000 − 150,000 − 720,000 = 60,000.
Show the numbers
| Revenue | $3,000,000 |
| Product cost | −$1,596,000 |
| Freight, commission | −$198,000 |
| Shipping and fees | −$276,000 |
| Ad spend | −$150,000 |
| Fixed costs | −$720,000 |
| Operating profit | $60,000 |
Fixed cost coverage: $780,000 ÷ $720,000 = 1.08x. Barely above water.
Break-even revenue: $720,000 ÷ 26% = about $2,770,000. Actual revenue is $3,000,000, so the margin of safety is roughly 8%. Lose one mid-sized grocer and the year turns into a loss.
Gross margin trend: blended gross margin was 52% four years ago, then 50%, 48.5%, and 46.8% this year ($1,404,000 of gross profit on $3,000,000). Ingredient costs went up and wholesale prices didn't.
Cash conversion cycle: inventory of $410,000 against $1,596,000 of COGS is about 94 days. Receivables of $270,000 against $3,000,000 of revenue is about 33 days. Payables of $175,000 against COGS is about 40 days. So 94 + 33 − 40 = 87 days of cash tied up in every sale.
Concentration: the largest grocer buys $540,000 a year, 18% of revenue. The top three are $1,080,000, or 36%.
None of this shows up as a crisis on the P&L. A $60,000 profit looks fine. The scorecard tells a different story.
The one-page scorecard
Put the six numbers on one page with a simple flag. Here's the example company's version.
| Number | This business | Comfortable | Flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contribution margin | 26% overall (27% wholesale, 24.5% online) | Depends on your fixed costs; see coverage | Watch |
| Gross margin trend | 52% to 46.8% over four years | Flat or rising | Red |
| Fixed cost coverage | 1.08x | 1.25x or more | Red |
| Break-even vs actual revenue | $2.77M vs $3.0M (8% cushion) | 20% cushion or more | Red |
| Cash conversion cycle | 87 days | Shorter than last year | Watch |
| Largest customer | 18% of revenue | Under 10% is a common comfort level | Watch |
The "comfortable" column holds rules of thumb, not standards. What counts as healthy depends on your industry. The point is to pick a target, write it down and compare yourself to it every year.
What would you actually change?
The scorecard shows where to push. In this example, three levers stand out.
Price. A 4% increase on wholesale is $72,000 a year. If volume holds, all of it drops to contribution, which more than doubles operating profit from $60,000 to $132,000. Even if a few accounts push back, the math is strongly in favor of asking.
Online shipping. Shipping and packaging at $12 an order costs $240,000 a year, close to half of what online would contribute without it. A free-shipping threshold or a modest price rise on small orders could move it more than any new ad campaign.
Inventory. At 94 days, there's about $410,000 sitting on shelves. Cutting that to 70 days would free roughly $100,000 of cash without selling one more bottle.
What it would not fix is more volume at the current margins. With 26% contribution, every extra $100,000 of sales adds only $26,000 before any new fixed costs, and growth usually brings some.
Use the break-even calculator to test price changes against your own fixed costs before you commit.
Common mistakes in a business model check-up
Calling ad spend a fixed cost. If you'd cut it when sales drop, or raise it to get more sales, it's variable. Leaving it in overhead makes your channels look better than they are.
Using one year of gross margin. A single year can't show drift. Pull at least three.
Averaging away the problem. A blended 26% contribution hides the channel or customer that's really at 10%. Always break it down at least one level.
Ignoring cash timing. A model can be profitable on paper and still starve for cash if the cycle is long and growth is fast. The faster you grow, the more the cash cycle matters.
Running the check-up on messy books. If COGS includes random overhead, or shipping costs sit in "office expenses", every number on the scorecard is wrong. Clean the categories first.
When to get help
You can absolutely do this yourself. If your books are clean and you can pull revenue and costs by channel, the six numbers take an afternoon and a spreadsheet.
It's worth getting someone senior involved when the scorecard shows two or more red flags, when you're about to change prices or add a channel, or when a lender or investor is asking how the model works. That's the kind of work a fractional CFO does. At Fintrix Consulting it comes with a KPI dashboard and budget vs actual each month, plus a monthly strategy session on what the numbers mean. Here's how our fractional CFO service works.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between gross margin and contribution margin?
Gross margin subtracts only the cost of goods sold. Contribution margin also subtracts the other costs that move with each sale, like shipping, payment fees, commissions and variable marketing. Contribution margin is the better test of whether a sale really pays.
How often should I run a business model check-up?
At least once a year, ideally after your year-end close. Run it again before any big decision: a price change, a new channel, a major hire or a loan.
What's a good cash conversion cycle?
It depends heavily on the industry. Service businesses with no inventory usually run much shorter cycles than businesses that hold stock. The useful test is whether yours is getting shorter or longer year over year.
Is customer concentration really a business model problem?
It's a risk problem that affects the model. If one customer is a big share of revenue, they have pricing power over you, and losing them could push you below break-even overnight. Lenders and buyers look at it closely.
Can I do this with cash-basis books?
Roughly, but accrual numbers are much better. Cash books put costs in the month you paid them, not the month you sold the product, so contribution by month can swing wildly.
The bottom line
Growth can hide a business model that's quietly getting worse. Six numbers, contribution per order, gross margin trend, fixed cost coverage, break-even, cash cycle and concentration, show you whether each sale really pays and whether there's enough cushion. Put them on one page, set a target for each, and check them every year. When two or more turn red, fix the model before you chase more sales.
Sources
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Planning an exit: getting your financials sale-ready
November 20, 2026
- The monthly finance rhythm every CEO needs
November 20, 2026
- When to add a controller to your finance team
November 20, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.