Fractional CFO
Getting ready to sell: quality of earnings and clean books
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
A quality of earnings (QoE) report is a deep check, usually by an independent accounting firm, of how much of your profit is real, recurring and backed by cash. Buyers price your business off the adjusted EBITDA it produces, so weak add-backs and messy books come straight off the price. Start keeping clean monthly accrual books 12 to 36 months before you plan to sell.
Somebody has made you an offer, or you'd like to step back in a few years. Your broker has a spreadsheet of "add-backs" that makes the business look more profitable than you thought. Then the buyer's accountants arrive.
That's when many owners learn that the tax return, QuickBooks and the buyer's view are three different numbers. The buyer's is the one that counts, and it's usually the lowest.
Below: what a quality of earnings report tests, which add-backs survive, how the working capital peg moves your price at closing, what the SBA now requires for 7(a)-financed buyers, and a prep timeline.
12–36 months
of clean monthly accrual books before a sale is a sensible target
$3M+
SBA 7(a) acquisition price at which the lender must get a QoE (SOP 50 10 8.1)
4–6 weeks
typical length of the QoE work itself, per Baker Tilly
What does a quality of earnings report actually do?
A quality of earnings report starts with your reported profit and asks one question: if I owned this business next year, what would it really earn? It's not an audit; nobody issues an opinion. It's a buyer-focused, usually month-by-month analysis of whether your earnings are real, repeatable and backed by cash. (For how that differs from assurance work, see audit, review or compilation.)
A typical QoE covers five things:
- Adjusted EBITDA. Reported EBITDA plus or minus normalizing adjustments: owner pay brought to market, one-time costs removed, personal expenses added back, accounting errors fixed.
- Revenue quality. Customer concentration, contract terms, churn, and whether revenue landed in the right month.
- Net working capital. Your "normal" receivables, inventory and payables, which becomes the peg.
- Debt-like items. Loans, unpaid taxes, deferred revenue, accrued bonuses.
- A cash proof. Bank statements reconciled to the income statement and tax return, period by period.
Buyers commission their own (buy-side); sellers can commission one first (sell-side) to find the problems before buyers do. Baker Tilly puts the work at roughly four to six weeks once the data is ready. "Once the data is ready" is where clean books earn their money.
Why do clean monthly accrual books change the price and the timeline?
Because the QoE team rebuilds your numbers month by month. If your books are on cash basis, or cleaned up once a year for the tax return, they reconstruct the accruals themselves, slowly and conservatively. The difference between the two methods is explained in cash vs accrual accounting.
Clean books do three things:
- The work goes faster. The QoE team tests instead of rebuilding.
- Fewer surprises. Unrecorded bills and revenue booked early reduce EBITDA. Found by you, they're a footnote. Found by the buyer, they reopen the price.
- Your add-backs are believable. A clean ledger with clear memos is evidence. A pile of "misc expense" isn't.
Buyers don't need perfect. They need to trust that what they see is complete. Low confidence shows up as escrows, earnouts and lower multiples.
Which add-backs do buyers accept, and which do they reject?
An add-back is an expense you argue won't continue under a new owner. Buyers accept documented ones that genuinely go away, and reject wishes.
| Add-back | Usually accepted when | Usually rejected when |
|---|---|---|
| Owner pay above market | You can show what a hired manager would cost | Nobody would actually do the job for that market rate |
| One-time costs (lawsuit, move, rebrand) | It truly happened once, with invoices | "One-time" repairs or consultants that show up every year |
| Personal expenses run through the business | Clearly personal, documented, not needed to run things | Mixed-use costs the business still needs (the truck is also the work truck) |
| Family on payroll | They'll leave and won't need replacing | Their work still has to be done by someone |
| Discretionary spend you'd "cut" | Rarely | It drives revenue (marketing, sales staff) |
| Related-party rent | Normalized to market, up or down | You only adjust when it helps you |
Normalizing works both ways: below-market owner pay or friendly related-party rent gets adjusted to what a new owner would pay.
A worked example: from reported EBITDA to a price
Say you own a commercial HVAC service company. Hypothetical numbers, for illustration only. Your books show $820,000 of EBITDA for the last twelve months. Your broker's add-back schedule says adjusted EBITDA is $1,153,000.
The buyer's QoE goes through it line by line:
- Owner pay: you take $310,000. A hired general manager would cost about $160,000. Accepted: +$150,000.
- Personal expenses: a family vehicle and vacations booked through the business, with receipts. Accepted: +$38,000.
- Lawsuit: a one-time settlement and legal fees with a former supplier. Accepted: +$45,000.
- Revenue cut-off: $62,000 of maintenance prepayments was booked as revenue on receipt; the work happens next year. Removed: −$62,000.
- Related-party rent: you rent your own building to the company for $60,000 a year; market rent is $96,000. Normalized: −$36,000.
- Rejected: $60,000 of marketing you "could cut" (it brings in the leads) and $40,000 of "one-time" equipment repairs that appear every year.
Reported EBITDA to QoE-adjusted EBITDA
Hypothetical HVAC service company, last twelve months
- Raises EBITDA
- Lowers EBITDA
- Total
Hypothetical example. Not a market valuation.
Show the numbers
| Reported EBITDA | $820,000 |
| Owner pay to market | +$150,000 |
| Personal expenses | +$38,000 |
| One-time lawsuit | +$45,000 |
| Prepayment cut-off | −$62,000 |
| Rent to market | −$36,000 |
| Adjusted EBITDA | $955,000 |
So adjusted EBITDA is $955,000, not $1,153,000. The $198,000 gap is the $100,000 of rejected add-backs plus the $98,000 of negative adjustments the broker never listed.
Now apply a multiple. We'll use 4.5x purely as an illustration; real multiples depend on your industry, size, growth and the buyer, and we're not quoting market data here.
| EBITDA | × 4.5 (illustrative) | |
|---|---|---|
| Broker's adjusted EBITDA | $1,153,000 | $5,188,500 |
| QoE-adjusted EBITDA | $955,000 | $4,297,500 |
| Difference | $198,000 | $891,000 |
Every dollar of EBITDA the QoE removes costs you the multiple. Clean books let you find the $62,000 cut-off problem a year early. You can try your own numbers in the EBITDA calculator.
What is the working capital peg, in plain English?
Most deals assume the buyer gets a business with a normal amount of working capital in it: enough receivables, inventory and unpaid bills to keep running without new cash on day one. Cash and debt are usually excluded ("cash-free, debt-free").
The peg is that normal level, set in the purchase agreement. The most common method, per Withum, is the average monthly net working capital over the trailing twelve months. At closing, the actual figure is compared with the peg, and the price moves dollar for dollar.
Back to the example. The HVAC company's twelve-month average net working capital (receivables plus inventory, minus payables and accruals) is $410,000: that's the peg. Before closing you chase receivables and stretch payables, so closing working capital is $360,000. You've collected more cash, but the price drops by $50,000. Mostly you've moved money between pockets.
The peg is only as reliable as your month-end balance sheets. If they weren't right each month, the average is a guess, and the side with better numbers wins.
What does the SBA require when the buyer uses a 7(a) loan?
Many smaller acquisitions use SBA 7(a) loans. SBA's SOP 50 10 8.1 (with technical updates) applies to applications given an SBA loan number on or after October 1, 2026. Appendix 15 covers 7(a) changes of ownership.
The lender must use the QoE's earnings in its debt service coverage test; if they don't support the price, the loan shrinks and the buyer needs more equity. A buyer's own QoE counts only after one of the lender's vendors reviews it. The report must address owner pay above or below market, related-party transactions, deferred maintenance and cash vs accrual differences, the same items in our example.
So your sell-side QoE can't replace the lender's, but the lender's will find the same things, and you'd rather know first. If your returns, books and bank statements don't tie, the cash proof will show it.
How far ahead should you start preparing?
Earlier than you think. Buyers want two or three years of consistent history plus the current year.
36–24 months out
Switch to monthly accrual books
Close and reconcile every month, move to accrual, and fix the chart of accounts so the years compare.
24–12 months out
Clean up owner and related-party items
Stop running personal costs through the business and set market-rate pay and rent.
12–6 months out
Build the add-back file and the peg
Document every add-back and track monthly net working capital.
6–3 months out
Consider a sell-side QoE
Have an independent firm test your numbers, then fix or explain what they find.
3–0 months out
Stock the data room
Statements, returns, bank statements, contracts and debt schedules that tie to each other.
Whatever goes in the data room should already agree: return to books, books to bank. What buyers check item by item is covered in investor-ready books.
Common mistakes
- Treating the tax return as earnings. Tax books minimize tax; buyers want economic earnings.
- Padding the add-back list. Each rejected add-back makes buyers doubt the strong ones. Five documented beat fifteen hopeful.
- Ignoring negative adjustments. Below-market pay, cheap related-party rent and early revenue all come off.
- Cleaning up only the last year. If earlier years are cash basis, the trend can't be compared.
- Draining working capital before closing. It usually just lowers the price.
- Learning your numbers from the buyer's QoE. By then you're negotiating from behind.
When to get help
If a sale is years away and your books already close monthly on accrual, you're mostly fine. Document anything unusual as it happens.
Get help sooner if you're on cash basis, clean up once a year, mix personal and business costs, or don't know your real EBITDA. A fractional CFO helps: accrual books, a defensible model and the data room. If you'd like that kind of support, see fractional CFO services at Fintrix Consulting. The QoE itself, the valuation and the deal's legal and tax structure belong with an independent accounting firm, a valuation professional, an M&A attorney and your CPA.
Frequently asked questions
Is a quality of earnings report the same as an audit?
No. An audit gives an opinion on financial statements. A QoE is a deal-focused analysis of how much profit is recurring and backed by cash.
Should I get a sell-side QoE?
Often, if buyers will commission their own anyway: you find the problems first. For very small deals, clean monthly books get you most of the benefit.
Can my sell-side QoE be used for an SBA loan?
Not as the lender's report. Under SOP 50 10 8.1 the QoE for a 7(a) acquisition of $3 million or more must not be prepared by or for the seller. A buyer's own QoE can be used only after the lender's vendor reviews it.
How is the working capital peg usually set?
Most often as the average monthly net working capital over the last twelve months, excluding cash and debt. Closing above the peg raises the price; below it lowers the price, dollar for dollar.
How long before a sale should I clean up my books?
Ideally 24 to 36 months ahead. Twelve months is the practical minimum.
The bottom line
Buyers pay for the profit they believe will continue, and the QoE is how they decide what to believe. Clean monthly accrual books, documented add-backs and a working capital figure you already know leave less room to chip at the price. If an SBA-financed buyer is likely, make sure your bank statements tie to your tax returns. Start two or three years out if you can.
Sources
- SOP 50 10 8.1 with Technical Updates, effective October 1, 2026, Appendix 15 (SBA)
- SOP 50 10, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs (SBA)
- Information Notice 5000-880695, Issuance of SOP 50 10 8.1 (SBA)
- Information Notice 5000-882227, Issuance of Technical Updates to SOP 50 10 8.1 (SBA)
- What to know about a quality of earnings report in pre-sale due diligence (Baker Tilly)
- Basic Overview of Net Working Capital for Mergers & Acquisitions (Withum)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Financial forecasting for small businesses, step by step
November 18, 2026
- Fractional CFO vs full-time CFO: cost, fit and timing
November 18, 2026
- How to build a business budget from scratch (for 2027)
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.