E-commerce
Booking holiday returns and gift cards
November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
At December 31, book revenue only for holiday sales you expect customers to keep. Record a refund liability for the refunds you expect in January and a return asset for the cost of the goods you expect back, both under ASC 606. Unredeemed gift cards are a contract liability, not revenue, until they're used, and expected breakage can be recognized as revenue in step with redemptions, unless state unclaimed property law says the money goes to the state.
December was your best month. The P&L says so. Then January arrives and the returns roll in: the sweaters in the wrong size, the duplicate gadgets, the gifts nobody wanted. Refunds go out, and January's revenue looks dreadful. Meanwhile there's a pile of gift cards sitting in customers' drawers, and the cash from them is already in your bank account looking a lot like profit.
If that's how your books handle the holidays, December is overstated and January is understated, and a lender reading your year-end statements sees a better year than you had.
The fix is a handful of year-end entries. Here's what they are, with a worked example you can copy.
2
Balances to book for expected returns: a refund liability and a return asset
0
Revenue from a gift card on the day you sell it
5 years
Minimum life of a gift card's funds under federal rules, from issue or last load
Why can't you just record returns when they happen?
You can, and plenty of very small stores do. If returns are small and steady, the distortion is small too.
The trouble is the holidays aren't steady. A big chunk of December's sales comes back in January, so recording returns as they happen pushes December's returns into the next month and, at year end, into the next year. Under ASC 606, a sale with a right of return is a form of variable consideration. As PwC's revenue guide puts it, revenue is only recognized for the goods you don't expect to be returned. You estimate the returns, using your own return history by product or channel, and book them in the month of the sale.
That estimate creates two balance sheet items:
- a refund liability for the money you expect to give back
- a return asset for your right to get the products back, measured at what the goods cost you, less the cost of getting them back and any expected loss in value (opened boxes, damaged packaging)
They're shown separately, not netted. And you update both every period as returns actually come in and your expectations change.
One exception worth knowing: an exchange for the same product in a different size or color, at the same price, isn't a return for this purpose. No adjustment needed.
A worked example: closing December with returns
Say you run an online home goods store. December gross sales are $400,000. Your products cost you, on average, 45% of the selling price. During December:
- customers already returned and were refunded $15,000 of December orders, all in resellable condition
- based on your last two holiday seasons, you expect another $25,000 of December orders to come back in January
- you expect about $1,250 of those January returns to be damaged or cost money to process
Here's how the entries play out.
| Item | Amount | How it's booked |
|---|---|---|
| Gross December sales | $400,000 | Revenue (before returns) |
| Refunds already paid in December | −$15,000 | Reduces revenue; cash goes out |
| Refund liability for expected January returns | −$25,000 | Reduces revenue; liability on the balance sheet |
| Net revenue | $360,000 | |
| Cost of goods sold on all December sales (45%) | −$180,000 | Cost of sales |
| Cost of goods already returned, back in stock | +$6,750 | Inventory, reduces cost of sales |
| Return asset ($11,250 cost less $1,250 expected loss) | +$10,000 | Asset on the balance sheet, reduces cost of sales |
| Gross profit | $196,750 |
December gross profit after expected returns
A hypothetical online home goods store
- Adds
- Reduces
- Total
Hypothetical example: 400,000 − 15,000 − 25,000 = 360,000; 360,000 − 180,000 + 6,750 + 10,000 = 196,750.
Show the numbers
| Gross sales | $400,000 |
| December refunds | −$15,000 |
| Expected returns | −$25,000 |
| Net revenue | $360,000 |
| Cost of sales | −$180,000 |
| Returned stock | +$6,750 |
| Return asset | +$10,000 |
| Gross profit | $196,750 |
If you'd only recorded the December refunds, gross profit would have been $211,750 ($385,000 of revenue less $173,250 of cost). The difference, $15,000, is the $25,000 refund liability less the $10,000 return asset. That's profit that belongs to nobody yet, because you expect to hand it back.
In January, as the returns arrive, you charge the refunds against the refund liability and move the returned goods from the return asset back into inventory. If returns come in higher or lower than $25,000, the difference adjusts January's revenue. Then you set a new estimate.
How do you account for gift cards?
When you sell a gift card, you haven't sold anything yet. You've taken a prepayment and promised to hand over goods later. So the cash goes to a contract liability (often named "gift cards outstanding" or "unearned revenue"), not to sales. Our post on deferred revenue covers the same idea for other prepayments.
Revenue happens when the card is redeemed for products. The entry then reduces the gift card liability and records the sale.
Continuing the example: in December you sell $30,000 of gift cards. Customers redeem $8,100 of them before year end, and those purchases are already inside the $400,000 of gross sales above, paid with a gift card instead of a credit card.
What is breakage, and when can you book it?
Some gift cards never get used. They're lost, forgotten, or have a few dollars left that nobody bothers to spend. That's breakage.
Under ASC 606, if you expect to be entitled to breakage, you recognize it as revenue in proportion to the pattern of redemptions, as PwC's guide explains. You don't book it all on day one, and you don't wait for the card to be ancient. You need reliable history to estimate it, and the estimate is subject to the same caution as other variable revenue: book only what you're unlikely to have to reverse. If you can't estimate it, you recognize breakage only when the chance the customer uses the rest becomes remote.
In our example, suppose your history says about 10% of gift card value is never redeemed. Of the $30,000 sold, you expect $27,000 to be redeemed and $3,000 to be breakage. Customers redeemed $8,100, which is 30% of the expected $27,000. So you recognize 30% of the $3,000 breakage: $900.
Where December's $30,000 of gift card sales ended up
Same hypothetical store, at December 31
Hypothetical example: 8,100 + 900 + 21,000 = 30,000. Breakage of $900 is 30% (8,100 ÷ 27,000) of the $3,000 expected breakage.
Show the numbers
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Redeemed for products | $8,100 |
| Breakage recognized | $900 |
| Liability at Dec 31 | $21,000 |
The gift card liability at year end is $21,000. That's what your balance sheet should show, with a schedule behind it listing card sales, redemptions and breakage.
How do unclaimed property laws affect gift cards?
This is the part that catches stores out. Many states have unclaimed property (escheat) laws, and some of them require businesses to send unused balances on certain gift cards to the state after a dormancy period. Others exempt gift cards, or exempt them only if they don't expire or carry fees.
The accounting follows the law. Per PwC's guide, if you have to remit unredeemed balances to a government, those amounts are not breakage revenue. They stay a liability until you pay them to the state.
The rules differ by state and depend on the card's terms. Check with your CPA or an unclaimed property adviser before you book any breakage.
Two federal rules to keep in mind while you're at it. Under 12 CFR 1005.20, a store gift card's funds can't expire earlier than five years after the card was issued or last loaded. And promotional cards (the free $10 card with a $100 purchase) are excluded from those gift card rules, and their accounting differs too: they're a discount on a future sale, not a prepayment.
What about sales tax on returns and gift cards?
Gift cards: in most states, selling a gift card isn't a taxable sale. Minnesota's guidance, for example, says gift card sales are not taxable, and tax is charged when the card is used to buy taxable goods, on the full price before the card is applied. Some states differ on the details, so check your own.
Returns: to take the returned sale out of your taxable sales, you generally have to refund the tax as well as the price. California's Regulation 1655, for instance, requires the full sale price including tax to be refunded in cash or credit, though you may keep a restocking charge limited to your actual costs. If the sale was reported in an earlier period, some states want an amended return for that period, while others let you deduct it in the current one.
Platform sales tax reports usually handle returns processed through them. Refunds issued outside the platform, by bank transfer or a manual credit, are where the tax gets missed. For more on how platforms report all this, see Shopify payout reconciliation.
Common mistakes with holiday returns and gift cards
Booking gift card sales as revenue. The most common one by far. December looks fantastic, and the liability that should be on the balance sheet is missing.
Netting refunds against payouts and never seeing them. If your platform deducts refunds from payouts and only the net deposit gets recorded, returns disappear into revenue. You lose sight of your return rate, and the books can't support a refund liability estimate.
Forgetting the inventory side. Booking the refund liability but not the return asset overstates the hit to profit. The goods are coming back, and most can be sold again.
Booking breakage with no history. A new store in its first holiday season usually can't estimate breakage reliably. Keep the whole balance as a liability until you have the data.
Estimating once and never revisiting. Both the returns estimate and the breakage rate get trued up each month. If January's actual returns come in at $31,000, not $25,000, the extra $6,000 hits January.
When should you get help?
If you sell a few hundred orders a year and returns are minimal, recording them as they happen is a reasonable shortcut, and your CPA may be perfectly happy with it.
It's worth getting help if returns are a real share of holiday sales, you sell gift cards in any volume, you sell across several states, or a lender reads your year-end statements. Fintrix Consulting splits marketplace and payment payouts into sales, fees, refunds and reserves, and updates inventory and cost of goods sold every month, so December closes with the right numbers. See how we work with e-commerce businesses.
Frequently asked questions
How do I estimate expected returns?
Use your own history: returns from the last one or two holiday seasons as a percentage of sales, by product category or sales channel if they differ a lot. Adjust for anything new, like a more generous return window this year.
Is the refund liability the same as a sales returns allowance?
It does the same job. Older practice often netted an allowance against accounts receivable. Under ASC 606 the expected refunds are a liability, and the goods you expect back are a separate asset.
Do I need to do this if I use cash-basis accounting?
Not in the same way. Cash-basis books record refunds when paid and gift card cash when received. But if a lender or investor wants GAAP statements, these entries are part of getting there.
Can I put an expiration date on gift cards?
Federal rules say a store gift card's funds can't expire earlier than five years from issue or last load, and some states go further or ban expiration entirely. Check your state's law before printing a date on the card.
The bottom line
December's revenue should only include the sales customers will keep. Book a refund liability and a return asset for expected January returns, keep gift card cash in a liability until the cards are used, and only recognize breakage if you have the history and your state lets you keep it. Refund the tax along with the price on returns. Do it before you close the year, and January stops looking like a disaster that was really December's.
Sources
- 8.2 Rights of return (PwC Viewpoint, Revenue from contracts with customers guide)
- 7.4 Unexercised rights (breakage) (PwC Viewpoint, Revenue from contracts with customers guide)
- 12 CFR 1005.20, Requirements for gift cards and gift certificates (Cornell LII)
- Regulation 1655, Returns, defects and replacements (California Department of Tax and Fee Administration)
- Coupons and other discounts, gift cards (Minnesota Department of Revenue)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Contribution margin by sales channel, with an example
November 19, 2026
- Landed cost: what your COGS is missing
November 19, 2026
- Amazon settlement reports: how to reconcile every deposit
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.