Fintrix Consulting LLC

Payroll & 1099s

How to set up payroll for a small business, step by step

November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Person filling in a form on a clipboard at an office desk with a keyboard and notebook
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

To set up payroll you get an EIN, register with your state for income tax withholding and unemployment insurance, collect a Form W-4 and Form I-9 from each new hire, report them to your state's new-hire registry, pick a pay schedule and a payroll system, then deposit and file payroll taxes on the IRS schedule. Most new employers deposit monthly, file Form 941 every quarter and send W-2s by January 31 (February 1 in 2027).

You've found the person. They start in three weeks, and somewhere in the excitement you realize you've never actually paid an employee. Freelancers, sure. But a W-2 employee comes with registrations, forms and deadlines that nobody hands you.

The good news: it's a one-time setup followed by a routine. Get the setup right and the routine mostly runs itself. Get it wrong and you spend next year answering notices. Here's the setup in the order we'd do it, the federal deposit and filing rules for 2026 and early 2027, and what one employee really costs.

7.65%

Employer share of Social Security and Medicare on each paycheck (6.2% + 1.45%)

$184,500

2026 Social Security wage base. The 6.2% stops above it; Medicare doesn't

Feb 1, 2027

W-2s to employees and SSA, Q4 Form 941 and Form 940 due (Jan 31 is a Sunday)

What do you need before your first payday?

Here's the checklist. State registrations take longest, so start there.

Payroll setup checklist

1. Federal registration

  • Get an EIN from the IRS if you don't have one (free online, issued immediately if approved)
  • Enroll in EFTPS or another electronic payment option, because federal payroll deposits must be made electronically

2. State registration

  • Register for state income tax withholding (if your state has an income tax)
  • Register for state unemployment insurance (SUTA) with your state workforce agency
  • Check for local payroll taxes (some cities and counties have them)
  • Buy workers' compensation insurance, which most states require once you have employees

3. Paperwork from each new hire

  • Form W-4 (2026 version) for federal withholding, plus your state's form if it has one
  • Form I-9: employee completes Section 1, you examine their documents and complete Section 2
  • Direct deposit authorization
  • Report the hire to your state's new-hire registry (generally within 20 days)

4. Decisions

  • Pay schedule: weekly, biweekly, semimonthly or monthly (check your state's minimum pay frequency)
  • Exempt or nonexempt for overtime
  • Payroll software or provider, connected to your accounting system
  • Required federal and state workplace posters

Get an EIN

Every employer needs an Employer Identification Number to report employment taxes and give W-2s to employees. If your business already has one, you're set. If you're a sole proprietor who has been using your Social Security number, you'll need an EIN now. Apply directly at IRS.gov. It's free, and a site that charges you for one is just a middleman. (If you have an EIN already and want to sanity-check it, our EIN validator checks the format and prefix.)

Register with your state

This is the step people forget, and it causes the most mail later. Most states need two accounts: one for state income tax withholding (usually the department of revenue) and one for state unemployment insurance (usually the workforce agency, which assigns your rate). A few states have no wage income tax, but every state has unemployment insurance. If your employee works in another state, you'll generally register there too.

Collect the new-hire forms

Form W-4 tells you how much federal income tax to withhold. You keep it on file; it goes to the IRS only if they ask. If a new employee doesn't hand one in, Publication 15 says to withhold as if they checked Single or Married filing separately with no other entries.

Form I-9 proves the person can legally work in the US. The employee completes Section 1, you examine their documents and complete Section 2, and you keep the form. It doesn't go to the government either.

Then report the hire to your state new-hire registry, generally within 20 days (some states want it sooner). A rehire after a break of 60 days or more counts as a new hire again.

Which payroll taxes do you withhold and which do you pay?

Payroll tax is really two piles of money. One you take out of the employee's check and hold in trust. The other comes out of your own pocket.

TaxEmployee pays (withheld)Employer pays2026 limit
Social Security6.2%6.2%First $184,500 of wages
Medicare1.45%1.45%No limit
Additional Medicare0.9% on wages over $200,000NoneWithhold once wages pass $200,000
Federal income taxPer Form W-4 and IRS Pub. 15-TNoneNone
FUTA (federal unemployment)None6.0%, usually 0.6% after state creditFirst $7,000 per employee
State unemployment (SUTA)None in most statesYour assigned rateState wage base
State and local income taxPer state formNoneVaries

FICA is the Social Security and Medicare pair. FUTA is 6.0% on the first $7,000 of wages, but paying your state unemployment tax on time earns a credit of up to 5.4%, so most employers pay 0.6%, or $42 per employee per year (a bit more in "credit reduction" states).

Be careful with the withheld money. It isn't yours, and borrowing it for rent is a fast way for an owner to become personally liable for the tax.

A worked example: what does one employee really cost?

Say you run a small marketing studio and you hire your first employee at a $60,000 salary, paid semimonthly ($2,500 a paycheck). Here's your side of the bill for a full year. The state numbers are made up for illustration, because every state is different.

  • Social Security: 6.2% × $60,000 = $3,720
  • Medicare: 1.45% × $60,000 = $870
  • FUTA: 0.6% × $7,000 = $42
  • State unemployment: say 2.7% on a $10,000 state wage base = $270
  • Workers' comp insurance: say $300 for office work
  • Health insurance contribution: say $500 a month, so $6,000

What a $60,000 employee costs in a year

Hypothetical first hire at a small marketing studio

  • Adds cost
  • Reduces cost
  • Total
$0$20k$40k$60k$80kSalary: $60,000$60kSalarySocial Security (6.2%): +$3,720+$3.7kSocialSecurity(6.2%)Medicare (1.45%): +$870+$870Medicare(1.45%)FUTA (0.6% of $7,000): +$42+$42FUTA (0.6%of $7,000)State unemployment: +$270+$270StateunemploymentWorkers' comp: +$300+$300Workers'compHealth insurance: +$6,000+$6kHealthinsuranceTrue annual cost: $71,202$71kTrue annualcost

Hypothetical example. 60,000 + 3,720 + 870 + 42 + 270 + 300 + 6,000 = 71,202. State unemployment, workers' comp and health insurance vary widely.

Show the numbers
Salary$60,000
Social Security (6.2%)+$3,720
Medicare (1.45%)+$870
FUTA (0.6% of $7,000)+$42
State unemployment+$270
Workers' comp+$300
Health insurance+$6,000
True annual cost$71,202

So the $60,000 hire costs about $71,200, roughly 19% more than the salary (about 9% more without the health insurance), before retirement matching or equipment. Run your own numbers with the payroll cost calculator before you make the offer.

On the employee's side, each $2,500 paycheck has $155.00 of Social Security and $36.25 of Medicare withheld, plus income tax based on their W-4. You send all of it in along with your own share.

How often do you deposit payroll taxes?

This has nothing to do with how often you pay staff. The IRS puts you on a monthly or semiweekly schedule based on the tax you reported in a lookback period.

  • Lookback period: for Form 941 filers, the four quarters from July 1 of the year before last to June 30 of last year. For 2026 that's July 1, 2024 to June 30, 2025. For 2027 it's July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026.
  • $50,000 or less of tax in the lookback period: you're a monthly depositor. Deposit each month's taxes by the 15th of the following month.
  • More than $50,000: you're a semiweekly depositor. Taxes from a Wednesday, Thursday or Friday payday are due the following Wednesday; from a Saturday through Tuesday payday, the following Friday.
  • New employers are monthly depositors for their first calendar year (Form 941 filers).
  • $100,000 next-day rule: if you ever pile up $100,000 or more of tax on a single day, it's due the next business day, and you become a semiweekly depositor.
  • Under $2,500 for the quarter: you can pay with a timely filed Form 941 instead of depositing.

In our studio example, each month's 941 taxes are $765 of Social Security and Medicare (15.3% of $5,000 in wages) plus withheld income tax, say $450, for $1,215 a month and $3,645 a quarter. That's over $2,500, so the studio deposits monthly (January's taxes by February 15). A full year is $14,580, well under $50,000, so it stays monthly.

FUTA is only deposited once the undeposited amount tops $500. At $42 a year, you just pay it with Form 940.

What do you file, and when?

Federal payroll filings for a calendar-year employer
  1. 15th of each month

    Monthly deposit

    Last month's withheld income tax plus both halves of Social Security and Medicare (monthly depositors).

  2. Apr 30, Jul 31, Oct 31

    Form 941

    Quarterly return for Q1, Q2 and Q3. If every deposit was on time, you get 10 extra days to file.

  3. Feb 1, 2027

    Q4 Form 941 and Form 940

    Fourth-quarter 941 and the annual FUTA return for 2026 (January 31 is a Sunday).

  4. Feb 1, 2027

    W-2s and W-3

    Give each employee a W-2 and file the W-2s with Form W-3 at the Social Security Administration.

  5. Ongoing

    State returns

    State withholding and unemployment returns, usually quarterly. Check each state's calendar.

Keep all employment tax records for at least four years: W-4s, payroll registers, deposit confirmations and copies of every return.

Should you run payroll yourself or use a provider?

You can run payroll by hand with IRS Publication 15-T and a spreadsheet. We wouldn't. The math isn't hard; one missed deposit is. Payroll software calculates withholding, makes the deposits, files the returns and produces W-2s, so your job becomes approving each run. Just remember it only knows what you tell it. Set someone up in the wrong state and it will get that wrong perfectly every time.

Common payroll setup mistakes

Paying people before registering with the state. The first state return comes due and you have no account to file under.

Calling an employee a contractor to skip all this. If you control when, where and how someone works, they're very likely an employee. We cover the tests in employee or contractor?.

Forgetting the remote employee's state. Someone working from another state usually means registering, withholding and paying unemployment tax there.

Not reconciling payroll to the books. Each quarter, wages on Form 941 should match wages in your accounting software. Find out why they don't before the W-2s go out.

When should you get help with payroll?

Running payroll yourself through good software is reasonable with one or two salaried employees in one state and simple benefits. Get help when you hire in a second state, add hourly staff with overtime, run benefits through payroll, or get a notice you don't understand. Setup choices follow you for years, so getting them right the first time pays off.

At Fintrix Consulting, payroll sits alongside the monthly books: we prepare each run, you approve it, and payroll is reconciled to the books every month as part of the close. If you'd like to talk it through before your first hire, book a free call.

Frequently asked questions

Can I run payroll without an EIN?

No. You need an EIN to report employment taxes and issue W-2s. It's free from the IRS.

Do I have to pay myself through payroll?

It depends on how your business is taxed. Sole proprietors and partners take draws instead. S corporation owners who work in the business generally need a reasonable salary through payroll. Ask your CPA first.

What's the difference between Form 941 and Form 940?

Form 941 is filed every quarter and reports wages, withheld income tax, and Social Security and Medicare. Form 940 is filed once a year and reports federal unemployment (FUTA) tax, which only the employer pays.

What happens if I miss a payroll tax deposit?

Make it as soon as you notice. The IRS failure to deposit penalty grows the longer the deposit is late, plus interest. Then fix whatever caused it.

The bottom line

Setting up payroll is mostly a matter of order: EIN, state accounts, new-hire paperwork, then a system that deposits and files on time. The federal rules for a new small employer are manageable (monthly deposits, quarterly 941s, W-2s by February 1, 2027 this coming season). Budget for the real cost of a hire, not just the salary, and reconcile payroll to your books every quarter so the year-end forms hold no surprises.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.