Taxes & your CPA
LLC vs S corp: the tax difference for owners, with real numbers
November 18, 2026 · 9 min read

Quick answer
An LLC is a legal entity you form under state law. An S corp is a tax election, and an LLC can make it. Electing S status lets you split profit into a reasonable salary (taxed for Social Security and Medicare) and distributions (not). On $120,000 of profit with a $60,000 salary, our 2026 example saves $7,733 of payroll taxes, but after $3,000 of extra costs and a smaller QBI deduction, the real federal saving is $2,652.
Somebody at a networking event told you to "become an S corp" and save thousands. Your LLC made good money this year, and now you're wondering if you've been overpaying.
Maybe. But the advice you heard skips two things. First, an LLC and an S corp aren't competing options; one is a legal structure and the other is a way of being taxed. Second, the saving is real but smaller than the headline number, because an S corp costs money to run and changes your QBI deduction.
This post runs the actual 2026 numbers on one hypothetical owner, both ways, so you can see where every dollar goes.
Is an LLC different from an S corp?
Yes, and mixing them up causes most of the confusion.
An LLC is a business structure allowed by state law. It's what you file with your state to get liability protection. For federal tax, the IRS uses defaults: a single-member LLC is disregarded (its profit goes on your Schedule C), and an LLC with two or more members is taxed as a partnership.
An [S corporation](/glossary#s-corporation) is a federal tax status. A corporation, or an LLC that's eligible, elects it by filing Form 2553. An eligible LLC that files a timely Form 2553 is treated as a corporation from the election date and generally doesn't need to file Form 8832 as well.
So the real question isn't "LLC or S corp?" It's "should my LLC keep its default tax treatment, or elect to be taxed as an S corp?"
Schedule C
Default (single-member LLC)
- All profit is subject to self-employment tax
- No payroll for the owner; you take draws
- One return: your Form 1040 with Schedule C
- Full profit counts toward the QBI deduction
- Lowest admin cost
Form 1120-S
LLC taxed as an S corp
- Only your salary is subject to Social Security and Medicare
- You must run payroll and pay yourself a reasonable salary
- A separate business return plus a K-1 to you
- Your salary doesn't count toward QBI
- More admin: payroll filings, possibly state fees
Where does the S corp saving come from?
From one tax: Social Security and Medicare.
As a single-member LLC, your whole profit is subject to self-employment tax. The rate is 15.3% (12.4% Social Security plus 2.9% Medicare), applied to 92.35% of your net earnings. The Social Security part stops at the 2026 wage base of $184,500. You get to deduct half of it when figuring income tax.
As an S corp, you're an employee of your own company. Social Security and Medicare (FICA) apply only to your salary: 7.65% withheld from you and 7.65% paid by the company. The rest of the profit passes to you as S corp income on a K-1, and distributions of it aren't subject to those taxes.
That's the whole trick. Everything else is a cost of using it.
A worked example: $120,000 of profit in 2026
Say you run a one-person marketing consultancy as a single-member LLC. In 2026 it makes $120,000 of profit before paying you anything. You file single and have no other income. We'll ignore state taxes for now.
Option A: stay a default LLC.
- Self-employment earnings: $120,000 × 92.35% = $110,820
- Social Security: $110,820 × 12.4% = $13,742
- Medicare: $110,820 × 2.9% = $3,214
- Self-employment tax: $16,955. Half ($8,478) is deductible.
- Adjusted gross income: $120,000 − $8,478 = $111,522
- Less the $16,100 standard deduction: $95,422
- QBI deduction (20% of QBI, capped at 20% of that $95,422): $19,084
- Taxable income $76,338, federal income tax $11,506
Option B: elect S corp, pay yourself a $60,000 salary.
The $60,000 is an assumption for illustration, not a rule. (More on what "reasonable" means below.)
- Your FICA, withheld: $60,000 × 7.65% = $4,590
- Company FICA: $60,000 × 7.65% = $4,590
- Federal unemployment (FUTA): 0.6% of the first $7,000 = $42
- Extra running costs (payroll software, the separate S corp return, state fees), assumed at $3,000 a year
- S corp profit passed to you on the K-1: $120,000 − $60,000 − $4,590 − $42 − $3,000 = $52,368
- Adjusted gross income: $60,000 + $52,368 = $112,368
- Less the standard deduction: $96,268
- QBI deduction: 20% of the $52,368 only = $10,474 (your salary isn't QBI)
- Taxable income $85,794, federal income tax $13,587
Where the money goes: default LLC vs S corp election
Hypothetical consultant, $120,000 profit, single filer, tax year 2026
- Default LLC
- S corp, $60,000 salary
Hypothetical example. S corp Social Security and Medicare includes both halves of FICA ($9,180) plus FUTA ($42). Federal only, rounded to the dollar.
Show the numbers
| Default LLC | S corp, $60,000 salary | |
|---|---|---|
| Social Security and Medicare | $16,955 | $9,222 |
| Federal income tax | $11,506 | $13,587 |
| Extra S corp costs | $0 | $3,000 |
| Default LLC | S corp ($60,000 salary) | |
|---|---|---|
| Self-employment tax or FICA + FUTA | $16,955 | $9,222 |
| Federal income tax | $11,506 | $13,587 |
| Extra running costs (assumed) | $0 | $3,000 |
| Total | $28,461 | $25,809 |
The S corp election saves $7,733 of Social Security and Medicare tax. Take away the $3,000 of extra costs and the $2,081 of extra income tax, and the real saving is $2,652 a year.
Why does income tax go up? Two reasons. Your QBI deduction shrinks from $19,084 to $10,474 because wages don't count as qualified business income. And you lose the deduction for half of self-employment tax, which is only partly made up by the company deducting its half of FICA.
$7,733
Payroll-tax saving in the example
$2,652
What's left after extra costs and a smaller QBI deduction
March 15, 2027
Form 2553 deadline for a calendar-year S corp election for 2027
Is $2,652 worth it? For some owners, yes. For others, not once you count the time spent on payroll filings. At $60,000 of profit, the saving would likely disappear. At $200,000, it would be much bigger. That's why "become an S corp at $X" rules of thumb are rough at best. You can test your own numbers with our self-employment tax calculator.
What counts as a "reasonable" salary?
This is where the IRS pays attention. An S corp must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder who works in the business before taking distributions, and the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages if the salary is too low.
The IRS lists factors courts have used, including:
- your training and experience
- your duties and responsibilities
- time and effort devoted to the business
- what comparable businesses pay for similar services
- what non-shareholder employees are paid
The IRS also points out that profit coming from other people's work or from the company's equipment and capital isn't necessarily your wages. So a solo consultant whose profit comes almost entirely from their own hours has a weaker case for a low salary than an owner managing a team of eight.
Our $60,000 is half the profit, which is a common starting point for discussion, not a safe harbor. There's no IRS percentage. Your CPA should help you set and document a number you'd be comfortable defending.
How and when do you elect S corp status?
You file Form 2553. To take effect for a tax year, it has to be filed no more than 2 months and 15 days after that year begins, or at any time during the year before. For an existing calendar-year LLC that wants S status from January 1, 2027, the deadline is March 15, 2027, and you can file it now.
Every shareholder has to consent, and the business has to meet the S corp eligibility rules in the Form 2553 instructions (limits on the number and type of owners, among others). If you miss the deadline, the instructions describe late-election relief in some cases, generally if you file within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date and had reasonable cause.
Then the real work starts: payroll for yourself from day one, quarterly Form 941 filings, a W-2 at year-end, and an S corp return (Form 1120-S) in March.
Do state taxes change the answer?
They can, a lot. Depending on where you are, your state or city may charge entity-level taxes, annual fees or minimum taxes, and state unemployment tax applies to your salary. State rules on S corps vary. All of this sits outside our example, so treat $2,652 as a federal number only and have your CPA add the state layer before you decide.
Common mistakes
Electing too early. At modest profit, the payroll and return costs eat the saving. Run the numbers first.
Paying no salary at all. Taking only distributions from an S corp where you do the work is exactly what the IRS looks for.
Forgetting the QBI effect. The headline payroll saving is not the real saving, as the example shows.
Running payroll once a year. Reasonable compensation should be paid through regular payroll with deposits and quarterly filings, not as one December entry.
Mixing distributions and expenses. Distributions are equity, not costs. If they land in an expense account, your profit, your QBI and your K-1 are all wrong.
When should you get help?
If your profit is steady and comfortably above what you'd pay yourself as a salary, it's worth a proper look. If it's lumpy or modest, the default LLC is usually simpler and nearly as cheap.
Either way, the decision is your CPA's to model with you, and it needs clean books to start from. Fintrix Consulting keeps those books and can run your payroll, and our tax support service gets everything ready for the CPA who files your returns. For the next step after electing, read how to pay yourself from an LLC or S corp.
Frequently asked questions
Can a single-member LLC be an S corp?
Yes. An eligible LLC, including a single-member LLC, can elect to be taxed as an S corporation by filing Form 2553. It stays an LLC under state law.
At what profit does an S corp make sense?
There's no fixed number. It depends on what salary is reasonable for your work, your state's taxes and fees, your extra costs and the QBI effect. In our example, $120,000 of profit with a $60,000 salary saved $2,652 federally.
Can I just pay myself a very low salary?
Not safely. The IRS requires reasonable compensation for the services you provide and can reclassify distributions as wages, with back payroll taxes and penalties.
What's the deadline to become an S corp for 2027?
For a calendar-year business, file Form 2553 by March 15, 2027, or any time during 2026.
Does an S corp get rid of self-employment tax?
It replaces self-employment tax on your salary with regular payroll taxes (FICA). Profit you take as distributions isn't subject to either, which is where the saving comes from.
The bottom line
An LLC is how your business exists. An S corp election is how it can be taxed. The election saves Social Security and Medicare tax on the profit above a reasonable salary, but payroll, a second return and a smaller QBI deduction take a real bite. In our 2026 example that turned a $7,733 headline into $2,652. Run your own numbers with your CPA, including your state, before March 15.
Sources
- Limited liability company (LLC) (IRS)
- Instructions for Form 2553 (IRS)
- S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues (IRS)
- Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes) (IRS)
- Topic no. 554, Self-employment tax (IRS)
- Topic no. 759, Form 940 (FUTA) (IRS)
- Revenue Procedure 2025-32, 2026 inflation adjustments (IRS)
- IRS releases tax inflation adjustments for tax year 2026 (IRS)
- Qualified business income deduction (IRS)
- Paying yourself (IRS)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Behind on taxes? How catch-up bookkeeping gets you compliant
November 19, 2026
- Deducting business meals: the rules for 2026
November 19, 2026
- Business mileage: IRS rates and a log that holds up
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.