Fintrix Consulting LLC

Bookkeeping

10 signs your books are wrong, and what to do next

November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Hand holding a magnifying glass over a printed balance sheet on a wooden table
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Your books are probably wrong if the cash balance in your software doesn't match the bank, if any account shows a balance that can't exist (negative cash, negative receivables), or if holding accounts like Undeposited Funds, Uncategorized or Ask My Accountant keep growing. Tax and payroll liabilities that don't match what you filed and paid are the other big tell. Start by reconciling cash, then work outward.

You open your accounting software to check one number before a meeting with the bank. The cash balance says $61,400. Your bank app says $50,250. You tell yourself it's probably timing, close the laptop, and go to the meeting with the bigger number in your head.

That moment is usually the first visible symptom of books that have drifted. Wrong books rarely look wrong. The reports still run, the P&L still shows a profit, nothing turns red. You find out when a lender, your CPA or a sales tax notice asks a question the numbers can't answer.

Below are ten specific signs, a worked example of how a $14,050 gap built up in one business, and the order to fix things in.

$0

What your unreconciled difference should be at every month end

Zero

The balance Uncategorized and Ask My Accountant should carry once a month is closed

4 years

How long the IRS says to keep employment tax records, at minimum

Why do small errors in the books turn into big ones?

Because in double-entry bookkeeping every wrong entry has a matching wrong entry elsewhere. A deposit recorded twice inflates cash and revenue. The reports still balance, so nothing looks broken. And errors stack: by summer nobody can say which month started it. That's why the first sign below matters more than the other nine combined.

The 10 signs your books are wrong

1. The cash balance doesn't match the bank

Your software's balance on the last day of the month should equal the bank statement, minus checks that haven't cleared and plus deposits in transit. If you can't explain the difference with a short list of specific items, something is missing or duplicated. A bank reconciliation is how you prove it. If the account hasn't been reconciled in months, that alone is a sign.

2. An account shows a balance that can't exist

Negative cash in an account the bank never let you overdraw. Negative accounts receivable, as if customers paid more than you billed. These almost always come from payments recorded without their invoice or bill, or recorded twice.

3. Undeposited Funds keeps growing

Undeposited Funds is a temporary holding account for customer payments you plan to deposit together (QuickBooks lets you rename it, so yours may show a different name). When it holds thousands of dollars from months ago, payments were usually received on invoices and then the matching bank deposit was added again from the bank feed as new income. Revenue is overstated by whatever is stuck there.

4. Uncategorized, Suspense or Ask My Accountant has a balance

At month end these accounts should be zero. If Uncategorized Expense holds $9,420, your expense lines are understated by $9,420, and any margin built on them is fiction.

5. Sales tax payable doesn't match your returns

Compare the sales tax liability account to the returns you filed and the payments you made. After the last payment, it should hold only what you collected since. If it holds more, you may have under-remitted. If it's negative, payments were probably coded to the liability without the tax that created it ever being recorded.

6. Payroll liabilities never clear

When payroll runs, withheld taxes and the employer share go into liability accounts. When the payroll provider pays them, those accounts should fall back to near zero. If payroll tax payable climbs every quarter, payments are being coded to an expense (double counting payroll tax) or they aren't being made. Compare the accounts to each quarter's Form 941 and your provider's tax payment reports.

7. Personal spending runs through the business

Groceries, a family vacation, a personal car payment, all coded to "office supplies" or "travel." This understates profit and creates tax risk, because the IRS expects you to back up every deduction. Personal items belong in an owner's draw or distribution account, never in an expense.

8. Gross margin jumps around for no reason

If gross margin is 41% in May, 19% in June and 56% in July with no change in pricing or suppliers, costs are landing in the wrong months or lines. Usually it's bills recorded when paid instead of when received.

9. Loan balances don't match the lender

Each loan payment has an interest part (an expense) and a principal part (reduces the loan). If the whole payment was expensed, the loan never goes down and profit is understated. If nothing was recorded, both cash and the loan are too high.

10. Your CPA keeps sending the same questions

"What's this $12,000 in Opening Balance Equity?" "Why did retained earnings change from last year's return?" If your tax preparer makes big adjusting entries every year, and the same ones come back the next year, the fixes aren't making it into the books.

A quick self-check you can do in 30 minutes

Open last month's balance sheet and your bank and card statements, and go down the list.

Are my books right? A month-end self-check

Cash

  • Every bank and credit card account is reconciled through last month
  • The reconciled balance equals the statement balance, with only a few dated timing items in between
  • No account shows a balance the bank would never allow

Holding accounts

  • Undeposited Funds holds only payments from the last few days
  • Uncategorized Income, Uncategorized Expense, Suspense and Ask My Accountant are all zero
  • Opening Balance Equity is zero, or your accountant knows exactly why it isn't

Customers and suppliers

  • Accounts receivable isn't negative, and nothing on the aging report is a year old
  • Accounts payable doesn't show bills you know you've paid

Taxes and payroll

  • Sales tax payable equals tax collected since your last payment
  • Payroll liabilities are close to zero after each tax payment
  • Payroll expense for the quarter ties to your payroll provider's reports

Owner and loans

  • Personal purchases sit in owner's draw or distributions, not in expenses
  • Each loan balance matches the lender's latest statement

Two or three misses are normal and fixable in an afternoon. If you're missing most of the cash section, start there.

A worked example: where a $14,050 gap came from

Say you run a landscaping business with two crews. Your QuickBooks file shows $61,400 in checking at the end of September. The bank statement says $50,250. You finally reconcile, and here's what turns up:

What the reconciliation foundEffect on the book balanceWhat actually happened
Customer deposits recorded twice−$7,800Payments were applied to invoices, then the same deposits were added from the feed as new income
Equipment loan auto-payments never recorded−$3,600Three monthly payments of $1,200 left the account, nothing was entered
Processing and bank fees never recorded−$1,150Fees came out of deposits, but only the gross amount was booked
Personal purchases on the business debit card−$1,500Never entered at all
Checks written but not yet cleared+$2,900Normal timing. Correct in the books; the bank just hasn't seen them yet

From the book balance to the bank statement

A hypothetical landscaping business, September checking account

  • Raises balance
  • Lowers balance
  • Total
$0$20k$40k$60k$80kBalance in the books: $61,400$61kBalance inthe booksDeposits recorded twice: −$7,800−$7.8kDepositsrecordedtwiceLoan payments missing: −$3,600−$3.6kLoanpaymentsmissingFees not recorded: −$1,150−$1.1kFees notrecordedPersonal purchases: −$1,500−$1.5kPersonalpurchasesChecks not yet cleared: +$2,900+$2.9kChecks notyet clearedBank statement balance: $50,250$50kBankstatementbalance

Hypothetical example. 61,400 − 7,800 − 3,600 − 1,150 − 1,500 + 2,900 = 50,250.

Show the numbers
Balance in the books$61,400
Deposits recorded twice−$7,800
Loan payments missing−$3,600
Fees not recorded−$1,150
Personal purchases−$1,500
Checks not yet cleared+$2,900
Bank statement balance$50,250

Only one line is a legitimate timing difference. The other four are real errors totaling $14,050, and after fixing them the correct book balance is $47,350 (the bank's $50,250 less the $2,900 of checks still to clear).

And cash is only the visible part. Revenue was overstated by $7,800, expenses missed the fees and loan interest, the loan balance was too high by the principal paid, and $1,500 of personal spending was neither an expense nor a draw. One unreconciled account had bent the P&L, the balance sheet and owner's equity at once.

What should you do first?

Work in this order, because each step changes the numbers underneath the next one.

  1. Reconcile every bank and card account, oldest unreconciled month first. Get each one to a zero difference. Intuit's own help notes that a balance that won't match on a first reconciliation is often an incorrect opening balance, so check that entry before chasing anything else.
  2. Clear the holding accounts. Match each item in Undeposited Funds to a real deposit, then empty Uncategorized and Ask My Accountant one transaction at a time.
  3. Tie out the liabilities. Sales tax, payroll and loans, against filings, provider reports and lender statements.
  4. Fix customers and suppliers. Match stray payments to invoices and bills, and delete true duplicates.
  5. Review the P&L by month. Now that the base is right, look for months that don't make sense.
  6. Lock the periods you've fixed so they don't drift again.

If you're more than a couple of months behind, this becomes a project rather than a weekend task. Our cleanup plan for months of unreconciled books covers that case, and catch-up vs cleanup bookkeeping explains the difference between books that are late and books that are wrong.

Common mistakes when fixing wrong books

Plugging the difference. One "reconciliation adjustment" to force a match buries the real errors, and usually distorts profit too.

Deleting transactions you didn't create. A deposit that looks like a duplicate might be the only record of a real sale. Check the statement first.

Fixing closed years in place. If your CPA already filed a return from those numbers, changing prior-year balances means the books no longer match the return. Ask your CPA first; they may want the correction recorded in the current year.

Starting with the P&L. Until cash is reconciled, every fix you make there can be undone by what the bank reconciliation turns up.

When should you get help?

If the self-check came back mostly clean, fix the stray items yourself. That's a normal month.

Get help when cash hasn't been reconciled for several months, when payroll or sales tax liabilities don't tie to filings (penalties and interest keep growing while you work it out), when a loan application or tax return is coming up, or when you've tried twice and the difference keeps moving.

Fintrix Consulting does this kind of cleanup and monthly bookkeeping in QuickBooks Online and Xero, with catch-up work priced separately from the monthly fee. If you'd like someone to look at your file first, you can book a free call.

Frequently asked questions

Is a small difference in my bank reconciliation OK?

No. A $40 difference can be two errors of $2,000 that almost cancel out. The target is zero, with any timing items listed individually.

What is Opening Balance Equity, and why does my CPA ask about it?

It's an account QuickBooks uses when you enter starting balances. It should be moved to owner's equity once setup is done. A balance there that keeps changing usually means someone is adjusting starting balances to force reconciliations to work.

Can I fix last year's books after my tax return is filed?

You can, but don't change the filed year quietly. Ask your CPA how to record the correction. Often it goes in the current year, and if the error changed taxable income, your CPA can tell you whether an amended return makes sense.

My software says everything is reconciled. Can the books still be wrong?

Yes. Reconciliation proves the cash is right, not that every transaction is in the right category or month. A reconciled file can still have personal spending in expenses or bills in the wrong period.

The bottom line

Wrong books rarely announce themselves. They show up as a cash balance you can't explain, an account holding a number it shouldn't, or a liability that never goes down. Run the self-check once a month, fix cash before anything else, and don't plug differences you can't explain. If the list is long or involves tax, get help before the next filing deadline rather than after it.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.