Taxes & your CPA
Why your tax bill surprises you every year (and how to stop it)
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Your tax is based on your business's profit, not on the cash you have left. Owner draws, loan principal and inventory you haven't sold yet all take cash without reducing taxable profit, so the bill looks too big for the bank balance. Add estimated payments set from old numbers, a big write-off in an earlier year and books that are months behind, and April becomes a surprise. The fix is quarterly: current books, a fresh estimate, and payments that meet the safe harbor.
Every spring it's the same conversation. Your CPA sends the numbers, the business owes far more than you expected, and you're sure there's a mistake because the bank account never looked that healthy. Usually there's no mistake. The tax was always going to be that size. You just couldn't see it coming.
The good news is that the surprise is almost always fixable, and most of the fix happens in the business's books, not in the tax return. This post covers the six reasons the bill keeps catching owners off guard, a worked example with the numbers, and what to do before the January 15, 2027 estimated payment for tax year 2026.
Jan 15, 2027
Fourth 2026 estimated tax payment due (IRS Pub. 505)
100% / 110%
Prior-year safe harbor: 110% if 2025 AGI was over $150,000
90%
Current-year safe harbor: 90% of your 2026 tax
Why is my tax bill higher than the cash I have?
Because you're taxed on profit, and a lot of things take cash without reducing profit. We cover the full gap between the two in cash flow vs profit. For taxes, these are the ones that bite:
| What happened | Cash | Taxable profit |
|---|---|---|
| You took owner draws | Down | No change: IRS Pub. 334 says you can't deduct your own salary or personal withdrawals as a sole proprietor |
| You paid down a loan | Down by the full payment | Only the interest is deductible; the principal is repaying money that was never income |
| You bought inventory you haven't sold | Down | No change until it's sold and becomes cost of goods sold |
| You bought equipment in an earlier year and wrote it all off then | Loan payments continue | No deduction left this year |
| Customers owe you (accrual books) | No change yet | Up, once invoiced |
None of these are loopholes or errors. They're how taxable income works. But if you judge the year by the bank balance, every one of them makes the tax look unfair.
A worked example: $148,000 of profit, $21,000 more cash
Say you run a single-member LLC that sells outdoor gear online and through two local shops. You file as a sole proprietor. In 2026:
- Net profit on the books: $148,000.
- You took $72,000 in owner draws to live on. Draws aren't an expense (see owner's draw).
- You paid $18,000 of principal on the loan for a van you bought in 2025. If you took 100% bonus depreciation on the van in 2025, the whole cost was deducted that year, so 2026 gets the loan payments and none of the deduction.
- You stocked up for spring: $25,000 of inventory is still on the shelves at year-end.
- You paid $12,000 of estimated tax ($4,000 in April, June and September).
From 2026 taxable profit to the change in cash
Hypothetical online and wholesale outdoor gear seller, single-member LLC
- Adds cash
- Uses cash
- Total
Hypothetical example. 148,000 − 72,000 − 18,000 − 25,000 − 12,000 = 21,000.
Show the numbers
| Net profit | $148,000 |
| Owner draws | −$72,000 |
| Van loan principal | −$18,000 |
| Inventory not yet sold | −$25,000 |
| Estimated tax paid | −$12,000 |
| Change in cash | $21,000 |
So the bank balance rose by $21,000 and it felt like a modest year. But tax is figured on the $148,000.
Here's the rough federal math, simplified (single filer, no other income, standard deduction, no state tax):
- Self-employment tax: $148,000 × 92.35% × 15.3% = about $20,900 (IRS Topic 554).
- Income tax: after half the SE tax, the $16,100 standard deduction and the 20% qualified business income deduction, taxable income is about $97,200, which is about $16,100 of tax at 2026 rates.
- Total: about $37,000. Paid so far: $12,000. Still to pay: about $25,000.
The owner set the $4,000 quarterly payments from a year when profit was lower. Their 2025 tax was $21,000. That's the next problem.
Are you paying enough estimated tax to avoid a penalty?
If you expect to owe $1,000 or more, the IRS expects you to pay during the year, through withholding or quarterly estimated payments. For 2026, IRS Pub. 505 says the required amount is the smaller of:
- 90% of your 2026 tax, or
- 100% of the tax on your 2025 return (110% if your 2025 AGI was more than $150,000, or $75,000 if married filing separately).
That's the safe harbor: pay at least that much, on time, and there's no underpayment penalty even if you owe more in April. The glossary has a short entry on the safe harbor.
In the example, 100% of the 2025 tax is $21,000, so each quarterly installment should have been $5,250. The owner paid $4,000.
2026 estimated payments vs the prior-year safe harbor
Same hypothetical seller: 2025 tax was $21,000, so $5,250 a quarter
- Safe harbor installment
- Paid or planned
Hypothetical example. Paying $9,000 on January 15, 2027 brings the total to $21,000.
Show the numbers
| Safe harbor installment | Paid or planned | |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 15, 2026 | $5,250 | $4,000 |
| Jun 15, 2026 | $5,250 | $4,000 |
| Sep 15, 2026 | $5,250 | $4,000 |
| Jan 15, 2027 | $5,250 | $9,000 |
Paying $9,000 by January 15, 2027 gets the total to $21,000. That cuts the penalty a lot, but doesn't erase it. The Form 2210 instructions say the penalty is figured separately for each installment due date, so the $1,250 shortfall in each of the first three quarters still carries a small charge for the months it was late. The IRS describes the penalty as based on the amount underpaid, how long, and its published quarterly interest rates.
Pub. 505 also has an exception: if you file your 2026 return and pay all the tax you owe by January 31, 2027, you don't need to make the January 15 payment. Realistic only if your books are closed early.
Why does April 2027 hurt twice?
This is the part that catches owners who did nothing "wrong". On April 15, 2027, the seller owes:
- the rest of the 2026 tax: about $37,000 − $21,000 = $16,000, and
- the first 2027 estimated payment. Their 2026 AGI is under $150,000, so the safe harbor is 100% of the 2026 tax: $37,000 ÷ 4 = $9,250.
That's about $25,250 on a single day. If you've been setting aside cash at last year's rate, you won't have it. Seeing this in November is the whole point: you have five months to put the money aside.
What else makes the bill jump?
Books that are months behind. If November's books aren't done until March, your CPA can't plan anything in time. Year-end moves (buying equipment, paying a bonus, a retirement contribution) only work before December 31.
Mixing personal and business spending. Personal charges on the business card get pulled out at tax time, and profit goes up. Business expenses paid from a personal card often never make it into the books.
A big deduction last year, none this year. The 2025 tax law made 100% bonus depreciation permanent for property acquired after January 19, 2025 (IRS, Working Families Tax Cuts). Great in the year you buy. But it pulls the deduction forward, so the next year looks more profitable by comparison.
Growth. With progressive brackets, profit up 50% can mean income tax up by more than 50%, especially once you climb a bracket.
Inventory build-ups. Buying ahead for the next season moves cash out in December and the deduction into next year, when the stock sells.
How do you stop being surprised?
Make taxes a quarterly habit instead of an annual event.
Each month
Close the books
Reconcile bank and card accounts, record draws separately from expenses, and split loan payments into principal and interest.
Two weeks before each due date
Re-estimate
Year-to-date profit, a projection for the full year, and the safe harbor amount. Adjust the next payment up or down.
Apr 15, Jun 15, Sep 15, Jan 15
Pay
Make the estimated payment (2026's last one is January 15, 2027). Move a set percentage of profit into a tax savings account every month.
November
Year-end planning call
Look at full-year profit with your CPA while there's still time to act: equipment, retirement contributions, bonuses, and the January payment.
The quarterly estimated tax calculator does the safe harbor math using 2026 rates. If you're a sole proprietor or LLC owner, the self-employment tax calculator shows how much of the bill is Social Security and Medicare.
Common mistakes
Setting estimates once and forgetting them. Basing payments on last year's tax works for the safe harbor only if you pay the full 100% (or 110%) of it, on time. Paying "about the same as last year" without checking is how people end up short.
Saving for tax out of whatever is left. Owners who move a fixed share of profit into a separate account each month rarely get surprised. Owners who pay tax from the operating account usually do.
Treating draws as salary. For a sole proprietor or partner, draws aren't deductible. If you want to compare the S corp route, see how to pay yourself.
Booking loan payments as an expense. It overstates expenses all year, then your CPA corrects it and profit jumps.
Waiting for the CPA to find problems in March. By then, the only options left are paying and filing an extension.
When to get help
If you're a sole proprietor with steady profit, clean books and the same income as last year, paying 100% (or 110%) of last year's tax in four equal installments is simple, and you can do it yourself.
Get help when profit is growing fast, when the books are more than a month behind, when you're switching to an S corp or adding owners, or when you've had an underpayment penalty before. A CPA files the return and gives tax advice. A bookkeeper or tax preparation support team keeps the books current enough for the quarterly re-estimate to mean something. Fintrix Consulting does the second part and works alongside your CPA.
Frequently asked questions
Can I still fix my 2026 estimated payments?
Partly. The January 15, 2027 payment can bring your total up to the safe harbor and cut the penalty. Because the penalty is figured separately for each installment, shortfalls in earlier quarters may still cost a little, but paying now stops them growing.
How much should I set aside for taxes?
It depends on your profit, filing status and state. Rather than a rule of thumb, run your year-to-date numbers through a calculator or have your CPA give you a percentage, then move that share of profit to a tax account every month.
Do I pay tax on money I left in the business?
For a sole proprietorship, partnership or S corporation, yes. Profit is taxed to the owners whether or not it's withdrawn. That's why a growing business with little cash can still owe a lot.
Is the underpayment penalty large?
Usually it's modest, because it works like interest on the amount underpaid for the time it was late, using the IRS's quarterly rates. The bigger problem is the lump sum due in April, not the penalty.
Does bonus depreciation lower my taxes?
It moves the deduction earlier. You deduct the full cost of qualifying equipment in the year you buy it instead of over several years. Total deductions over time are the same, so later years have less to deduct.
The bottom line
Your tax bill isn't based on what's in the bank. Draws, loan principal, unsold inventory and last year's big write-off all make profit higher than cash suggests. Keep the books current, re-estimate every quarter, and pay at least the safe harbor on time. For 2026, that means checking your numbers now and making the January 15, 2027 payment count, then planning for a heavier April.
Sources
- Publication 505 (2026), Tax Withholding and Estimated Tax (IRS)
- Underpayment of estimated tax by individuals penalty (IRS)
- Instructions for Form 2210 (IRS)
- Estimated taxes (IRS)
- Estimated tax, individuals: payment due dates (IRS FAQ)
- Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business (IRS)
- Working Families Tax Cuts: business provisions (IRS)
- Topic no. 554, Self-employment tax (IRS)
- Revenue Procedure 2025-32, 2026 inflation adjustments (IRS)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- How your bookkeeper and CPA should work together
November 18, 2026
- Business tax prep checklist: the documents your CPA needs
November 18, 2026
- How to pay yourself from an LLC or S corp
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.