Fintrix Consulting LLC

Free tools · Costs & decisions

Outsourced vs in-house accounting cost

A salary is only part of what an in-house finance hire costs. Add the payroll taxes, benefits, hiring, tools and your own time, then compare it with an outsourced quote.

← All free tools

Your numbers

In-house team

Example values throughout: replace them with salaries and quotes for your area.

$
$
$
$

Your state sets your rate and wage base. Federal taxes are worked out for you.

%

Health insurance, retirement match, paid leave you'd pay for.

$

Job ads, recruiter fees, training time, spread over a typical year.

$
$
$

Temp help or overtime when someone is out or leaves.

Outsourced

$

Example value: enter a real quote for the same scope of work.

Outsourcing would cost less by

$186,107 a year

In-house $236,507 vs outsourced $50,400

In-house, per year

$236,507

2 people, salaries $165,000

Outsourced, per year

$50,400

Fee plus your remaining time

Yearly cost side by side

In-house team$236,507
Outsourced$50,400
In-house costPer year
Salaries$165,000
Employer payroll taxes (Social Security, Medicare, FUTA, state)$13,307
Benefits$33,000
Recruiting and onboarding$8,000
Software and equipment$5,000
Your management time$7,200
Cover for leave and turnover$5,000
Total in-house$236,507

What the numbers don't show

In-houseOutsourced
When someone leaves or is outWork stops until you hire or coverThe firm reassigns the work
Second pair of eyes on the workOnly if you hire someone senior to reviewUsually built in: ask who reviews
Scaling up or downHiring and letting go take monthsChange the scope with notice
Knowing the business day to dayStrongest: they sit with your teamDepends on how often you talk
Control over prioritiesFullAgreed in the engagement

Everything you type stays in your browser: nothing is sent to us or saved.

How this works

For each in-house role you enter a headcount and a salary. The calculator adds the employer's share of 2026 payroll taxes: 6.2% Social Security on wages up to $184,500, 1.45% Medicare on all wages, and federal unemployment tax of 0.6% on the first $7,000 per person. State unemployment tax varies by state and by employer, so you enter your own.

Then come the costs people forget: benefits, recruiting and onboarding, a laptop and software seat, cover when someone is out or leaves, and the hours you spend managing the team. Small numbers individually, but they add up.

On the outsourced side, enter a real monthly fee you've been quoted for the same scope of work, plus the hours you'd still spend answering questions and approving things. We don't fill in a default fee because prices depend on volume and complexity.

The table at the bottom covers what money doesn't: continuity, review, flexibility and day-to-day knowledge of the business. Plenty of companies end up with a mix, such as an in-house bookkeeper with outside help for the close and reporting.

Questions people ask

How much does an employee cost on top of salary?

Employer payroll taxes alone add 7.65% up to the Social Security wage base, plus federal and state unemployment tax. Benefits, equipment and hiring costs come on top. Run the payroll cost calculator for one role in detail.

Where do I find realistic salaries?

Job ads for similar roles in your area, recruiter quotes and salary surveys. Use what you'd actually need to pay to hire someone good, not the lowest figure you've seen.

When does in-house make more sense?

When there's a full-time workload that needs someone on site, deep knowledge of daily operations, or immediate turnaround. Many growing businesses keep one person in-house and outsource the review, close and reporting around them.

What should I compare in an outsourced quote?

What's included each month, when you get your statements, who reviews the work, response times, and what happens if your needs change. If you want a quote to compare, Fintrix Consulting can provide one.

This tool gives estimates for general information, not tax, legal or accounting advice for your situation. Talk to us or your CPA before acting on the results.

Related tools

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.