Accounting standards
Found a mistake in last year's books? Errors vs changes in estimate
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Under ASC 250, it depends on what caused the difference. If last year's number was wrong because someone missed or misused information that existed at the time, it's an error: material errors are fixed by restating the prior year (reissuing it, or flagging it the next time it's presented), and small ones can be corrected in the current period. If the number was a reasonable estimate and new information has changed it, that's a change in estimate: you adjust this year and going forward, and never restate.
It's March. Last year's financial statements went to the bank in February, and now your bookkeeper finds a $90,000 supplier invoice from December that never got recorded. The same week, your operations manager says the delivery trucks you're depreciating over five years will clearly last seven. And a customer who owed you $40,000 has just filed for bankruptcy.
All three change last year's picture. Only one of them means going back and fixing last year.
The rules for telling them apart sit in ASC 250, Accounting Changes and Error Corrections. Here's how it sorts things out, what each path looks like in the books, and a worked example with all three.
What counts as an accounting error?
An error is a mistake in recognition, measurement, presentation or disclosure in statements you've already issued. BDO's guide lists the usual causes: arithmetic mistakes, misapplying GAAP, and oversight or misuse of facts that existed when the statements were prepared.
That last one is the line that matters most for small businesses. If the information was available when you closed the books and it wasn't used, it's an error, even if the number was technically "an estimate." BDO is explicit that using outdated information when newer data existed is an error, not a change in estimate.
Two other things that look like something else but are errors:
- Moving from a non-GAAP method to GAAP. If you were booking revenue on a cash basis inside accrual statements and fix it, that's an error correction, not a change in accounting principle.
- Many "reclassifications." Shifting an amount between lines just for presentation isn't an error. But if the original classification broke GAAP (for example, reporting revenue gross when it should be net), the fix is an error correction.
What counts as a change in estimate?
A lot of accounting is estimating: how long equipment will last, how much of your receivables you'll collect, which inventory won't sell. Those estimates get updated as you learn more. Per PwC's guide, a change in estimate results from new information or revised estimating techniques, and it's accounted for prospectively: in the period of the change and in future periods if they're affected. Prior periods aren't restated (ASC 250-10-45-17).
The test is whether the earlier estimate was reasonable given what you knew. If it was, and something new has happened since, you're changing an estimate. Keep the evidence: PwC notes the change should rest on facts or circumstances from the period it was made.
And a change in accounting principle?
That's a third category: switching from one acceptable GAAP method to another, like FIFO to weighted average for inventory. A voluntary change has to be preferable, and you explain why. It's generally applied retrospectively: prior periods presented are adjusted, with the cumulative effect going to opening retained earnings of the earliest period shown, unless that's impracticable.
New accounting standards usually come with their own transition rules, which override ASC 250's default. (Our roundup of new accounting standards for 2026 and 2027 covers the current ones.)
One hybrid: a change in depreciation method (say, accelerated to straight line) is treated as a change in estimate effected by a change in principle. It's handled prospectively like an estimate, but it still has to be preferable and gets both sets of disclosures.
Look back
Error correction
- Information existed and wasn't used, or GAAP was misapplied
- Material: restate prior periods
- Not material: correct in the current period
- Disclose the nature and effect of the error
Look forward
Change in estimate
- New information or experience
- Adjust current and future periods
- Never restate
- Disclose the effect if material, or if it will be later
Look back
Change in principle
- Switch between acceptable GAAP methods
- Voluntary change must be preferable
- Generally retrospective, cumulative effect to opening retained earnings
- New ASUs follow their own transition rules
How do you correct an error: restate, revise or just fix it?
The answer turns on materiality, judged on both amounts and qualitative factors. PwC's guide describes three routes for private companies:
- Restatement (the "Big R"). The error is material to the prior year's statements. Those statements can't be relied on anymore, so you correct them, usually by reissuing them labeled "as restated" (with a reissued report if a CPA reviewed or audited them), or by reflecting the restatement in the next comparative statements. Anyone who received the old statements needs to be told not to rely on them.
- Revision (the "little r"). The error isn't material to the prior year, but fixing it all in the current year would make this year materially wrong. You revise the prior year numbers the next time they're presented and disclose it. Old statements don't need reissuing, and they aren't labeled "as restated."
- Out-of-period adjustment. The error is immaterial to both years. You correct it in the current period, with disclosure where appropriate.
A worked example: one distributor, three surprises
Say you run a building supplies distributor organized as an S corporation, so there's no company-level income tax to complicate things. Your 2025 statements, issued to the bank in February 2026, showed net income of $600,000 and retained earnings of $1,450,000 at December 31, 2025. In March 2026 you learn three things.
1. The missed invoice: an error. A $90,000 supplier invoice for goods sold in December 2025 was never accrued. It got paid in February 2026 and was booked as a 2026 cost of sales. The information existed at year end; it just wasn't recorded. At 15% of net income, assume your CPA agrees it's material, so 2025 is restated.
2025 net income, as reported to restated
- Increase
- Reduces income
- Total
Hypothetical example. S corporation, so no income tax effect.
Show the numbers
| As reported | $600,000 |
| Missed supplier bill | −$90,000 |
| As restated | $510,000 |
| Line item, 2025 | As reported | Correction | As restated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost of sales | $4,100,000 | +$90,000 | $4,190,000 |
| Net income | $600,000 | ($90,000) | $510,000 |
| Accrued liabilities, Dec 31 | $210,000 | +$90,000 | $300,000 |
| Retained earnings, Dec 31 | $1,450,000 | ($90,000) | $1,360,000 |
In the 2026 books, the cost is sitting in the wrong year. The correcting adjusting entry moves it: debit opening retained earnings $90,000, credit 2026 cost of sales $90,000. Without it, 2026 profit would be understated by the same $90,000 that 2025 was overstated.
2. The trucks: a change in estimate. You bought a delivery fleet for $420,000 in January 2024, depreciated straight line over five years with no salvage value: $84,000 a year. After two years ($168,000 of accumulated depreciation), maintenance data shows the trucks will last seven years in total. The remaining $252,000 is spread over the five years left: $50,400 a year from 2026. Nothing about 2024 or 2025 changes, because the five-year estimate was reasonable when you made it.
Truck depreciation by year
$420,000 fleet bought January 2024, useful life revised in 2026
- Original 5-year life
- Revised to 7 years
Hypothetical example. Prior years stay as reported; 2026 expense falls by $33,600.
Show the numbers
| Original 5-year life | Revised to 7 years | |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | $84,000 | $84,000 |
| 2025 | $84,000 | $84,000 |
| 2026 | $84,000 | $50,400 |
| 2027 | $84,000 | $50,400 |
| 2028 | $84,000 | $50,400 |
Because a useful life change affects several future periods, ASC 250-10-50-4 asks you to disclose its effect on the current year's income. Here that's $33,600.
3. The bankrupt customer: it depends on when you knew. At year end you'd reserved $15,000 against receivables. The $40,000 customer filed for bankruptcy in February 2026, with no warning signs in December. That's new information, so the extra write-off goes through 2026 as a change in estimate. But change one fact: if the customer had filed in November 2025 and the notice was sitting in someone's inbox at close, ignoring it would make the year-end reserve an error.
Common mistakes
Calling an error an estimate to avoid restating. "We estimated low" doesn't work when the invoice, the bankruptcy notice or the count sheet was available at close. Reviewers ask what was known and when.
Burying a prior-year error in this year's expenses. Booking last year's missed invoice as this year's cost makes both years wrong, and it can make this year's margins look like a trend that isn't real.
Restating for a change in estimate. Going back to rerun 2024 and 2025 depreciation at seven years is wrong. Estimates move forward only.
Forgetting the people who got the old statements. If a material error means restating, the bank and anyone else relying on the old statements needs to be told. Check your loan agreement too: a restatement can affect covenant calculations and reporting obligations.
Assuming the tax return follows automatically. A book correction doesn't amend a tax return. If the error changed taxable income, ask your CPA whether an amended return is needed.
When should you get help?
If your statements are internal only and the error is small, fixing it in the current month with a clear note in the file is usually fine. Once statements have gone to a lender, investor or buyer, or a CPA has reviewed or audited them (see audit, review or compilation), materiality is a judgment your CPA or auditor should make with you, and the disclosure needs care.
The cheaper fix is not needing one. Monthly reconciliations, accruals for invoices that arrive late, and a second set of eyes on every close catch most of these before statements go out. That's how Fintrix Consulting runs monthly accounting: a qualified professional who didn't prepare the work reviews every close. If your books already have problems spread over several years, our post on signs your books are wrong is a good place to start.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between a restatement and a revision?
A restatement ("Big R") corrects an error that was material to the prior statements, which can no longer be relied on and are relabeled "as restated." A revision ("little r") corrects an error that wasn't material to the prior year but would distort the current year if booked there all at once, so the prior figures are revised the next time they're shown.
Is changing a useful life ever an error?
Yes, if the original life was unreasonable based on information available at the time, or if you simply used the wrong life. If the original estimate was reasonable and new experience changed it, it's a change in estimate.
Do I have to restate if my statements are only used internally?
ASC 250 applies to GAAP statements whoever reads them, but materiality depends on the users. For internal management reports, most owners just correct the current period and note it. Once outsiders rely on the statements, follow the ASC 250 route.
Does a change in estimate need a disclosure?
Routine estimates made every period, like bad debts or inventory obsolescence, need disclosure only if the effect is material. A change that affects several future periods, like a useful life, gets its effect on current year income disclosed.
Where does a prior-year error correction go in the current books?
To opening retained earnings, not to current year income. That keeps the current year's profit clean and puts the correction where it belongs.
The bottom line
Ask one question first: was the information available when the books were closed? If yes, it's an error, and materiality decides whether you restate, revise or simply correct it now. If the number was reasonable at the time and new facts changed it, it's a change in estimate, and you adjust this year and going forward without touching the past. Document which one you think it is and why, and bring your CPA in before anything goes back to the bank.
Sources
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Buying a business: the ASC 805 accounting checklist
November 18, 2026
- CECL isn't just for banks: the bad-debt allowance for your receivables
November 18, 2026
- Implementing a new cloud ERP? Which costs you can capitalize
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.