Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Refinanced your loan? Modification vs extinguishment

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Close-up of a printed loan agreement template lying on a polished wooden table
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

When you change a loan's terms with the same lender, ASC 470-50 asks whether the new terms are substantially different: is the present value of the new cash flows (including fees paid to the lender) at least 10% different from the present value of the old loan's remaining cash flows, both discounted at the old loan's effective rate? Under 10%, it's a modification: no gain or loss, lender fees are spread over the loan's life and third-party costs are expensed. At 10% or more, or if you pay off the old lender with money from a new lender, it's an extinguishment: old unamortized costs and any prepayment penalty hit profit now as a loss.

Rates dropped, or your bank offered a better deal, or you needed another year before the balloon payment. So you signed an amendment, paid a fee and a lawyer, and moved on. Then your accountant asks a question that sounds like paperwork: was that a modification or an extinguishment?

It isn't paperwork. The answer decides whether you book a loss this year, whether fees are expensed or spread, and what interest expense looks like for the rest of the loan. It can also move your covenant ratios. Below: how GAAP decides, with one loan refinanced two different ways.

Which question comes first?

Before the 10% test, there are two gates.

Did the lender change? If you repay the old loan with money borrowed from an unrelated new lender, that's an extinguishment of the old loan. Full stop. PwC's guide puts it plainly: a new loan from one lender combined with repaying an unrelated lender is always an extinguishment. The 10% test only applies when the same lender is on both sides.

Is the borrower in financial difficulty, and did the lender give a concession? If both are true, it's a troubled debt restructuring under ASC 470-60, which has its own rules. (ASU 2022-02 removed the troubled debt restructuring model for lenders, but borrowers still apply ASC 470-60.) Most refinancings by healthy businesses fail this gate easily, especially when the business got a better rate because its credit improved.

If the same lender is involved and it isn't troubled, you go to the 10% test.

How does the 10% cash flow test work?

Under ASC 470-50-40-10, the new terms are "substantially different" if the present value of the new loan's cash flows is at least 10% different from the present value of the old loan's remaining cash flows. Per PwC's summary of the rules:

  • Discount both sets of cash flows at the old loan's effective interest rate. That's the rate that includes the old issuance costs, not the coupon.
  • Include fees paid to the lender as a cash flow on day one of the new loan, along with any noncash consideration like warrants.
  • Leave out third-party costs, such as your lawyer and the appraiser. They don't count in the test.
  • Ignore noncash terms. Changes to covenants, collateral or seniority don't move the math.
  • For variable rates, use the rate in effect on the modification date.
  • If the loan has a prepayment or call option, run the test both ways (assume it's exercised, then assume it isn't) and use the scenario with the smaller change. RSM's article on prepayment penalties walks through how that works when the penalty itself changes.
  • Look back a year. If the loan was also modified in the past 12 months, compare against the terms before the earliest of those changes.

Lines of credit and revolvers follow a different rule (ASC 470-50-40-21) that compares borrowing capacity, meaning the remaining term times the maximum available credit, instead of cash flows. More on that in the FAQ.

Modification or extinguishment: what changes in the books?

The two outcomes treat the same costs in nearly opposite ways.

What happens to each cost

Under 10%, same lender

Modification

  • No gain or loss
  • Fees paid to the lender: added to unamortized costs and spread over the remaining term as interest
  • Third-party costs (legal, appraisal): expensed now
  • Old unamortized issuance costs: stay on the balance sheet and keep amortizing
  • A new effective interest rate is calculated going forward

10% or more, or a new lender

Extinguishment

  • Gain or loss now: what you paid to settle minus the old loan's net carrying amount
  • Fees and prepayment penalties paid to the old lender: part of the loss
  • Third-party costs for the new loan: capitalized and amortized over the new loan
  • Old unamortized issuance costs: written off into the loss
  • The new loan is recorded at fair value

The gain or loss on extinguishment is the reacquisition price (what you paid the old lender, including any penalty) minus the net carrying amount (principal less any unamortized discount and issuance costs). It goes in earnings in the period, shown as a separate item. You don't spread it.

A worked example: one loan, two ways to refinance

Here's a hypothetical example. Say your distribution company has a $1,000,000 term loan at 6%, interest-only with annual payments and the principal due in four years. When you took it out, you paid $16,000 of issuance costs, and $12,000 is still unamortized. So the loan sits on your balance sheet at $988,000, and its effective interest rate is about 6.35%.

Rates have come down and you have two offers.

Option A, same bank. Your bank amends the loan: rate down to 5.25%, maturity extended by one year (five years from now), for a $10,000 amendment fee paid to the bank. Your own lawyer charges $6,000.

Option B, new bank. A different bank lends you $1,000,000 at 5.25% for five years. You pay off the old loan, plus a 1% prepayment penalty of $10,000. The new bank charges a $10,000 origination fee and your lawyer charges $6,000.

Option A: run the 10% test

Cash flows, discounted at 6.35%Old loan (remaining)Amended loan
Fee paid to the bank todaynone$10,000
Annual interest4 × $60,0005 × $52,500
Principal at maturity$1,000,000 in year 4$1,000,000 in year 5
Present value$988,000$964,139
Change$23,861, or 2.4%

The lawyer's $6,000 stays out of the test. A 2.4% change is well under 10%, so Option A is a modification. (Because the old loan can be prepaid, you'd also run the test assuming prepayment. But a change under 10% in any scenario means modification, so the answer stands.)

The bookkeeping: the $10,000 fee to the bank joins the $12,000 already unamortized, so $22,000 is spread over the next five years. The $6,000 legal bill is expensed now. The loan's carrying amount becomes $978,000, and the new effective rate works out to about 5.77%, which is what drives interest expense from here.

Option B: the new lender settles it

No test needed. A new, unrelated lender means the old loan is extinguished.

Loss on extinguishmentAmount
Paid to the old bank: principal$1,000,000
Paid to the old bank: prepayment penalty$10,000
Reacquisition price$1,010,000
Less net carrying amount ($1,000,000 − $12,000)$988,000
Loss on extinguishment$22,000

The new loan goes on the books at $1,000,000, with the $10,000 origination fee and $6,000 of legal costs ($16,000 in total) capitalized as its issuance costs and amortized over five years.

Same loan, same new rate: where the costs land

Hypothetical $1,000,000 loan refinanced at 5.25%

  • Hits profit now
  • Spread over the next 5 years
$0$10k$20k$30kA: amend with same bank · Hits profit now: $6,000A: amend with same bank · Spread over the next 5 years: $22,000B: refinance with new bank · Hits profit now: $22,000B: refinance with new bank · Spread over the next 5 years: $16,000A: amend with same bankB: refinance with new bank

Hypothetical example. A: $6,000 legal expensed; $12,000 old costs + $10,000 bank fee spread. B: $12,000 old costs + $10,000 penalty as a loss; $10,000 origination fee + $6,000 legal spread.

Show the numbers
 Hits profit nowSpread over the next 5 years
A: amend with same bank$6,000$22,000
B: refinance with new bank$22,000$16,000

Notice that the totals aren't far apart ($28,000 versus $38,000, with the $10,000 difference being the prepayment penalty). The timing is what changes. Option B puts $22,000 through this year's profit and loss; Option A puts $6,000 there. If your bank covenant is based on this year's earnings or debt service coverage, that difference is real. Our post on what happens when you break a loan covenant explains why.

How big a change does it take to cross 10%?

Bigger than most owners expect. Here's the Option A amendment (same bank, one-year extension, $10,000 fee) at different new rates:

Change in present value under the 10% test

Same $1,000,000 loan, amended by the same bank at different new rates

New rate 5.25%New rate 5.25%: 2.4%2.4%New rate 4.50%New rate 4.50%: 5.6%5.6%New rate 4.00%New rate 4.00%: 7.7%7.7%New rate 3.50%New rate 3.50%: 9.8%9.8%New rate 3.00%New rate 3.00%: 11.9%11.9%

Hypothetical example, discounted at the old loan's 6.35% effective rate. Only the 3.00% amendment crosses 10% and would be an extinguishment.

Show the numbers
New rate 5.25%2.4%
New rate 4.50%5.6%
New rate 4.00%7.7%
New rate 3.50%9.8%
New rate 3.00%11.9%

On this loan, the rate has to drop by about three percentage points before the amendment counts as an extinguishment. On a longer loan, a smaller cut can cross the line, because the rate difference applies for more years. Large fees to the lender, principal changes and added conversion features can also push it over. That's why you run the numbers instead of guessing.

What else should you watch for?

Before you sign a loan amendment or refinancing

Gather

  • The old loan's effective interest rate and unamortized costs
  • The new term sheet, including every fee and who it's paid to
  • Any prepayment penalty or call option on the old loan
  • Any other changes to the same loan in the past 12 months

Decide

  • Same lender or a new one?
  • Is it a troubled debt restructuring?
  • Term loan (10% test) or line of credit (borrowing capacity test)?
  • Run the 10% test, both ways if there's a prepayment option

Record

  • Split fees paid to the lender from third-party costs
  • Expense or capitalize each one per the outcome
  • Recalculate the effective rate and amortization schedule
  • Check what the result does to covenant ratios this year

Common mistakes

Expensing everything. It feels conservative, but it's wrong for lender fees in a modification and new-loan costs in an extinguishment.

Forgetting the old unamortized costs. In an extinguishment, they must be written off. Left on the balance sheet, they keep amortizing against a loan that no longer exists.

Using the coupon rate in the test. The test uses the old loan's effective rate, including its issuance costs. Near the 10% line, the difference matters.

Putting the lawyer in the test. Third-party costs are excluded. Fees paid to the lender are included.

Treating the prepayment penalty as interest. In an extinguishment, a penalty paid to the old lender is part of the reacquisition price, so it lands in the loss, not in interest expense.

Assuming tax follows book. Tax has separate rules; ask your CPA.

When should you get help?

If your statements are prepared on a cash or tax basis just for your tax return, this matters less. If they're GAAP statements that go to a bank, investors or a reviewer, or if your loan has covenants tested on earnings, get the analysis done when the deal closes, not at year end.

Having balance sheet accounts, loans included, reconciled and explained every month is part of the accounting work Fintrix Consulting does. Your CPA or auditor still reviews the conclusion.

Frequently asked questions

Does a lower interest rate always mean modification?

No. A rate cut with the same lender is a modification only if the present value change stays under 10%. On a long loan, or combined with a big fee, a rate cut can cross the line. Moving to a new lender is always an extinguishment.

What about lines of credit?

Revolving lines follow ASC 470-50-40-21. You compare borrowing capacity (remaining term times maximum available credit) before and after. If capacity goes down, old unamortized costs are written off in proportion; new fees and costs are deferred over the new arrangement.

Is a gain on extinguishment possible?

Yes. If you settle debt for less than its net carrying amount, for example by buying back a loan at a discount, the difference is a gain.

Where does the loss go on the income statement?

It's recognized in the period of the extinguishment and shown as a separate item. It isn't spread over future periods.

We amended our loan twice this year. Does that matter?

Yes. If the loan was modified within the past 12 months, the test compares the new terms to the terms before the earliest modification in that period.

The bottom line

When a loan changes, the accounting turns on three questions: is it a new lender, is it a troubled debt restructuring, and does the change pass the 10% test? A modification spreads lender fees over the loan and expenses third-party costs. An extinguishment books a loss now for old costs and penalties, and starts the new loan fresh. Run the numbers before you sign, so the result shows up in your plans, not as a surprise in your year-end statements.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.