Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Should you capitalize sales commissions? (ASC 340-40)

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Overhead view of a handshake across a desk covered with revenue reports, charts and a laptop
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under GAAP (ASC 340-40), you capitalize a sales commission if it's an incremental cost of obtaining a contract (you'd only pay it because the contract was signed) and you expect to recover it. You then amortize the asset over the period the customer receives the related goods or services, which can include expected renewals when renewal commissions aren't commensurate. If that amortization period is one year or less, a practical expedient lets you simply expense the commission when incurred.

Your best salesperson just closed a three-year software deal and earned a $24,000 commission. Her manager gets a $6,000 override on the same deal. Payroll pays both this month, and your P&L shows a $30,000 hit in the same month the customer starts paying you $10,000 a month.

If your books are on a tax or cash basis, that's the end of it. But if a bank, an investor or an auditor wants GAAP statements, ASC 340-40 (the cost guidance that came with ASC 606) usually says that $30,000 belongs on the balance sheet and gets spread over the life of the customer relationship.

Which sales costs does ASC 340-40 say to capitalize?

The test is narrow. Per PwC's summary of ASC 340-40-25-1, you recognize an asset for the incremental costs of obtaining a contract with a customer if you expect to recover them. Incremental means you would not have incurred the cost if the contract hadn't been obtained.

That's why commissions are the classic example, and most other sales costs are not. Some quick sorting:

CostCapitalize?Why
Commission paid to the rep because the deal signedYes, if recoverablePaid only because the contract was obtained
Override paid to the sales manager on the same dealUsually yesAlso triggered only by the signed contract
Employer payroll taxes on those commissionsUsually yesThey exist only because the commission does
Commission on a renewal or upsellYes, if recoverableA renewal is a contract obtained
Base salaries of the sales teamNoPaid whether or not anything signs
Bonus tied to company revenue or profit targetsUsually noDepends on things other than obtaining contracts
Commission that is forfeited unless the rep stays employed for a yearUsually noIt's pay for future service, not for getting the contract
Proposal, travel, legal and marketing costsNoIncurred whether you win or lose

Two details trip people up. First, the timing of the payment doesn't decide anything on its own. A commission paid half at signing and half when the customer pays can still be incremental. Second, a commission subject to clawback (say, if the customer cancels in 90 days) can still be capitalized. You just reassess and test for impairment if the customer does cancel.

What is the one-year practical expedient?

ASC 340-40 has a practical expedient that lets you skip all of this when the amortization period of the asset would be one year or less. You expense the commission when incurred, the same as you would have done anyway.

The test is the amortization period, not the contract term. A one-year contract where you fully expect the customer to renew for years, and where renewals pay a much smaller commission, may have an amortization period of five years. In that case the expedient isn't available, even though each signed contract runs twelve months.

The expedient is an accounting policy, so apply it consistently to similar contracts. If one commission relates to several performance obligations with different periods, the expedient only works if every period is one year or less.

Honestly, for many small businesses this is where the analysis ends: commissions on one-off projects or truly one-year deals usually fit the expedient.

Expense now or capitalize?

Practical expedient

Expense when incurred

  • Amortization period would be one year or less
  • Typical: project work, product sales, short contracts that rarely renew
  • No asset, no schedule, no impairment test
  • Apply consistently to similar contracts

Default rule

Capitalize and amortize

  • Amortization period longer than one year
  • Typical: multi-year contracts, subscriptions with expected renewals
  • Asset on the balance sheet, amortized monthly
  • Tested for impairment when facts change

How long should you amortize capitalized commissions?

ASC 340-40 says to amortize the asset on a systematic basis consistent with the transfer of the goods or services the asset relates to. In plain terms: spread the cost over the period the customer gets what the contract was for.

That period can run longer than the signed contract. PwC's guide explains that if you expect renewals and the commission relates to those renewal periods, the amortization period can cover them, for example the average customer life or something shorter.

The deciding question is whether you pay a commensurate commission on renewal:

  • Renewal commission is commensurate with the initial one (similar as a percentage of contract value): the initial commission relates only to the initial contract. Amortize it over the initial term, and treat each renewal commission separately.
  • Renewal commission is much smaller, or zero: part of the initial commission is paying for the renewals you expect. Amortize it over the expected customer relationship.

PwC notes that "commensurate" is generally judged on contract values, not on how hard the rep works on a renewal versus a new deal. A plan that pays 20% on new business and 2% on renewals is not commensurate.

As for the pattern, straight-line fits only when the service is delivered evenly, like most subscriptions. If delivery is front-loaded, amortization should be too. A later change in the expected customer life is a change in estimate, handled going forward, not by restating the past. Our post on errors versus changes in estimates covers that difference.

Where does the amortization go on the P&L? Generally the same line where you'd have put the commission: if commissions sit in sales and marketing, so does the amortization.

A worked example: a three-year software contract

Say you run a 30-person B2B software company that reports under GAAP for its bank. In January 2026 you sign a three-year subscription at $120,000 a year, billed monthly at $10,000. The service is delivered evenly over the term.

  • The rep earns 20% of first-year contract value: $24,000
  • The sales manager earns a $6,000 override
  • Total incremental cost: $30,000 (payroll taxes left out to keep the math simple)
  • Renewals are yearly after the third year, and the plan pays only 2% on renewals, which isn't commensurate with the 25% paid on year one
  • Your customer history supports an expected relationship of five years

The amortization period is five years, so the expedient doesn't apply. Amortization is $30,000 ÷ 60 months = $500 a month, or $6,000 a year.

Commission cost on the P&L, expensed vs capitalized

$30,000 of commissions on a deal signed in January 2026

  • Expensed when paid
  • Capitalized, amortized over 5 years
$0$10k$20k$30k2026 · Expensed when paid: $30,0002026 · Capitalized, amortized over 5 years: $6,0002027 · Expensed when paid: $02027 · Capitalized, amortized over 5 years: $6,0002028 · Expensed when paid: $02028 · Capitalized, amortized over 5 years: $6,0002029 · Expensed when paid: $02029 · Capitalized, amortized over 5 years: $6,0002030 · Expensed when paid: $02030 · Capitalized, amortized over 5 years: $6,00020262027202820292030

Hypothetical example. Both approaches total $30,000; only the timing differs.

Show the numbers
 Expensed when paidCapitalized, amortized over 5 years
2026$30,000$6,000
2027$0$6,000
2028$0$6,000
2029$0$6,000
2030$0$6,000

The asset on the balance sheet runs down like this:

YearOpening balanceAmortizationClosing balance
2026$30,000$6,000$24,000
2027$24,000$6,000$18,000
2028$18,000$6,000$12,000
2029$12,000$6,000$6,000
2030$6,000$6,000$0

The entries are simple. When the commission is earned, debit a "capitalized contract costs" (or "deferred commissions") asset for $30,000 and credit commissions payable. Each month, debit commission expense $500 and credit the asset. When renewal commissions come in years four and five, they're separate costs with their own short periods, and they'll usually fit the one-year expedient.

The total cost is identical either way. What changes is your 2026 margin: $24,000 less commission expense in the first year, matched against the revenue the deal actually brings in.

When do capitalized commissions become impaired?

You test the asset when facts change. Per ASC 340-40-35-3, as PwC summarizes it, you recognize an impairment loss to the extent the carrying amount exceeds the consideration you still expect to receive (including amounts received but not yet recognized as revenue) less the direct costs of providing those goods or services that haven't been expensed yet. Under US GAAP, an impairment loss can't be reversed later.

Real impairments tend to come from terminations, price concessions or customers that stop paying.

What records do you need?

Capitalizing commissions is easy for one deal and messy for three hundred. Most growing companies keep a schedule by contract, or by portfolio of similar contracts, which PwC notes is an acceptable approach when the results wouldn't differ materially.

Commission capitalization file

Policy

  • A written policy: which plans qualify, when the one-year expedient applies, the amortization period by product line
  • The evidence behind the expected customer life (renewal and churn history)
  • A note on whether renewal commissions are commensurate

Monthly

  • Commission reports from payroll or the commission tool, tagged by contract
  • The amortization schedule rolled forward and tied to the balance sheet
  • Cancellations and clawbacks flagged for impairment review

Year end

  • Recheck the customer life assumption against actual churn
  • Impairment review of contracts with bad news

On disclosures: PwC's summary of the private company relief says nonpublic entities may treat the disclosures about contract cost assets, and about which practical expedients they used, as optional. The accounting itself is not optional.

Common mistakes

Using contract length to test the expedient. Annual contracts with expected multi-year relationships often don't qualify. The question is the amortization period.

Capitalizing too much. Salaries, team bonuses on company targets and commissions that depend on the rep staying employed aren't incremental costs of getting a contract.

Forgetting the payroll taxes. Employer taxes on a capitalized commission usually belong in the same asset.

Never revisiting the customer life. A five-year estimate set in 2023 and never checked against churn is a stale number. Update it, prospectively, when the data changes.

When should you get help?

If your statements are tax basis or cash basis, or your commissions all fit the one-year expedient, you probably don't need more than a short written policy. Our post on GAAP vs tax basis vs cash basis helps you check which framework you're on.

Get help when you're moving to GAAP for a loan, an audit or a fundraise, when you have multi-year or renewing contracts, or when nobody can explain the deferred commissions balance. This usually sits next to the revenue work: the five steps of ASC 606 and, for subscription businesses, SaaS revenue recognition. Accrual-basis statements, closed and reviewed every month, are part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting. Your auditor or CPA has the final word on the policy.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to capitalize sales commissions?

Under GAAP, yes, if they're incremental costs of obtaining a contract, you expect to recover them, and the amortization period would be longer than one year. If the period is one year or less you may expense them under the practical expedient. Tax basis and cash basis statements follow their own rules.

Can I amortize commissions over the contract term only?

Only if that matches the period the commission relates to. If you expect renewals and the renewal commission isn't commensurate with the initial one, the amortization period usually extends to cover the expected renewals.

Are commissions on renewals capitalized too?

They can be. A renewal is a contract obtained, so an incremental, recoverable renewal commission is capitalized and amortized over the period it relates to. Often that's a year or less, so the expedient applies.

Where does the amortization show up on the income statement?

Usually on the same line as other selling costs, typically sales and marketing. Capitalizing generally doesn't change the classification, only the timing.

The bottom line

ASC 340-40 doesn't change what your commissions cost. It changes when the cost hits your P&L. If the amortization period is a year or less, expense them and move on. If you sign multi-year or renewing contracts, capitalize the incremental commissions, amortize them over the expected customer relationship, and keep a schedule you can tie to the balance sheet each month. A short written policy, applied the same way every time, is most of the work.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.