Accounting standards
Is that grant a contribution or a contract? (ASU 2018-08)
November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Under ASU 2018-08, a grant is an exchange (accounted for under ASC 606) only if the resource provider itself receives value roughly equal to what it pays. A benefit to the general public, or to the funder's mission, doesn't count. Everything else is a contribution, and then you ask a second question: is it conditional? It is only if the agreement has both a barrier you must overcome and a right of return or release. Conditional means revenue waits until you clear the barrier; unconditional means you record it when promised.
It's January, and three award letters sit in the folder for the coming year. A family foundation pledged money for the after-school program. The state approved a cost-reimbursement grant. The county signed a contract for a reading curriculum. Your program director calls them all "grants." Your auditor won't.
Each one can land on your statement of activities at a different time, under a different standard. Get the label wrong and revenue moves between years. Below are the questions ASU 2018-08 asks, in order, then three hypothetical grants classified, with when each becomes revenue. For tracking restricted money and releases once it's booked, see our post on nonprofit grant accounting.
Why does the label matter?
Because it decides both which standard applies and when revenue shows up.
ASC 606
Exchange transaction
- The resource provider gets commensurate value back
- Revenue as you satisfy performance obligations
- No donor restrictions: it's earned revenue
- Unearned cash is a contract liability
ASC 958-605
Contribution
- Nonreciprocal: the provider gets nothing of equal value
- Unconditional: revenue when promised or received
- Conditional: revenue when the barrier is overcome
- May carry donor restrictions on purpose or time
Before ASU 2018-08, many organizations treated government grants as exchanges because the government "gets something" from them. FASB's update clarified the test, and BDO expected it to move more grants into contribution treatment. It's been effective for years, so this isn't new GAAP. It's GAAP people still get wrong.
Question 1: Does the funder get commensurate value?
This is the exchange test. The ASU spells out two things that don't count as value to the resource provider:
- A benefit to the general public. A foundation or government agency isn't the general public. If the public benefits from your work, that's not commensurate value received by the funder.
- Advancing the funder's mission, or the good feeling of being a donor.
The ASU also lists indicators. Pointing toward an exchange: both parties intend to swap goods or services of comparable value, they agree on the amount in return for those goods or services, and the contract carries penalties beyond giving back what was transferred. Pointing toward a contribution: you asked for the money without intending to give equal value back, the funder decides the amount on its own, and the only penalty for not performing is returning unspent money.
Who the funder is doesn't settle it. FASB's own examples show a federal research grant that's a contribution (the university keeps the rights to the findings, and the public benefits) and a local government study that's an exchange (the government owns the study it paid for).
Question 2: If it's a contribution, is it conditional?
A contribution is conditional only if the agreement has both:
- a barrier you have to overcome to be entitled to the money, and
- a right of return of assets already transferred, or a right of release from the funder's obligation to pay the rest.
Miss either piece and the contribution is unconditional.
Spotting a barrier takes judgment. The ASU gives three indicators:
- A measurable performance-related or other measurable barrier, like serving 5,000 meals, training 2,000 people a quarter, or raising matching gifts.
- Limited discretion over how you conduct the activity, such as spending only on allowable costs under detailed rules.
- A stipulation tied to the purpose of the agreement. Administrative or trivial requirements, like filing an annual report, generally aren't barriers.
Two rules surprise people. First, how likely you are to meet the barrier doesn't matter; the old "remote" test is gone. Second, if the wording is ambiguous and the stipulations aren't clearly unconditional, the contribution is presumed conditional.
If cash arrives before you clear the barrier, it's a refundable advance, a liability, until the condition is substantially met or the funder waives it.
Question 3: Is it restricted?
Restrictions and conditions are different questions, asked in that order.
| Condition | Donor restriction | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Decides when you record revenue | Decides which net asset class it goes in |
| Test | Barrier plus right of return or release | Limits on purpose or time, narrower than your overall mission |
| Before it's met | No revenue (refundable advance if cash came in) | Revenue recorded, held in net assets with donor restrictions |
| When it's met | Revenue recognized | Released to net assets without donor restrictions |
A grant can be both. FASB's homeless shelter example: a city gives $75,000 upfront for at least 5,000 meals, with a right of return for meals not served. It's conditional (measurable barrier plus right of return), so the cash sits as a refundable advance. Once the meals are served it becomes revenue with donor restrictions, because feeding people is narrower than the shelter's overall purpose.
There's one relief valve. If you've elected to report restricted contributions as unrestricted when the restriction is met in the same period, you can apply the same policy to conditional contributions whose conditions are met. BDO notes you can elect it for those conditional contributions alone, as long as you report consistently and disclose the policy. Our post on net asset classes and the liquidity note covers how restricted balances appear on the statements.
How are government cost-reimbursement grants treated?
Usually as conditional contributions. FASB's example is a federal research grant paid on a cost-reimbursement basis: the hospital must incur qualifying expenses under federal cost rules, unused amounts are forfeited, and unallowed costs must be refunded. The required spending limits the recipient's discretion, so it's a barrier, and the release for unused amounts supplies the second piece. Revenue is recorded as qualifying expenses are incurred.
In practice, that means grant revenue tracks allowable spending dollar for dollar, which EisnerAmper points out is the same answer most organizations reached before the update. The difference is the label and the reasoning, which your auditor will want to see documented. If you spend federal money, also keep an eye on the single audit threshold.
A worked example: three grants, three answers
Say you run a literacy nonprofit with a calendar fiscal year. In 2026 you sign three agreements:
Grant 1: Family foundation, $120,000. For the after-school reading program, paid $60,000 in February 2026 and $60,000 in February 2027. The only requirement is a short annual report. No barrier (the report is administrative), so it's unconditional, and because it's limited to one program, it's restricted. You record the full $120,000 as revenue with donor restrictions when the pledge is made in the first quarter, with the 2027 installment as a contribution receivable.
Grant 2: State education department, $200,000. Cost-reimbursement, July 2026 to June 2027, allowable costs only under the state's rules, unspent amounts forfeited. That's a barrier plus a right of release: conditional. Qualifying costs are $45,000 in the third quarter and $55,000 in the fourth, so 2026 revenue is $100,000. The other $100,000 isn't revenue or a receivable yet.
Grant 3: County library system, $80,000. The county hires you to design a family literacy curriculum it will own and use in its branches, delivered in two modules the county accepts separately: $30,000 in September and $50,000 in December. The county keeps all rights to what it paid for, so it receives commensurate value: an exchange under ASC 606. Revenue follows delivery: $30,000 in the third quarter, $50,000 in the fourth.
| Agreement | Classification | Why | 2026 revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foundation, $120,000 | Unconditional contribution, restricted | No barrier; purpose limited to one program | $120,000 |
| State, $200,000 | Conditional contribution | Allowable-cost barrier plus release of unspent funds | $100,000 |
| County, $80,000 | Exchange (ASC 606) | County owns the curriculum it paid for | $80,000 |
| Total | $300,000 |
Here's when that revenue lands, quarter by quarter:
When the three grants become revenue in 2026
Hypothetical literacy nonprofit, calendar fiscal year
- Contribution revenue (grants 1 and 2)
- Exchange revenue (grant 3)
Hypothetical example. Contributions total $220,000 ($120,000 foundation plus $100,000 state); exchange revenue totals $80,000.
Show the numbers
| Contribution revenue (grants 1 and 2) | Exchange revenue (grant 3) | |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 | $120,000 | $0 |
| Q2 | $0 | $0 |
| Q3 | $45,000 | $30,000 |
| Q4 | $55,000 | $50,000 |
Notice the shape. The foundation pledge spikes the first quarter even though half the cash arrives in 2027, while the state grant trickles in only as money is spent. If the state had advanced $50,000 in July, you'd have booked a $50,000 refundable advance and moved $45,000 of it into revenue as the third-quarter costs were incurred, leaving $5,000 as a liability at September 30.
Common mistakes
Calling every government award an exchange. "The state gets something" isn't the test. Unless the agency itself receives commensurate value, like owning a study it commissioned, it's a contribution. CLA calls this one of the most common misconceptions.
Mixing up conditions and restrictions. A purpose restriction doesn't delay revenue. Only a barrier with a right of return or release does.
Recording a conditional award as a receivable. The full $200,000 state award isn't revenue on the signing date. Book only what you've earned through qualifying spending.
Treating reporting requirements as barriers. An annual narrative report is administrative. It doesn't make a foundation pledge conditional.
Not documenting the analysis. Write a one-page memo per significant agreement: exchange or contribution, conditional or not, restricted or not, and why. Your auditor and your Form 990 preparer will both ask.
Read the agreement for
- Who owns the work product or results
- How the amount was set: negotiated price or funder's discretion
- Penalties beyond returning unspent money
- Measurable targets, allowable-cost rules or matching requirements
- Rights of return or release for unspent or unearned amounts
- Limits on purpose or time
Then record
- Classification memo filed with the agreement
- A separate class or fund for the grant
- Refundable advance for any cash received before conditions are met
- Unrecognized conditional amounts noted for the year-end disclosures
When should you get help?
If your grants are mostly simple foundation gifts with a purpose restriction, you can handle the classification yourself with the three questions above. Get help when you have government awards, contracts that look like procurement, conditional grants with cash advances, or an audit coming. Your auditor has the final word on any judgment call.
Keeping restricted and unrestricted money apart, and tracking spending against each grant's budget all year, is the core of what we do for nonprofits at Fintrix Consulting.
Frequently asked questions
Are government grants always contributions under ASU 2018-08?
No, but many are. A government grant is an exchange only if the agency itself receives commensurate value, like a study it owns. Grants that mainly benefit the public are contributions, and cost-reimbursement grants are usually conditional contributions.
What's the difference between a condition and a restriction?
A condition (a barrier plus a right of return or release) decides when you recognize revenue. A restriction (a limit on purpose or time) decides whether the revenue goes into net assets with or without donor restrictions. A grant can have both.
Does the chance of meeting the condition matter?
No. Under ASU 2018-08, the likelihood of overcoming a barrier isn't part of deciding whether a contribution is conditional. If the barrier and the right of return or release are both there, it's conditional.
What if the grant agreement is unclear?
If the stipulations aren't clearly unconditional, ASU 2018-08 says to presume the contribution is conditional. Ask the funder to clarify in writing when you can.
Where does cash received before the condition is met go?
On the balance sheet as a refundable advance, a liability. It moves into revenue as the condition is substantially met, or if the funder explicitly waives it.
The bottom line
Ask the questions in order. Does the funder get commensurate value? If yes, it's an exchange under ASC 606. If not, it's a contribution: look for a barrier plus a right of return or release to decide if it's conditional, then look for purpose or time limits to decide if it's restricted. Write the answer down for every significant agreement, and your revenue will land in the right year with an audit trail to back it.
Sources
- Accounting Standards Update 2018-08, Not-for-Profit Entities (Topic 958): Clarifying the Scope and the Accounting Guidance for Contributions Received and Contributions Made (FASB)
- FASB clarifies not-for-profit grant and contributions accounting (BDO)
- FASB ASU 2018-08 clarifies revenue accounting for nonprofit grants and contracts (CLA)
- FASB's ASU 2018-08 impacts not-for-profit organizations (EisnerAmper)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- 100% bonus depreciation is permanent: book vs tax effects
November 20, 2026
- The AICPA's FRF for SMEs: a simpler alternative to GAAP?
November 20, 2026
- Writing a capitalization policy: the $2,500 rule and GAAP
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.