Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

The AICPA's FRF for SMEs: a simpler alternative to GAAP?

November 20, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Eyeglasses and a pen on a printed report with blue bar and pie charts next to a desk calculator
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

FRF for SMEs is a non-GAAP reporting framework the AICPA built for owner-managed private businesses. It keeps accrual accounting and historical cost but drops the hardest parts of GAAP: operating leases stay off the balance sheet, there's no CECL credit loss model, and you can account for income taxes on a taxes payable basis. It's a good fit when your lender or surety agrees to it in writing; if they want GAAP, or if your statements already match your tax return, GAAP or tax basis is usually the better choice.

Your bank wants reviewed financial statements this year. Your CPA quotes the job, then mentions that a chunk of the cost is ASC 842 lease work and the CECL allowance on your receivables. Then comes the question: "Have you thought about FRF for SMEs instead?"

Most owners haven't heard of it, which is partly its problem. It's a sensible framework, but it only helps if the people reading your statements accept it.

Our post on GAAP, tax basis or cash basis compares the main frameworks side by side. This one looks closely at FRF for SMEs: what it actually changes, a worked example of what it does to your balance sheet, and when it beats the alternatives.

2013

Year the AICPA released FRF for SMEs as an optional, non-GAAP framework

None

Effective date: use is optional, so you can adopt it whenever your readers agree

Historical cost

The main way assets are measured, with very little fair value

What is FRF for SMEs, exactly?

The Financial Reporting Framework for Small- and Medium-Sized Entities is a special purpose framework, in the same family as tax basis and cash basis. A task force of CPA practitioners and AICPA staff wrote it for private, for-profit, owner-managed businesses that don't need GAAP. It's self-contained, meaning it isn't GAAP with pieces removed.

The framework describes itself as a blend of traditional accounting principles and accrual income tax methods, with historical cost as the main measurement basis. It favors broad principles and judgment over detailed rules, and its disclosures are much lighter than GAAP's.

Two things about its status matter:

  • Nobody can make you use it. The AICPA says it has no authority to require FRF for SMEs, so there's no effective date. You adopt it when you and your readers choose to.
  • It's meant to be stable. The framework was designed to change rarely, with reviews planned every few years rather than a constant stream of updates. The edition we reviewed for this post is dated November 2017.

See the glossary for special purpose frameworks and FRF for SMEs.

How is it different from GAAP?

Day-to-day bookkeeping is the same: accrual accounting, receivables and payables, inventory, depreciation over useful life. The differences show up in the year-end adjustments that cost the most to prepare.

AreaUS GAAPFRF for SMEs
Leases (lessee)Right-of-use asset and lease liability for most leases (ASC 842)Capital or operating lease; operating leases stay off the balance sheet
Credit lossesExpected credit loss model, known as CECL (ASC 326)Allowance for doubtful accounts based on judgment; no CECL
Income taxesDeferred taxes required, plus uncertain tax positionsChoice of taxes payable method or deferred income taxes method; no uncertain tax position analysis
SubsidiariesConsolidate, including variable interest entities unless an exception appliesChoice to consolidate or use the equity method; no VIE model
GoodwillImpairment testing (private companies can elect to amortize)Amortized over the federal tax period, or 15 years if not amortized for tax
Derivatives, such as an interest-rate swapRecorded at fair valueRecorded when settled, with disclosure
Stock compensationExpense measured at fair valueDisclosure only
RevenueFive-step model (ASC 606)Broad principles: performance achieved and collection reasonably assured

The three that save the most work for a typical small business:

Leases. Under GAAP, an office or warehouse lease brings a right-of-use asset and a lease liability onto the balance sheet. Under FRF for SMEs, lessees still classify leases as capital or operating, the way pre-842 GAAP did, so a normal operating lease is just rent expense. Our ASC 842 guide shows what GAAP requires.

Credit losses. GAAP's CECL model asks you to estimate expected losses on receivables, including forward-looking information. FRF for SMEs predates CECL and keeps a traditional allowance for doubtful accounts. GAAP has narrowed this gap with a practical expedient for current receivables, covered in the 2026 bad-debt shortcut, but the full model is still in CECL for small businesses.

Income taxes. A C corporation can elect the taxes payable method and record only the tax actually owed for the year, with no deferred tax assets or liabilities. Entities whose income is taxed to the owners, like S corporations and partnerships, record no income tax provision at all.

How is it different from tax basis?

If GAAP feels like too much, the usual alternative is income tax basis.

FRF for SMEs vs income tax basis

Accrual, judgment-based

FRF for SMEs

  • Equipment depreciated over its useful life
  • Revenue when earned, under the framework's own principles
  • Optional deferred taxes for C corporations
  • Structured statements and a defined set of disclosures
  • Reads more like GAAP to a lender

Follows the return

Income tax basis

  • Tax depreciation, often 100% bonus in year one
  • Revenue and expenses as reported on the return
  • No deferred taxes
  • Little or no reconciliation to the tax return
  • Profit can swing with tax elections

The big one is depreciation. With 100% bonus depreciation now permanent, tax-basis statements can show a loss in a year you buy equipment and a fat profit the next, which makes trend analysis hard. FRF for SMEs depreciates over useful life, so profit stays comparable year to year. See 100% bonus depreciation: book vs tax effects for how wide that gap gets.

A worked example: one balance sheet, two frameworks

Say you run a C corporation that distributes building supplies. At year end it has $3,500,000 of assets, $2,000,000 of liabilities and $1,500,000 of equity under FRF for SMEs. It has just signed a seven-year warehouse lease with a present value of $900,000, and it uses the taxes payable method. Its bank loan has a covenant capping debt to equity at 2.0 times. All of this is hypothetical.

Under GAAP, two things change:

  • The warehouse lease adds a $900,000 right-of-use asset and a $900,000 lease liability.
  • Deferred taxes. The company has used bonus depreciation for years, so GAAP requires a $60,000 deferred tax liability, which also reduces equity by $60,000.
FRF for SMEsUS GAAP
Total assets$3,500,000$4,400,000
Total liabilities$2,000,000$2,960,000
Equity$1,500,000$1,440,000
Debt to equity1.33x2.06x

From FRF for SMEs liabilities to GAAP liabilities

Hypothetical building supplies distributor at year end

  • Adds liabilities
  • Reduces liabilities
  • Total
$0$1M$2M$3MFRF liabilities: $2,000,000$2MFRFliabilitiesLease liability: +$900,000+$900kLeaseliabilityDeferred tax: +$60,000+$60kDeferredtaxGAAP liabilities: $2,960,000$3MGAAPliabilities

Hypothetical example: 2,000,000 + 900,000 + 60,000 = 2,960,000.

Show the numbers
FRF liabilities$2,000,000
Lease liability+$900,000
Deferred tax+$60,000
GAAP liabilities$2,960,000

Liabilities and equity under each framework

Same business, same day

  • Total liabilities
  • Equity
$0$1M$2M$3MFRF for SMEs · Total liabilities: $2,000,000FRF for SMEs · Equity: $1,500,000US GAAP · Total liabilities: $2,960,000US GAAP · Equity: $1,440,000FRF for SMEsUS GAAP

Hypothetical example. Debt to equity is 2,000,000 ÷ 1,500,000 = 1.33x under FRF for SMEs and 2,960,000 ÷ 1,440,000 = 2.06x under GAAP.

Show the numbers
 Total liabilitiesEquity
FRF for SMEs$2,000,000$1,500,000
US GAAP$2,960,000$1,440,000

Same business, same cash. Under FRF for SMEs it passes the covenant; under GAAP it fails.

Before you take that as an argument for switching: the covenant was set using numbers on some basis, and the bank knows which one. Moving frameworks to get under a covenant without the lender's agreement doesn't fix anything, and changing it without telling them can be a default in its own right. The honest use of this example is the reverse: if you're negotiating a new loan and plan to report on FRF for SMEs, make sure the covenants are written on that basis.

The income statement moves much less: lease cost is usually close under both, so profit differs mainly by the year's change in deferred taxes.

Who accepts FRF for SMEs?

Whoever reads your statements decides, so ask before you adopt it.

  • Banks. The framework was written with lenders in mind, and the AICPA describes it as a fit when a banker looks at collateral and other factors, not just the statements. Some lenders accept it; plenty have never seen it. Get the acceptance in the loan agreement, not just on a call.
  • Sureties. Bonding companies care about working capital and equity, and contractors usually hear GAAP. If you're bonded, check with your surety and its underwriter before switching.
  • Investors and buyers. Outside investors and buyers generally want GAAP, because it's comparable and it's what due diligence rebuilds anyway. See why lenders and investors want accrual financials.
  • Regulators and government contracts. If a regulator, grant or contract names the basis, use that one.

The framework and the level of CPA involvement are separate choices. A compilation, review or audit can each be done on FRF for SMEs. If you're not sure which level you need, start with audit, review or compilation.

When is GAAP or tax basis the better choice?

Picking a framework

GAAP is usually better if

  • Your loan agreement, surety or investors require it
  • You plan to raise outside equity or sell the business in the next few years
  • You have complex transactions the framework doesn't cover, like significant derivatives or stock compensation you want measured

Tax basis is usually better if

  • Your readers already accept tax-basis statements
  • You want statements that tie to the return with almost no reconciliation
  • Year-to-year swings from bonus depreciation don't bother your lender

FRF for SMEs makes sense if

  • Your lender agrees to it in writing
  • You want accrual statements with useful-life depreciation
  • ASC 842 and CECL work is a real cost and adds little for your readers

Honestly, familiarity usually decides it, not technical merit. GAAP has added private company alternatives over the years, like amortizing goodwill, which narrow the gap. If your readers know GAAP and the extra cost is modest, staying put is often the easier path.

Common mistakes

Switching without the lender's sign-off. The loan agreement says which statements you deliver. A different framework is a different deliverable.

Assuming FRF for SMEs is "basically tax basis." It isn't. Depreciation, revenue and accruals follow the framework, not the return, so you'll still have book-tax differences.

Forgetting the comparatives. The framework has its own transition rules, and the first year needs opening balances and any comparative figures worked out on the new basis. Plan it with your CPA before year end.

Calling the statements by GAAP names. Special purpose frameworks describe the basis used in the notes, and the CPA's report says which framework applies.

When should you get help?

If you're happy with GAAP or tax-basis statements and your readers are too, there's no reason to change. Get help when a lender asks for statements you don't produce yet, when ASC 842 and credit-loss work is driving up the cost of your review or audit, or when a new loan is being negotiated and the framework is still open.

The framework choice is one you make with your CPA and your lender. At Fintrix Consulting, our accounting service produces accrual-basis financial statements monthly by the 12th and audit- and tax-ready workpapers at year end, so whoever reports on them starts from clean, reconciled books.

Frequently asked questions

Is FRF for SMEs the same as IFRS for SMEs?

No. IFRS for SMEs is an international standard issued by the IASB. FRF for SMEs is a separate, non-GAAP framework from the AICPA, built for US owner-managed businesses.

Can a CPA audit statements prepared under FRF for SMEs?

Yes. An audit, review or compilation can be performed on special purpose framework statements, and the report names the framework used.

Does FRF for SMEs require ASC 842 lease accounting?

No. Lessees classify leases as capital or operating, and operating leases stay off the balance sheet.

Do I have to record deferred taxes under FRF for SMEs?

Not if you choose the taxes payable method, which records only the current year's tax. You can choose the deferred income taxes method instead. S corporations and partnerships record no income tax provision.

Will my bank accept FRF for SMEs statements?

Some will, many will want GAAP or tax basis. Ask your loan officer, and get any acceptance written into the loan agreement.

The bottom line

FRF for SMEs is a reasonable middle ground: accrual statements with useful-life depreciation, without ASC 842, CECL or mandatory deferred taxes. Its weakness is that fewer readers know it than GAAP or tax basis, and a framework your lender doesn't accept saves you nothing. Ask your lender, surety and investors first, write the answer into your agreements, and pick the framework that serves the people reading your statements.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.