Accounting standards
Private companies can amortize goodwill: should you?
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Yes, if you're a private company or a not-for-profit you can elect to amortize goodwill straight-line over 10 years or less and test it for impairment only when something happens, with a simpler one-step test. For most owner-managed companies that will stay private, it's the easier and cheaper choice. Skip it if an IPO, SPAC or sale to a public company is a real possibility, because the election would have to be undone.
You bought a competitor. The deal closed, the lawyers sent their bills, and now your accountant is asking a question that sounds academic: "Do you want to amortize the goodwill?"
It isn't academic. That choice decides whether a seven-figure asset sits untouched until something goes wrong, or shrinks a little every year. It changes your reported profit, your yearly valuation work, and how messy things get if you later sell to a public company.
Here's what the alternative is, who can use it, a worked acquisition, and when to say no.
10 years
Maximum life for goodwill under the private company alternative (shorter if you can support it)
Triggers only
No annual impairment test. You test when an event suggests value has dropped
Private + NFP
Private companies and not-for-profits can elect it. Public business entities can't
What is goodwill, and why does the accounting matter?
When you buy a business, you pay for more than its equipment and receivables. You pay for the customer relationships, the trained team, the reputation. Under GAAP, whatever you paid above the fair value of the identifiable assets and liabilities you took on is goodwill.
The default rule is that goodwill never gets amortized. It sits on the balance sheet at cost and is tested for impairment at least once a year, which for a small company often means paying a valuation specialist every year. Private companies told the FASB that was a lot of cost for little useful information, and the answer was ASU 2014-02.
What does the private company goodwill alternative allow?
If you elect it, four things change:
- You amortize goodwill straight-line over 10 years, or a shorter period if you can show a shorter life fits better. You can never go beyond 10 years. Ten years works as a practical default for each acquisition.
- You only test for impairment when a triggering event happens. No annual test. Triggering events are things like losing a major customer, a sharp drop in results, a key person leaving or a big shift in your market.
- You choose the level: test the whole company as one unit, or test at the reporting unit level. You make this policy choice when you adopt.
- The test is one step. Compare the fair value of the company (or reporting unit) with its carrying amount. If carrying amount is higher, the difference is your impairment loss, capped at the goodwill balance. An optional qualitative look comes first, so you only run the numbers if it looks more likely than not that you're impaired.
Impairment losses can't be reversed later, with or without the alternative.
Public companies must use this
Default GAAP
- Goodwill is not amortized
- Impairment test at least once a year, plus whenever a trigger occurs
- Tested at the reporting unit level
- Balance only falls if you're impaired
- Profit looks higher in normal years, then can take a big hit in a bad one
ASU 2014-02, extended to NFPs by ASU 2019-06
Private company alternative
- Amortized straight-line over 10 years or less
- Tested only when a triggering event happens
- Entity level or reporting unit level, your choice at adoption
- Balance falls every year
- Steady amortization expense, smaller impairments if things go wrong
Who can elect it?
Private companies, meaning companies that don't meet the definition of a public business entity, can elect it. Since ASU 2019-06, not-for-profit organizations can too. Employee benefit plans can't.
The election is adopted prospectively, at the beginning of any fiscal year, and you don't have to argue that the new method is "preferable" (normally required when you change accounting principles). Goodwill already on the books when you adopt can be amortized over a remaining life of up to 10 years. You don't go back and catch up amortization from the original acquisition date.
What does ASU 2021-03 add?
A triggering event in June used to mean testing goodwill as of June, which is painful for a company that only prepares annual statements.
ASU 2021-03 lets private companies and not-for-profits evaluate triggering events only as of the end of each reporting period. If you only report annually, that's once a year at year-end. If you prepare quarterly GAAP statements for your lender, it's each quarter-end. It's a separate election: you can take it with or without goodwill amortization. It's a one-time, unconditional choice applied going forward.
What about other intangibles from the deal?
There's a sister alternative, ASU 2014-18. It lets a private company stop recognizing two kinds of intangible assets separately in an acquisition: customer-related intangibles that can't be sold or licensed on their own, and noncompete agreements. They're folded into goodwill instead, which saves part of the purchase price valuation work.
The catch: if you elect ASU 2014-18, you must also amortize goodwill under ASU 2014-02. The reverse isn't true. Intangibles already on your books when you adopt keep their existing accounting.
A worked example: one acquisition, two ways
Say you own a regional HVAC services company with a December year-end. On January 1, 2026 you buy a smaller competitor for $3,000,000. The identifiable assets you pick up (trucks, equipment, receivables, a customer list valued separately, less the liabilities you assume) have a fair value of $1,800,000. Goodwill is $1,200,000.
You elect the alternative and use a 10-year life. That's $120,000 of amortization a year, $10,000 a month.
| Year-end | Goodwill, alternative elected | Goodwill, default GAAP (no impairment) | Amortization expense that year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $1,080,000 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 |
| 2027 | $960,000 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 |
| 2028 | $840,000 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 |
| 2029 | $720,000 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 |
| 2030 | $600,000 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 |
Goodwill balance at each year-end
$1.2M of goodwill from a January 2026 acquisition, with and without the private company alternative
- Amortized over 10 years
- Default GAAP, no impairment
Hypothetical example. $1,200,000 ÷ 10 years = $120,000 a year.
Show the numbers
| Amortized over 10 years | Default GAAP, no impairment | |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $1,080,000 | $1,200,000 |
| 2027 | $960,000 | $1,200,000 |
| 2028 | $840,000 | $1,200,000 |
| 2029 | $720,000 | $1,200,000 |
| 2030 | $600,000 | $1,200,000 |
Now say that in 2028 your largest commercial customer, about a fifth of revenue, moves to a competitor. That's a triggering event. At December 31, 2028, a valuation puts the whole company's fair value at $4,600,000.
- With the alternative (entity-level test): carrying amount of the company is $4,840,000, including $840,000 of goodwill. It's $240,000 above fair value, so you record a $240,000 impairment. Goodwill drops to $600,000.
- Under default GAAP: goodwill is still $1,200,000, so the carrying amount is $360,000 higher, at $5,200,000. It's $600,000 above fair value, so you record a $600,000 impairment, all in one year.
2028 hit to profit from goodwill
Same customer loss, same fair value, two accounting choices
- Alternative elected
- Default GAAP
Hypothetical example. For simplicity it ignores deferred taxes, which are part of the carrying amount in a real test.
Show the numbers
| Alternative elected | Default GAAP | |
|---|---|---|
| Amortization | $120,000 | $0 |
| Impairment | $240,000 | $600,000 |
| Total 2028 charge | $360,000 | $600,000 |
Over 2026 to 2028, both approaches have charged $600,000 against profit in total (three years of $120,000 plus $240,000, versus a single $600,000 impairment). The difference is timing and shape: steady and predictable, or quiet and then a cliff.
One thing doesn't change at all: cash. Amortization and impairment are non-cash. Your EBITDA is the same either way, which is why most lenders' covenants won't care. Check yours anyway, since some agreements are written on net income or tangible net worth.
Should you elect it?
Honestly, for most owner-managed companies that plan to stay private, yes. You save the annual valuation exercise, impairment tests become rare, and the balance sheet doesn't carry an aging number from a deal you did eight years ago.
It's a weaker fit when:
- An IPO, SPAC merger or sale to a public company is realistic. If you later meet the public business entity definition, the alternative goes away and your historical goodwill accounting has to be restated as if you'd never elected it. If your financial statements end up in a public acquirer's SEC filing, you can face the same unwinding for those statements. That's expensive work at the worst possible time.
- Your goodwill really does hold its value. If you're consistently growing and the acquired business is thriving, amortization makes your reported profit look worse than the economics.
- A loan or investor agreement is written on GAAP net income and amortization would squeeze a covenant.
Strategy
- Rule out an IPO, SPAC or sale to a public buyer in the next several years, or accept the unwind cost
- Check loan covenants that use net income or tangible net worth
- Check earnout and bonus formulas that use net income
Accounting choices
- Pick a useful life for each acquisition (10 years unless a shorter life fits better)
- Decide entity-level or reporting unit testing
- Decide on ASU 2021-03 period-end trigger evaluation
- Decide whether to also elect ASU 2014-18 for customer intangibles and noncompetes
Paperwork
- Agree the elections with your auditor or reviewer before year-end
- Write the policy down, with the adoption date
- Set up the monthly amortization entry in your books
- Add a year-end triggering event checklist to your close
Common mistakes
Amortizing without telling anyone. Your auditor or reviewer needs to agree the election up front. Turning up at year-end with amortization already booked and no policy decision isn't a great start.
Ignoring triggers because "we amortize now." Amortization replaces the annual test, not the duty to look. At each period-end, ask what happened: lost customers, falling margins, key departures. Write the answer down even when it's "nothing".
Forgetting the interaction with ASU 2014-18. If you want customer relationships folded into goodwill on a new deal, you need goodwill amortization too. Decide both together, before the purchase price allocation is done.
When should you talk to your auditor or an accountant?
Before the first year-end after an acquisition, ideally before the deal closes. The decision affects the purchase price allocation (especially if you want ASU 2014-18), your covenants and your future exit options. It's a judgment call your auditor will want to see documented.
If you don't have a finance team that handles acquisition accounting, this is the kind of work our accounting service covers at Fintrix Consulting: setting up the policy, the monthly entries and the year-end trigger review, working alongside your auditor or CPA. You're welcome to talk it through with us.
For more on how goodwill and other intangibles show up on your statements, see how to read a balance sheet. If you like private company shortcuts, the 2026 credit loss shortcut is another one worth knowing about.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch to amortizing goodwill now for an acquisition I made years ago?
Yes. You can adopt the alternative at the start of any fiscal year, and goodwill already on the books is amortized over a remaining life of up to 10 years from that point. You don't go back and catch up amortization from the original deal date.
Do I have to use 10 years?
No. Ten years is the maximum and a common default. You can use a shorter life for an acquisition if you can show it fits better, for example a business built around a contract that runs for six years.
Does amortizing goodwill reduce my taxes?
Not by itself. Book amortization under GAAP is separate from tax rules. Whether goodwill is deductible for tax depends on how the deal was structured, so ask your CPA.
Can a nonprofit use this?
Yes. ASU 2019-06 extended the goodwill alternative, the intangibles alternative and later the triggering event alternative to not-for-profit entities. Nonprofits that merge or acquire another organization should consider it.
What happens if we later go public?
The alternative is no longer available once you meet the public business entity definition, and your historical statements have to be adjusted as if you had followed the default goodwill rules all along. That usually means retroactive impairment testing, which is costly.
The bottom line
For a private company that expects to stay private, amortizing goodwill over 10 years or less is usually the simpler, cheaper and more predictable choice. You trade an annual valuation exercise for a steady non-cash charge and an impairment test only when something actually happens. If a public buyer or an IPO is a real possibility, slow down and price the unwind first. Either way, make the decision deliberately, with your auditor, before your first year-end after the deal.
Sources
- Goodwill alternatives for private companies and not-for-profits (RSM)
- 9.11 Accounting alternatives for private companies/NFP entities, Business combinations guide (PwC Viewpoint)
- ASU 2021-03 full text (PwC Viewpoint)
- ASU 2019-06 full text (PwC Viewpoint)
- FASB Issues Guidance for Private Cos. on Intangible Assets in Biz Combos (Accounting Today)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- CECL isn't just for banks: the bad-debt allowance for your receivables
November 18, 2026
- Bitcoin on your balance sheet: the fair value rules (ASU 2023-08)
November 18, 2026
- New GAAP for government grants received by businesses (ASU 2025-10)
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.