Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Bitcoin on your balance sheet: the fair value rules (ASU 2023-08)

November 18, 2026 · 9 min read

← All articles
Stacks of gold and silver bitcoin coins in front of a blurred price chart
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASU 2023-08, a company holding bitcoin or a similar crypto asset carries it at fair value on the balance sheet, on its own line, and puts every increase or decrease in value through net income each period. Before this, crypto was held at cost less impairment: you wrote it down when the price fell but could never write it back up. The rules apply to all entities for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2024, so calendar-year companies are already on them for 2025 and 2026.

A few years ago, a company holding bitcoin had a strange-looking balance sheet. The coins sat at cost minus every impairment you'd ever taken, so if the price dropped hard one quarter and then doubled, your books still showed the low number. Lenders and investors had to read the footnotes to find out what the holdings were worth.

ASU 2023-08, issued by the FASB on December 13, 2023, fixed that. In-scope crypto assets are now measured at fair value, and the gains and losses go through net income. For calendar-year companies the rules have applied since January 1, 2025. If your company bought bitcoin in 2026, or your fiscal year started after December 15, 2024, these are the rules for your year-end.

This post is for owners and small finance teams of private companies that hold crypto as a treasury asset or accept it as payment. It covers what's in scope, what the numbers look like quarter by quarter, the disclosures, and the tax wrinkle.

Fair value

Carried at fair value each reporting date, with changes in net income

6 criteria

A crypto asset must meet all six to be in scope

FY 2025

Required for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2024, for all entities

Which crypto assets are in scope?

A crypto asset falls under the new rules (ASC 350-60) only if it meets all six of these criteria, as summarized by Grant Thornton:

  1. It's an intangible asset.
  2. It doesn't give you enforceable rights to, or claims on, underlying goods, services or other assets.
  3. It's created or lives on a blockchain or similar distributed ledger.
  4. It's secured through cryptography.
  5. It's fungible.
  6. It wasn't created or issued by you or your related parties.

Bitcoin and ether typically pass. Things that commonly fail one of the tests:

  • NFTs fail "fungible".
  • Tokens you issued yourself fail criterion six. (A miner or validator that receives newly created coins as its reward isn't treated as the creator, as long as that's its only role in creating them.)
  • Many stablecoins that give the holder a right to redeem for dollars may fail criterion two. Look at the actual terms and ask your auditor.

Assets that fail stay under the older intangible asset guidance or whatever other GAAP applies, so you can end up with two models on one balance sheet.

What changed from the old model?

Before and after ASU 2023-08

Cost less impairment

Old model

  • Treated as an indefinite-lived intangible asset
  • Written down when fair value fell below carrying amount
  • Write-downs could never be reversed
  • Price increases ignored until you sold
  • Balance sheet often far below market value

Fair value through net income

ASU 2023-08

  • Measured at fair value under ASC 820 every reporting date
  • Increases and decreases both go through net income
  • Shown on its own line, separate from other intangibles
  • Gains and losses shown separately from amortization or impairment of other intangibles
  • New disclosures: holdings, cost basis, restrictions, annual rollforward

The old model was asymmetric. Bad news hit the P&L immediately; good news waited until you sold. Fair value is symmetric, which makes the balance sheet more honest and the P&L more volatile. That trade-off is the whole story of this standard.

A worked example: one year, four quarters

Say you run a 25-person software company with a December year end. In January 2026, the board approves putting part of your cash reserve into bitcoin. On January 15 you buy 4 bitcoin at $100,000 each, $400,000 in total. You hold them all year.

The prices below are made up for the example. They are not actual bitcoin prices.

DatePrice per coin (made up)Fair value of 4 coinsGain or (loss) in the quarter
Jan 15 (purchase)$100,000$400,000
Mar 31$85,000$340,000($60,000)
Jun 30$95,000$380,000$40,000
Sep 30$110,000$440,000$60,000
Dec 31$90,000$360,000($80,000)
Full year($40,000)

Under ASU 2023-08, the balance sheet shows the fair value at each quarter end, and each quarter's change hits net income. The year's total loss is $40,000, which is exactly the drop from $400,000 to $360,000.

Now the old model, simplified: you write the coins down to the lowest price seen during a quarter and never write them back up. Say the lowest price in Q1 was $80,000 (carrying amount $320,000, an $80,000 impairment). Prices in Q2 and Q3 never went below $80,000, so nothing changes. In Q4 the price briefly touched $78,000, so another $8,000 write-down, to $312,000.

Carrying value of 4 bitcoin: old model vs fair value

Hypothetical software company, 2026. Prices are made up for the example

  • Fair value (ASU 2023-08)
  • Cost less impairment (old model)
$0$200k$400k$600kJan 15 · Fair value (ASU 2023-08): $400,000Mar 31 · Fair value (ASU 2023-08): $340,000Jun 30 · Fair value (ASU 2023-08): $380,000Sep 30 · Fair value (ASU 2023-08): $440,000Dec 31 · Fair value (ASU 2023-08): $360,000Jan 15 · Cost less impairment (old model): $400,000Mar 31 · Cost less impairment (old model): $320,000Jun 30 · Cost less impairment (old model): $320,000Sep 30 · Cost less impairment (old model): $320,000Dec 31 · Cost less impairment (old model): $312,000Jan 15Mar 31Jun 30Sep 30Dec 31

Hypothetical example. Fair value: full-year loss of $40,000. Old model: impairments of $80,000 in Q1 and $8,000 in Q4, total $88,000, never reversed.

Show the numbers
 Fair value (ASU 2023-08)Cost less impairment (old model)
Jan 15$400,000$400,000
Mar 31$340,000$320,000
Jun 30$380,000$320,000
Sep 30$440,000$320,000
Dec 31$360,000$312,000

Look at September 30. Under fair value, the coins are on the books at $440,000 and you've recognized $100,000 of gains over Q2 and Q3. Under the old model they'd still be at $320,000, $120,000 below what they were worth. By December the gap narrows to $48,000 ($360,000 vs $312,000).

The P&L tells the other half of the story:

Quarterly effect on net income

Same 4 bitcoin, same made-up prices

  • Fair value gain or (loss)
  • Old model impairment
−$100k−$50k$0$50k$100kQ1 · Fair value gain or (loss): −$60,000Q1 · Old model impairment: −$80,000Q2 · Fair value gain or (loss): $40,000Q2 · Old model impairment: $0Q3 · Fair value gain or (loss): $60,000Q3 · Old model impairment: $0Q4 · Fair value gain or (loss): −$80,000Q4 · Old model impairment: −$8,000Q1Q2Q3Q4

Hypothetical example. Fair value total: −$40,000. Old model total: −$88,000.

Show the numbers
 Fair value gain or (loss)Old model impairment
Q1−$60,000−$80,000
Q2$40,000$0
Q3$60,000$0
Q4−$80,000−$8,000

For a software company earning, say, $150,000 a quarter, swings of $60,000 to $80,000 change the story your quarterly P&L tells. That's worth telling your lender about before they see it, and worth keeping in mind if any loan covenant is based on net income.

How is it presented and what do you disclose?

Balance sheet. In-scope crypto assets go on their own line, separate from other intangible assets. You can split them further (by type of asset, for example).

Income statement. Remeasurement gains and losses are shown separately from changes in the carrying amount of other intangibles, such as amortization or impairment. Many companies show a line like "Gain (loss) on crypto assets, net".

Cash flow statement. The ASU adds one specific rule (agree how your other crypto purchases and sales are classified with your auditor): if you accept crypto from customers as payment in the ordinary course of business and convert it to cash nearly immediately (Grant Thornton describes this as within hours or a few days, not weeks), the cash received is an operating cash flow.

Disclosures. Per Grant Thornton's summary:

ASU 2023-08 disclosures

Every reporting period (interim and annual)

  • For each significant holding: name, cost basis, fair value and number of units
  • Aggregate cost basis and fair value of holdings that aren't individually significant
  • Fair value of any crypto under contractual sale restrictions, plus the nature and remaining length of the restriction

Annual only

  • Rollforward from opening to closing balance: additions, dispositions, gains and losses
  • Description of the activities behind additions and dispositions
  • Your method for determining cost basis (for example specific identification, FIFO or average cost)

Track cost basis by lot from day one. You need it for the disclosures, and your CPA needs it for the tax return.

What about taxes?

This part trips people up. The accounting standard changes your books, not your taxes. The IRS says that for US tax purposes, digital assets are property, not currency. In general, you have a taxable gain or loss when you sell or exchange them, not when the price moves.

So in the example, the $40,000 fair value loss in 2026 is a book loss only. No coins were sold, so there's no tax loss. For a C corporation, that difference between book and tax usually creates a deferred tax item your CPA will need to calculate. If you sell in 2027, your tax gain or loss is measured from your tax basis (the $400,000 cost), not from the year-end book value.

Brokers now report too. The IRS says brokers report gross proceeds on Form 1099-DA for transactions on or after January 1, 2025, and basis for certain transactions on or after January 1, 2026. Reconcile those forms to your own lot records.

Common mistakes

Pulling the price from a random website. Fair value under ASC 820 means the price in your principal market (or most advantageous market) at the measurement date. Decide which exchange that is, document why, and use the same time of day consistently.

Carrying everything at fair value without checking scope. Stablecoins with redemption rights, NFTs and tokens you issued may not qualify. Check each asset against the six criteria.

Forgetting the transition entry. If you held crypto before adopting, the difference between the old carrying amount and fair value at the start of the adoption year goes to opening retained earnings, not through that year's P&L.

Mixing book and tax basis. Your books follow fair value; your tax return follows cost basis and sales. Keep both.

Ignoring restrictions. Coins that are staked, locked or pledged may carry sale restrictions you need to disclose.

When should you get help?

If you hold a small amount of one coin, buy and hold, and don't issue GAAP statements to anyone, a simple quarter-end fair value entry and a lot-by-lot purchase record will cover you. Your bookkeeper can do that.

Bring in your CPA and auditor when you have reviewed or audited statements, when crypto is material to your balance sheet or covenants, when you accept crypto from customers, or when you hold anything other than plain bitcoin or ether. Scope questions and principal market decisions are judgment calls your auditor will want documented. Fintrix Consulting can set up the quarter-end entries, lot tracking and year-end schedules as part of our accounting service; the tax side stays with your CPA.

Frequently asked questions

Is ASU 2023-08 already in effect?

Yes, for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2024. A calendar-year company has applied it since January 1, 2025. A company with a fiscal year starting July 1 first applies it to the year that began July 1, 2025.

Does it apply to private companies?

Yes. It applies to all entities that hold in-scope crypto assets, public or private, with the same effective date.

Do I pay tax on the fair value gains?

Generally no. The IRS treats digital assets as property, so you usually have a taxable gain or loss when you sell or exchange them, not when the price moves. Your CPA will track the difference between book and tax.

What price do I use at quarter end?

Fair value under ASC 820: the price in your principal market at the measurement date. Pick the exchange you normally trade on, document the choice and use it consistently.

What happens to impairments I recorded under the old model?

On adoption, you compared the old carrying amount with fair value at the start of the adoption year and recorded the difference in opening retained earnings. From then on, everything is fair value.

The bottom line

If your company holds bitcoin or a similar crypto asset, your balance sheet now shows what it's worth, and your P&L shows every swing. That makes your numbers more honest and a lot bumpier. Check each holding against the six scope criteria, pick and document a pricing source, keep lot-level cost records for the tax return, and warn your lender before a big quarter-end swing lands in net income.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.