Accounting standards
New income tax disclosures for private companies (ASU 2023-09)
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
If your company prepares GAAP financial statements and pays income tax itself (a C corporation, usually), ASU 2023-09 changes your tax footnote starting with fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2025, so calendar 2026 statements are the first. You'll disclose income taxes paid, net of refunds, split into federal, state and foreign, and name any single jurisdiction that makes up 5% or more of the total. Private companies don't need the numerical rate reconciliation table public companies give, but they must describe in words what pushes the effective rate away from the statutory rate.
Your auditor or reviewer is about to ask for a schedule you may never have built: every income tax payment you made in 2026, by jurisdiction, net of refunds. Not the tax expense on the P&L. The cash that actually went to the IRS, to each state and to any foreign tax authority.
That's the most visible change from ASU 2023-09, Improvements to Income Tax Disclosures, which the FASB issued on December 14, 2023. Public companies have been living with it since 2025. For private companies, the first year is now: fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2025.
This post covers who it affects, what a private company actually has to disclose, a worked example of the new taxes-paid table, and what to pull together before your year-end close.
FY 2026
First year for private companies: annual periods beginning after December 15, 2025
5%
Any single jurisdiction at 5% or more of total income taxes paid is shown on its own line
No table
Private companies describe the rate reconciliation in words instead of a numerical table
Who does ASU 2023-09 actually affect?
It changes the income tax footnote in financial statements prepared under US GAAP. So two things have to be true before you care:
- You issue GAAP financial statements to someone outside the business. Usually that's a bank, investors or a bonding company asking for reviewed or audited statements. If your only "financial statements" are the reports your bookkeeper sends you and the tax return your CPA files, nothing changes for you.
- The company itself pays income tax. In practice that means C corporations. An S corporation or a partnership generally passes its income through to the owners, so the entity-level tax footnote is thin to begin with. If you're a pass-through that pays any entity-level state taxes, ask your auditor whether they fall within the income tax footnote. That's a judgment call, not something to guess.
Honestly, for most small private C corporations with reviewed or audited statements, this is a footnote exercise, not a change in how you account for taxes. Your tax expense, your deferred taxes and your balance sheet don't change. What changes is how much detail you show, and the taxes-paid piece needs data you may not be capturing today.
What exactly do private companies have to disclose?
The standard has a public-company version and a lighter version for everyone else. Here's how the main pieces compare, based on RSM's and KPMG's summaries.
Effective 2025 for calendar years
Public business entities
- Numerical rate reconciliation table with specific required categories
- Reconciling items above a 5% threshold shown separately
- Income taxes paid by federal, state and foreign, plus jurisdictions at 5% or more
- Pretax income split domestic and foreign
- Tax expense split federal, state and foreign
Effective 2026 for calendar years
All other entities (private companies)
- No numerical reconciliation table required
- Describe in words the nature and effect of significant reconciling items, by category and by individual jurisdiction
- Income taxes paid by federal, state and foreign, plus jurisdictions at 5% or more
- Pretax income split domestic and foreign
- Tax expense split federal, state and foreign
So the three pieces that apply to a private company are:
- A written rate reconciliation. Explain what makes your effective tax rate differ from the statutory rate. The federal corporate rate is 21% (IRS Publication 542). If your effective rate is 26%, say what added the extra five points (state taxes, nondeductible expenses, a valuation allowance) and which jurisdictions drive it.
- Income taxes paid, disaggregated. Annually, net of refunds: federal, state and foreign totals, plus any individual jurisdiction that makes up 5% or more of total income taxes paid.
- Pretax income and tax expense, split. Income before tax, domestic vs foreign. Tax expense, federal vs state vs foreign.
The ASU also removed a couple of older requirements. RSM names two: the disclosure about changes in unrecognized tax benefits expected within the next 12 months, and the cumulative amount of certain temporary differences left unrecognized under Topic 740 exceptions. Small companies rarely had either, but check that your template no longer carries them.
A worked example: building the taxes-paid table
Say you run a 60-person industrial parts manufacturer organized as a C corporation, calendar year end, with audited statements for your bank. You sell into several states and have a small sales office in Canada. During 2026 you paid:
- federal estimated payments and the balance due on your 2025 return: $310,000
- Pennsylvania: $48,000
- New Jersey: $22,000
- Illinois: $9,000
- three other states together: $11,000
- Canada: $12,000
Total income taxes paid, net of refunds: $412,000. Five percent of that is $20,600, so any single jurisdiction at $20,600 or more gets its own line.
| Jurisdiction | Paid in 2026, net of refunds | Share of total | Shown separately? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal | $310,000 | 75.2% | Yes (federal total) |
| Pennsylvania | $48,000 | 11.7% | Yes, over 5% |
| New Jersey | $22,000 | 5.3% | Yes, just over 5% |
| Illinois | $9,000 | 2.2% | No, in other states |
| Three other states | $11,000 | 2.7% | No, in other states |
| State and local total | $90,000 | 21.8% | Yes (state total) |
| Canada | $12,000 | 2.9% | No, in foreign total |
| Foreign total | $12,000 | 2.9% | Yes (foreign total) |
| Total income taxes paid | $412,000 | 100% |
In the footnote, that becomes something like: federal $310,000; state and local $90,000 (of which Pennsylvania $48,000 and New Jersey $22,000); foreign $12,000; total $412,000.
State and foreign taxes paid against the 5% line
Hypothetical manufacturer, 2026. Federal ($310,000) left off so the smaller amounts are readable
Hypothetical example. Total paid: $310,000 federal + $90,000 state and local + $12,000 foreign = $412,000.
Show the numbers
| Income taxes paid, net of refunds | |
|---|---|
| Pennsylvania | $48,000 |
| New Jersey | $22,000 |
| Canada | $12,000 |
| Other states (3) | $11,000 |
| Illinois | $9,000 |
Notice New Jersey. At $22,000 it clears the line by $1,400. Next year, a slightly smaller New Jersey payment or a bigger federal one could drop it back into "other states". That's fine. The threshold is applied each year to that year's payments, so the list of named states can change.
Also notice what this table is not. It's cash paid during 2026, which mixes the balance due on your 2025 returns with 2026 estimated payments. It won't match your 2026 tax expense, and nobody expects it to.
How do you write the rate reconciliation in words?
Same manufacturer. Say pretax income for 2026 was $1,800,000 and total income tax expense was $468,000, an effective rate of 26%. At the 21% federal rate, you'd expect $378,000. Your tax advisor's provision shows what explains the other $90,000: mostly state income taxes, a smaller amount of nondeductible items, partly offset by a research credit.
A private company doesn't need to put those numbers in a table. A disclosure along these lines would cover the substance:
The key words are nature, effect, category and jurisdiction. Say what kind of item it is, which way it moved the rate, and which jurisdictions matter. Vague wording like "differences from the statutory rate arise from state taxes and other items" is exactly what the ASU was meant to replace.
What should you do before December 31, 2026?
The taxes-paid table is easy if you plan for it in December and miserable if you start in March. Here's the list.
In the books
- Record each income tax payment to a separate account or class by jurisdiction (federal, each state, each country)
- Record refunds against the jurisdiction that paid them, not as other income
- Keep franchise taxes, sales taxes and payroll taxes out of the income tax accounts
- Keep copies of payment confirmations for every estimated payment and extension payment
With your tax advisor
- Ask for the provision split into federal, state and foreign, current and deferred
- Ask which items drive the gap between 21% and your effective rate
- Confirm which jurisdictions are over 5% of total taxes paid
With your auditor or reviewer
- Agree on the footnote format early
- Agree on prospective adoption (the usual approach) or showing prior years too
- Ask whether any entity-level state taxes you pay belong in the footnote
If your chart of accounts lumps every tax payment into one "Taxes" account, fix that now. Splitting twelve months of payments after the fact is doable, but it's slow and it's where errors creep in.
Common mistakes
Disclosing tax expense instead of taxes paid. The new table is cash, net of refunds, during the year. Your P&L tax expense is a different number and belongs in a different part of the footnote.
Mixing in non-income taxes. Sales tax, payroll tax, property tax and many franchise taxes aren't income taxes. If they're sitting in the same GL account, your taxes-paid total will be wrong. Some states have taxes that look like a hybrid; ask your tax advisor how to classify them.
Netting refunds in the wrong place. A $15,000 state refund received in 2026 reduces that state's 2026 taxes paid. Booking it as "other income" overstates the payments.
Treating the 5% list as permanent. It's recalculated every year. A state can drop on or off.
Writing a reconciliation that says nothing. "Various permanent differences" won't do. Name the categories and the main jurisdictions.
Assuming it doesn't apply because you're private. Private companies get relief from the numerical table, not from the standard.
When should you involve your CPA or auditor?
If you're an S corporation or a partnership with compiled statements, or no outside financial statements at all, you can mostly skip this. Make sure your tax payments are cleanly recorded anyway, because your CPA needs that for the return.
If you're a C corporation with reviewed or audited GAAP statements, involve your tax advisor and your auditor before year end, not after. The provision work (current and deferred taxes, the rate drivers) is their territory, and the footnote wording should be agreed with your auditor. Where you can save everyone time is the data: a clean ledger with tax payments split by jurisdiction and reconciled to payment confirmations. That bookkeeping groundwork, plus the year-end schedules your auditor asks for, is the kind of work Fintrix Consulting handles as part of our accounting service. For the tax side, the business tax document checklist covers what your CPA will want from you.
Frequently asked questions
When do private companies have to adopt ASU 2023-09?
For annual periods beginning after December 15, 2025. For a calendar-year company, that means the December 31, 2026 financial statements. A company with a July 1 fiscal year first applies it to the year starting July 1, 2026. Early adoption is allowed for annual statements not yet issued or made available for issuance.
Do I have to restate prior years?
No. The standard is applied prospectively, though retrospective application to prior years presented is allowed. Most private companies will apply it to the current year only. Agree the approach with your auditor.
Does ASU 2023-09 change how much tax I pay?
No. It's a disclosure standard for financial statements. Your tax returns, payments and tax expense don't change, only what the footnote shows.
Does this apply to an LLC taxed as a partnership?
Usually very little, because the partnership itself doesn't pay federal income tax. If it pays any entity-level state taxes, ask your auditor whether those belong in the income tax footnote.
What counts toward the 5% threshold?
Each individual jurisdiction's income taxes paid, net of refunds, compared with total income taxes paid (net of refunds) for the year. Any jurisdiction at 5% or more of the total is shown separately.
The bottom line
ASU 2023-09 doesn't change your tax bill or your tax expense. For a private C corporation with GAAP statements, it adds a taxes-paid table by jurisdiction and asks for a real explanation of why your effective rate isn't 21%. The hard part is the data, so set up your ledger to track payments and refunds by jurisdiction before December 31, 2026. Then agree the footnote wording with your auditor early, while there's still time to fix gaps.
Sources
- ASU 2023-09: Expanded income tax disclosure requirements (RSM)
- FASB issues final standard on income tax disclosures (RSM)
- FASB issues ASU to disaggregate income tax disclosures (KPMG Financial Reporting View)
- New Accounting Standards and Upcoming Effective Dates for Public and Private Companies (BDO)
- Publication 542, Corporations (IRS)
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- CECL isn't just for banks: the bad-debt allowance for your receivables
November 18, 2026
- Bitcoin on your balance sheet: the fair value rules (ASU 2023-08)
November 18, 2026
- New GAAP for government grants received by businesses (ASU 2025-10)
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.