Accounting standards
Inventory reserves and write-downs: setting a reasonable reserve (ASC 330)
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Under ASC 330, inventory on FIFO or average cost is carried at the lower of cost and net realizable value (estimated selling price less costs to complete, sell and ship). LIFO and retail-method inventory still uses lower of cost or market. A reasonable reserve combines specific write-downs for items you know are impaired with percentages from an aging or slow-moving report, backed by your actual sales and scrap history. For tax, a general reserve usually isn't deductible: the IRS generally allows a write-down only when goods are actually sold, scrapped or offered for sale at a lower price.
Your stockroom has shelves of parts nobody has ordered in two years. A product line got discontinued in the spring. Tariffs pushed up what you paid for some items, but customers won't pay more for them. And your balance sheet still shows every one of those units at full cost.
That's an overstated balance sheet, and lenders and buyers look for it. The fix is an inventory reserve (or a direct write-down) that brings inventory down to what it can realistically be sold for.
This post covers the ASC 330 rule, how to build a reserve from an aging report, the journal entries, and why your tax return will usually treat it differently.
What does ASC 330 require?
The principle: inventory can't sit on the balance sheet at more than you'll get back from it, and the loss is recognized when value drops, not when you finally throw the stuff away.
How you measure "value" depends on your cost method. ASU 2015-11 split the rule in two:
FIFO, average cost, specific identification
Lower of cost and NRV
- Covers any method other than LIFO or the retail method
- NRV = estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less reasonably predictable costs of completion, disposal and transportation
- One number to estimate: what you'll net from selling it
- Most small and mid-sized businesses are here
LIFO and the retail method
Lower of cost or market
- The older test, kept for these methods only
- Market = current replacement cost, capped at NRV (the ceiling) and floored at NRV less a normal profit margin
- More estimates, more judgment
- Common for LIFO users and some retailers
ASU 2015-11 has been in effect for every company for years. If your policy note still says "lower of cost or market" and you're on FIFO, it should say net realizable value.
Two more rules worth knowing:
- A year-end write-down creates a new cost basis. Under US GAAP, if the item's value recovers next year, you don't write it back up. The CPA Journal's summary puts it plainly: write-downs may not be restored in future years.
- Interim write-downs are different. A write-down taken in a quarter can be restored in a later quarter of the same year if the decline turns out to be temporary.
Reserve or write-down: what's the difference?
In practice, both reduce inventory to its recoverable amount and hit cost of goods sold. The difference is mostly mechanics.
A direct write-down reduces the inventory item's cost itself. It works when you know exactly which units are impaired and your system can carry a reduced cost.
A reserve (a contra-asset account next to inventory) holds the estimated reduction while gross cost stays in the item records. Most businesses use one, because the estimate spans many items.
Either way, think of a reserved unit as having a new, lower cost. The reserve for that unit gets used up when it's sold or scrapped, not released into income because you'd rather have the profit back.
What makes inventory lose value?
The usual causes:
- Obsolescence. Discontinued products, superseded part numbers, outdated packaging or labels.
- Slow movement. More stock on hand than you'll sell in a reasonable period, even if it's perfectly good.
- Damage and expiry. Shopworn, broken, past shelf life.
- Selling price drops. Competitors cut prices, or a big customer renegotiates.
- Cost increases you can't pass on. If tariffs or freight push landed cost above what customers will pay, cost can exceed NRV even for fast-moving items.
That last one catches people out: a new shipment can be impaired on arrival.
How do you build a reserve from an aging report?
A practical reserve has two layers.
Layer 1: specific identification. Go through the items you know about: discontinued lines, damaged lots, items a customer has stopped buying. For each, estimate NRV (expected selling price less costs to sell) and reserve the difference from cost.
Layer 2: aging percentages on everything else. Pull an inventory aging report showing cost by time since last sale or receipt. Apply a reserve percentage to each bucket. The percentages should come from your own history: what share of stock in each age bucket did you end up scrapping or selling below cost over the last two or three years? A percentage you can't explain from history is a guess, and a reviewer will treat it as one.
Then sanity-check the total against last year's reserve, actual scrap losses and your inventory turns.
A worked example: an industrial parts distributor
Say you run a 30-person distributor of industrial valves and fittings, on FIFO. At December 31, 2026, inventory at cost is $1,200,000.
Specific item. A valve line was discontinued by its manufacturer. You hold 2,000 units at a cost of $30 each, $60,000. A liquidator has offered $12 a unit, and selling and shipping will cost about $2 a unit, so NRV is $10 a unit, or $20,000. Write-down needed: $40,000.
Aging on the remaining $1,140,000. Based on your scrap and markdown history over the last three years, you use these hypothetical rates:
| Months since last sale | Cost | Reserve rate | Reserve |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 to 6 | $700,000 | 0% | $0 |
| 7 to 12 | $230,000 | 10% | $23,000 |
| 13 to 24 | $130,000 | 30% | $39,000 |
| Over 24 | $80,000 | 70% | $56,000 |
| Discontinued valves (specific) | $60,000 | NRV | $40,000 |
| Total | $1,200,000 | $158,000 |
Inventory cost and reserve by age bucket
Industrial parts distributor, December 31, 2026
- Cost
- Reserve
Hypothetical example. Total cost $1,200,000; total reserve $158,000.
Show the numbers
| Cost | Reserve | |
|---|---|---|
| 0–6 mo | $700,000 | $0 |
| 7–12 mo | $230,000 | $23,000 |
| 13–24 mo | $130,000 | $39,000 |
| Over 24 mo | $80,000 | $56,000 |
| Discontinued | $60,000 | $40,000 |
Last year's reserve was $110,000. During 2026 you scrapped old stock that had been fully reserved at a cost of $25,000. So the reserve roll-forward is:
Inventory reserve roll-forward, 2026
- Adds to reserve
- Uses reserve
- Total
Show the numbers
| Opening reserve | $110,000 |
| Scrapped stock | −$25,000 |
| 2026 provision | +$73,000 |
| Closing reserve | $158,000 |
The 2026 provision is the plug that gets you from $85,000 (after using $25,000) to the required $158,000: $73,000.
Journal entries. First, when the reserved stock was scrapped:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Inventory reserve | $25,000 | |
| Inventory | $25,000 |
No P&L effect, because the loss was recognized in an earlier year when it was reserved. Then the year-end provision:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold (inventory write-down) | $73,000 | |
| Inventory reserve | $73,000 |
The balance sheet shows inventory of $1,200,000 less a $158,000 reserve: $1,042,000 net. The $73,000 goes through cost of goods sold, which lowers gross margin for the year. Our COGS calculator shows how beginning inventory, purchases and ending inventory feed that number.
How is an inventory reserve treated for tax?
Usually differently from your books, and this is where owners get surprised.
The tax regulations specifically list "deducting from the inventory a reserve for price changes, or an estimated depreciation in the value thereof" as a practice not in accord with the rules (Treas. Reg. 1.471-2(f)). The Supreme Court confirmed this in Thor Power Tool (1979): a write-down of excess inventory that followed GAAP was still disallowed for tax, because the company hadn't sold or offered the goods at lower prices.
What the regulations do allow for "subnormal" goods (damaged, shopworn, obsolete, odd lots and similar) is valuing them at a bona fide selling price less direct cost of disposition, where the bona fide price means an actual offering of the goods within 30 days after the inventory date. The IRS adds that you shouldn't value them below scrap value. For tax, LIFO inventory can't use lower of cost or market at all.
In the example, the discontinued valves might support a tax write-down to $10 a unit if they were actually offered at $12 within 30 days of year end. The $118,000 aging reserve generally would not be deductible until the stock is sold or scrapped. That's a book-tax difference your CPA tracks, on Schedule M-1 or M-3, and as a deferred tax item for a C corporation.
Smaller businesses have another layer. A small business taxpayer (average annual gross receipts of $32 million or less for 2026, and not a tax shelter) can skip traditional inventory accounting and either treat inventory as non-incidental materials and supplies or follow its financial statements or books and records, under section 471(c). How a book reserve works under those methods is a technical question. Ask your CPA rather than assuming the book number carries over.
Common mistakes
No reserve at all. Plenty of small companies carry every unit at cost until the day it's thrown out. The loss then lands in one bad month, often during a sale process.
Using a percentage nobody can explain. "We've always reserved 5%" isn't support.
Releasing the reserve to manage profit. Once reserved, a unit's lower cost sticks under GAAP. Reserve comes off when the unit is sold or scrapped.
Ignoring cost increases. If tariffs pushed landed cost above selling price, that stock needs an NRV test even if it's brand new.
Not counting first. Do the physical count and fix the item records before you age anything (our year-end bookkeeping checklist covers the count).
Assuming the tax return follows the books. It usually doesn't for general reserves. Flag the reserve to your CPA every year.
Before you estimate
- Physical count done and item records corrected
- Landed costs complete, including freight and duties
- Aging report run by months since last sale
The estimate
- Specific items reviewed: discontinued, damaged, expired, below-cost sellers
- Aging rates tied to scrap and markdown history
- Total compared with last year, actual write-offs and inventory turns
After
- Roll-forward prepared: opening, used, provision, closing
- Provision booked to a separate COGS account
- Book-tax difference flagged to your CPA
When should you get help?
If you carry a small amount of fast-moving stock and nothing has been sitting for a year, a simple specific-item review at year end may be all you need.
Get help when inventory is a big share of your assets, when a lender borrowing base depends on it, when your statements are reviewed or audited, or when you're preparing to sell. If you're a manufacturer or distributor, see how we work with manufacturing and distribution businesses. At Fintrix Consulting we reconcile inventory to your counts and tie it to the general ledger at every close, which is where a sound reserve starts; your CPA decides the tax treatment.
Frequently asked questions
What is a reasonable inventory reserve percentage?
There's no standard figure. A reasonable reserve is one you can support from your own scrap, markdown and sales history by age bucket, plus specific write-downs for items you know are impaired.
Can I reverse an inventory write-down if prices recover?
Not after year end under US GAAP: the written-down amount becomes the new cost. A write-down taken in an interim quarter can be restored later in the same fiscal year if the decline was temporary.
Does an inventory reserve reduce my taxes?
Usually not right away. Tax rules generally don't allow a deduction for a general reserve. Subnormal goods can be valued at a bona fide selling price less disposal costs if they're actually offered at that price within 30 days after the inventory date. Ask your CPA.
Does lower of cost and NRV apply to LIFO inventory?
No. LIFO and retail-method inventory still uses lower of cost or market under ASC 330. Everything else, including FIFO and average cost, uses lower of cost and net realizable value.
Where does the write-down go on the income statement?
Usually in cost of goods sold. Unusually large losses may be disclosed or shown separately; your CPA or auditor can advise on presentation.
The bottom line
Inventory should never sit on your balance sheet at more than you'll get back from it. Build the reserve from specific items you know about plus aging rates backed by your own history, roll it forward every year, and book it through a separate cost of goods sold account. Then hand the number to your CPA, because for tax most of it waits until the stock is actually sold, scrapped or offered at a lower price.
Sources
- Net realizable value is the new market (The CPA Journal, June 2018)
- 26 CFR § 1.471-2, Valuation of inventories (Cornell LII)
- Thor Power Tool Co. v. Commissioner, 439 U.S. 522 (1979) (Cornell LII)
- Publication 538, Accounting Periods and Methods (IRS)
- Small business taxpayer gross receipts limit for 2026 ($32 million), lib/tools/rates.ts
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Buying a business: the ASC 805 accounting checklist
November 18, 2026
- CECL isn't just for banks: the bad-debt allowance for your receivables
November 18, 2026
- Bitcoin on your balance sheet: the fair value rules (ASU 2023-08)
November 18, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.