Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Lawsuits and claims: when to book a loss and when to disclose it

November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
A wooden gavel resting on its sound block on a polished wooden desk, with a hand on the handle
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASC 450-20, you accrue a loss from a lawsuit or claim only when it's probable a loss has been incurred and you can reasonably estimate the amount. If you can only estimate a range and no amount in it is a better guess, you book the low end and disclose the rest. A loss that's reasonably possible (or probable but not estimable) gets a note, not an entry. Remote claims usually need neither. A lawsuit you might win is a gain contingency: you don't book it until it's realized.

It's January. You're closing December, and there's a letter on your desk from a former employee's lawyer. A customer is threatening to sue over a job that went wrong. Your insurer is handling a slip-and-fall from October, and nobody knows yet what it'll cost.

Do you put a number on the books, mention it in a note, or leave it alone? Get it wrong one way and your profit is overstated to a lender. Get it wrong the other way and you've booked a loss you didn't have to, maybe tripping a covenant for nothing.

US GAAP answers it in ASC 450-20, Loss Contingencies. Below: how the test works, a worked example and a sample note.

What counts as a loss contingency?

A contingency is an existing condition with an uncertain outcome that a future event will settle. Lawsuits, threatened claims, warranty problems and government investigations all qualify. The thing that might cost you money (the injury, the firing, the defective work) has to have happened by the balance sheet date. The lawsuit itself can come later.

How do probable, reasonably possible and remote differ?

ASC 450 sorts every loss into three buckets. The glossary definitions are short:

  • Probable: the future event is likely to occur.
  • Reasonably possible: the chance is more than remote but less than likely.
  • Remote: the chance is slight.

The standard gives no percentages, so judgment is required. In practice, PwC says "probable" is generally read as about a 75% or greater likelihood. That's higher than most owners assume. "We'll probably have to pay something" often means 50/50, which is reasonably possible, not probable.

What each likelihood means for your statements

Likely to occur

Probable

  • Accrue if you can reasonably estimate it
  • If not estimable: disclose the nature and say an estimate can't be made
  • Disclose any reasonably possible loss above the accrual

More than remote, less than likely

Reasonably possible

  • No journal entry
  • Disclose the nature of the claim
  • Give an estimate of the possible loss or range, or say one can't be made

Slight chance

Remote

  • No entry
  • Generally no disclosure, unless leaving it out would mislead

When do you actually book the loss?

Two conditions, both required, judged on information available before the statements are issued (or available to be issued):

  1. It's probable that a liability has been incurred at the balance sheet date.
  2. The amount of the loss can be reasonably estimated.

If both are met, you debit an expense (litigation or claims expense, usually in operating expenses) and credit an accrued liability. PwC's guidance says the accrual is classified current if you expect to settle within a year of the balance sheet date, noncurrent if not, and generally isn't discounted.

That "before the statements are issued" part matters. If a claim from a November accident settles in February, before your statements go out, the settlement is evidence for the year-end number. If the accident itself happened in January, you don't accrue anything at December 31. At most you disclose it as a subsequent event.

What if you can only estimate a range?

This trips people up more than anything else in ASC 450.

If one amount in the range is a better estimate than any other, accrue that amount. If no amount is better, accrue the minimum of the range, even though the final settlement will probably be higher. Then disclose the reasonably possible amount above what you booked.

So a lawyer who says "somewhere between $60,000 and $140,000, can't say where" means you book $60,000 and disclose up to $80,000 more. Booking the midpoint because it feels conservative is just a different wrong number.

A worked example: an HVAC contractor's year end

Say you run a 40-person commercial HVAC contractor with a December 31 year end. Before you think about any claims, the year's pretax profit is $520,000. Four legal matters are open as you close the books in January 2027:

  • Wage claim. A former technician claims unpaid overtime for himself and three coworkers. Your employment lawyer thinks a settlement is probable and estimates $60,000 to $140,000, with no amount in the range more likely than another.
  • Customer suit. A building owner sued for $250,000 over water damage after a rooftop unit install. Your lawyer thinks your defense is solid but wouldn't call a loss remote. Reasonably possible.
  • Injury claim. A delivery driver slipped on your loading dock in October. The claim is probable and your insurer's adjuster puts it at $45,000. Your policy has a $10,000 deductible, and the insurer has accepted coverage, so a $35,000 recovery is probable.
  • Your own lawsuit. You sued an equipment supplier for $120,000 over defective compressors. Your lawyer likes your chances.

Here's how each one lands:

MatterLikelihoodBooked at Dec 31Disclosed in the note
Wage claimProbable, range $60,000 to $140,000Liability $60,000 (the minimum)Nature, $60,000 accrued, up to $80,000 more reasonably possible
Customer suitReasonably possibleNothingNature, possible loss up to $250,000
Injury claimProbable, $45,000 estimateLiability $45,000; insurance receivable $35,000Usually not material once insured; disclose if it is
Suit against supplierGain contingencyNothingOptional, worded with care

The injury claim is shown gross. PwC's guide says insurance receivable shouldn't be offset against the liability, so the $45,000 liability and the $35,000 receivable sit separately on the balance sheet. In the income statement, the recovery generally goes in the same line as the loss, up to the amount of the loss. The net hit to profit is your $10,000 deductible.

From profit before claims to reported profit

HVAC contractor, pretax, year ended December 31, 2026

  • Adds to profit
  • Reduces profit
  • Total
$0$200k$400k$600kBefore claims: $520,000$520kBeforeclaimsWage claim: −$60,000−$60kWage claimInjury claim: −$45,000−$45kInjuryclaimInsurance recovery: +$35,000+$35kInsurancerecoveryReported profit: $450,000$450kReportedprofit

Hypothetical example. The customer suit ($250,000) and your own suit against the supplier ($120,000) don't touch profit.

Show the numbers
Before claims$520,000
Wage claim−$60,000
Injury claim−$45,000
Insurance recovery+$35,000
Reported profit$450,000

Reported pretax profit drops from $520,000 to $450,000. The $250,000 customer suit, the biggest number in the room, doesn't hit profit at all. Neither does the $120,000 you hope to win.

If the wage claim later settles for $95,000, you book another $35,000 of expense in the period it settles. That's a change in estimate, not an error, as long as the $60,000 was a fair reading of what you knew at the time. Our post on errors vs changes in estimate explains why that difference matters.

What goes in the note?

For accrued matters, describe the nature of the accrual and, where needed so the statements aren't misleading, the amount. For reasonably possible ones (and probable ones you can't estimate), describe the claim and give an estimate of the possible loss or range, or say that an estimate can't be made. Call it an "estimated liability" or "accrued litigation," never a "reserve." PwC is blunt about that one.

Here's roughly how the HVAC contractor's note could read. Your CPA or reviewer will shape the final wording.

The $120,000 suit against the supplier is missing on purpose.

What about a lawsuit you might win?

That's a gain contingency, and the rules run the other way. ASC 450-30 says a contingency that might result in a gain usually shouldn't be reflected in the financial statements. PwC's view is that you recognize the gain at the earlier of when it's realized or realizable, meaning you hold the cash or a claim to cash. A favorable jury verdict that's under appeal usually isn't there yet. A signed settlement with the check on its way generally is.

You can disclose a gain contingency, but without misleading implications about the likelihood of realization. "The Company has filed suit seeking $120,000" is fine. "The Company expects to recover $120,000" isn't. GAAP books bad news when it's probable and good news when it's in hand.

No. PwC's guide says including expected defense costs in the accrual is an accounting policy choice, applied consistently and disclosed. Most smaller companies expense legal fees as the bills come in, which is simpler. Whichever you pick, state it in the note.

How does this hit your taxes?

Book and tax part ways. For tort, breach of contract and similar liabilities, Treasury regulation 1.461-4(g) says economic performance happens as payment is made. So the $60,000 accrual cuts your 2026 GAAP profit, but the tax deduction generally waits until you pay. Flag every settlement to your CPA, since some payments (certain fines and penalties) may never be deductible.

Common mistakes

Booking the midpoint. If no amount in the range is the best estimate, ASC 450 says the minimum. The rest goes in the note.

Treating "probable" like 51%. In practice it's closer to 75%. A coin flip is reasonably possible: disclose, don't accrue.

Netting insurance. Booking only the $10,000 deductible hides both the liability and the receivable. Show them gross.

Ignoring a threat because nobody has sued yet. A demand letter in your inbox counts.

Booking the win. Recording the $120,000 you expect from the supplier, or offsetting it against the customer suit, isn't allowed.

Year-end legal matters checklist

Gather

  • List every lawsuit, demand letter, inquiry and insurance claim
  • Get each lawyer's likelihood and range in writing

Decide

  • Sort each matter: probable, reasonably possible or remote
  • Accrue the best estimate or the range minimum
  • Record probable insurance recoveries separately

Before you issue

  • Check for settlements or rulings since year end
  • Draft the note and state your legal costs policy

When should you get help?

If nobody outside reads your statements and the only claim is a small insured one, a short memo is enough. Get help when statements go to a bank or investors, when a claim is big enough to matter for a loan covenant or your going concern assessment, or when your statements are reviewed or audited (see audit, review or compilation). Your lawyer judges the likelihood; your CPA or auditor signs off on the note. Booking accruals as part of a reviewed monthly close is core to the accounting service at Fintrix Consulting; the likelihood and range still come from your lawyer.

Frequently asked questions

Do private companies have to follow ASC 450?

Yes, if they issue GAAP financial statements. ASC 450 applies to all entities. A few pieces of related SEC guidance, like the staff's views on discounting and legal costs, are written for public companies, though PwC suggests private companies consider them too.

Our lawyer won't give a probability. What do we do?

That's common, because lawyers are careful about what they put in writing. Ask instead for a range of likely outcomes and whether a loss is more likely than not. If you still can't estimate the loss, you disclose the claim and say an estimate can't be made. If your statements are audited, expect the auditor to ask your lawyer directly.

Should we book the full amount the plaintiff is asking for?

No. The amount demanded in a complaint is rarely the best estimate of the loss. Accrue what's probable and estimable, and disclose the possible exposure above it.

The bottom line

ASC 450 asks two questions about every claim: how likely is a loss, and can you put a number on it? Probable and estimable means an entry, at the range minimum if nothing stands out. Reasonably possible means a note. Remote usually means nothing, and a lawsuit you might win stays off the books until the money is real. Get your lawyer's view in writing before you close the year and show insurance gross.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.