Fintrix Consulting LLC

Taxes & your CPA

Selling in multiple states: what changes for your income taxes

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Open atlas showing a colorful map of the United States with each state outlined
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Selling into other states can make you owe state income or franchise tax there, not just sales tax. You generally have nexus if you have people, property or inventory in a state, and some states also tax businesses whose sales into the state pass a dollar threshold. A federal law, P.L. 86-272, protects sellers of physical products whose only activity in a state is soliciting orders, but it doesn't cover services, and states read its limits narrowly. Once you have nexus, your income is split among states with an apportionment formula, usually based on sales.

Your business started in one state. Now customers in a dozen states order from you, you've got a salesperson who lives three states away, and maybe some inventory sitting in a warehouse you've never seen.

Income tax is the part people miss. It runs on different rules, different thresholds and a different federal law, and the first notice you get from a state revenue department can cover several years at once.

This post covers state income and franchise tax nexus only. If you need the sales tax side, read our post on sales tax nexus first.

Is income tax nexus the same as sales tax nexus?

No, and the difference trips people up.

Sales tax nexus is about whether you must collect tax from your customers. Since the Wayfair decision, nearly every state with a sales tax uses a sales threshold for remote sellers.

Income tax nexus is about whether the state can tax your profit (or, for franchise taxes, your privilege of doing business there). The tests overlap, but they aren't identical, and a federal law that protects some sellers from income tax has no effect on sales tax at all.

QuestionSales taxState income or franchise tax
Who paysCustomer pays, you collectYour business (or its owners)
Typical remote-seller testSales or transactions into the state above a thresholdPhysical presence, plus a sales threshold in some states
P.L. 86-272 applies?NoYes, for net income taxes on sellers of tangible goods
How the tax is measuredEach taxable saleApportioned share of profit (or gross receipts or margin for some franchise taxes)

What creates income tax nexus?

Physical presence is the classic trigger. Employees working in the state, an office, a warehouse, inventory (including inventory a marketplace stores for you in its fulfillment centers), property you own or lease there, or people performing services there. Texas's franchise tax rule, for example, lists things like maintaining a place of business, having employees or representatives doing the entity's business, and storing inventory in Texas. If you have remote employees in other states, each one can create nexus where they work.

Economic nexus also applies in some states. A growing number of states say you can have income or franchise tax nexus from sales alone. Two examples:

  • Texas (franchise tax): an out-of-state entity with $500,000 or more of gross receipts from business done in Texas has nexus, even with no physical presence. Having nexus doesn't automatically mean tax is due, because Texas also has a no-tax-due threshold.
  • California (franchise tax): a business is "doing business" in California if, among other tests, its California sales exceed the lesser of an inflation-adjusted amount ($757,070 for 2025) or 25% of its total sales. Property or payroll in the state above $75,707 (2025) also counts. California's Office of Tax Appeals ruled in 2025 that these bright lines are not a safe harbor: a business below them can still be doing business there.

Other states have their own tests, and the amounts move. Check each state before you assume you're under a line.

What does P.L. 86-272 protect?

P.L. 86-272 is a 1959 federal law. It stops a state from imposing a net income tax on an out-of-state business whose only activity in the state is soliciting orders for sales of tangible personal property, where the orders are approved or rejected outside the state and filled by shipment or delivery from outside the state.

That's narrower than it sounds:

  • It only covers tangible goods. Sell services, software subscriptions or digital products and you get no protection.
  • It only covers net income taxes. Taxes measured by gross receipts or margin, like Ohio's commercial activity tax, Washington's B&O tax or Texas's franchise tax, are a separate question. Don't assume P.L. 86-272 helps.
  • Anything beyond solicitation can break it. A sales rep who also installs equipment, handles repairs, trains customers or collects overdue accounts in the state is doing more than soliciting orders.
  • Inventory in the state breaks it. Orders aren't being filled from outside the state if the goods ship from a warehouse inside it.

How do states treat online activity under P.L. 86-272?

In 2021 the Multistate Tax Commission revised its statement on P.L. 86-272 to cover internet activity. Its view: interacting with customers through your website can count as doing business in their state, beyond mere solicitation. The statement isn't law on its own; each state has to adopt it.

Some have. New York adopted rules along these lines, and in May 2026 a New York appeals court upheld them, finding they aren't preempted by federal law. California tried similar guidance, but a state court struck it down in late 2023 on procedural grounds. Expect this to keep shifting.

Online activities under the MTC's 2021 statement

Solicitation

Generally still protected

  • A static FAQ page for after-sale questions
  • Cookies used only for things like remembering a shopping cart
  • A site that lets customers browse, read product descriptions, buy and choose shipping

Treated as not protected

  • Regular post-sale help through a website chat or email the customer starts
  • Inviting people in the state to apply online for non-sales jobs
  • Cookies that gather data for product development or inventory planning
  • Fixing or upgrading products remotely over the internet
  • Selling extended warranties online
  • Using a marketplace that stores your inventory in the state

If you sell physical products online and rely on P.L. 86-272, look honestly at your website. A live chat widget that handles warranty questions may be enough, in states that follow the MTC's view, to lose the protection.

How does apportionment split your income?

Once you have nexus in more than one state, each state taxes only its share of your profit. That share comes from an apportionment formula.

Most states now use a single sales factor: your share is your sales into that state divided by your total sales. Only a handful still use the older three-factor formula of property, payroll and sales. Massachusetts, for example, moved to a single sales factor for 2025.

For services and intangibles, states also differ on where a sale happens. The older rule, cost of performance, sourced the sale to where the work was done. Most states have moved to market-based sourcing, which looks to where the customer is. That matters for a consulting firm in one state with clients in ten: under market-based sourcing, its receipts follow its clients.

A worked example: a kitchen equipment maker

Say you run a C corporation that makes commercial kitchen equipment in your home state. Last year it had $5,000,000 of sales and $800,000 of taxable income. Sales by state:

  • Home state: $2,400,000
  • State B: $1,200,000. You have a sales rep living there who also installs equipment and trains customers.
  • State C: $900,000. Orders come in through your website and a rep who visits customers, takes orders and sends them to head office for approval. Goods ship from your plant.
  • State D: $500,000. No people or property, all orders online. Assume it's below State D's economic nexus test.

Assume every state uses a single sales factor and taxes C corporations on net income.

StateSalesShare of total salesApportioned incomeLikely position
Home state$2,400,00048%$384,000Taxable
State B$1,200,00024%$192,000Nexus: installation and training go beyond solicitation
State C$900,00018%$144,000Possibly protected by P.L. 86-272, if the website stays within protected activity
State D$500,00010%$80,000No nexus in this example
Total$5,000,000100%$800,000

Taxable income apportioned by state

Single sales factor, $800,000 of taxable income

Home state (48%)Home state (48%): $384,000$384kState B (24%)State B (24%): $192,000$192kState C (18%)State C (18%): $144,000$144kState D (10%)State D (10%): $80,000$80k

Hypothetical example. Only states where the business has nexus can tax their share.

Show the numbers
Home state (48%)$384,000
State B (24%)$192,000
State C (18%)$144,000
State D (10%)$80,000

Two lessons. First, State B can tax $192,000 of income because one person does more than take orders. Second, State C's protection hangs on details: add a live support chat or a warehouse there and $144,000 more could become taxable.

What changes for LLCs and S corporations?

Pass-through entities usually don't pay income tax themselves (with exceptions). The apportioned income flows to the owners on their Schedule K-1, and each owner may owe tax in every state where the business has nexus, even states they've never visited.

States handle this in a few ways:

  • Nonresident withholding. Many states require the business to withhold tax on nonresident owners' share of in-state income.
  • Composite returns. The business files one return and pays tax on behalf of nonresident owners, so they don't each file. Iowa, for example, requires composite filing for pass-through entities with nonresident members for 2022 and later. Composite tax is often figured at the state's top rate, and owners can lose deductions or credits they'd get filing on their own.
  • Pass-through entity tax (PTET). Many states let the business elect to pay tax at the entity level. See how to account for PTET payments for the bookkeeping side.

These payments are often treated as distributions, so if owners are in different states, distributions can get uneven quickly. Track them by owner.

Common mistakes

Assuming no sales tax means no income tax. The two systems use different tests, and income tax nexus can exist where you don't collect sales tax (or the other way round).

Relying on P.L. 86-272 for services. It doesn't apply. A consulting or software business gets no protection from it.

Ignoring franchise and gross receipts taxes. Some states tax revenue or margin rather than profit, and P.L. 86-272 is about net income taxes.

Not tracking sales by state. Apportionment needs sales by state, sourced the way each state requires. If your books only show total revenue, your CPA has to rebuild it at year end.

When should you get help?

If you sell only in your home state and everyone works there, you can stop here. The moment you have an employee, rep, inventory or meaningful sales elsewhere, get your CPA to do a nexus review, ideally before a state finds you. Filing late often costs more than filing on time, and voluntary disclosure programs exist for a reason.

On the bookkeeping side, the job is having the data ready: sales by state and customer location, payroll by work state, and property and inventory locations. Keeping sales tax tracked and books tax-ready for your CPA is the kind of work Fintrix Consulting does, while your CPA decides where you file.

Frequently asked questions

Do I owe state income tax just because I sell to customers in that state?

Not always. Some states have an economic nexus test for income or franchise tax based on sales alone. Others need physical presence. And if you sell only physical goods and just solicit orders there, P.L. 86-272 may protect you from net income tax.

Does P.L. 86-272 apply to my LLC?

The law applies to the business activity, not the entity type, but it only protects sales of tangible personal property and only against net income taxes. How each state applies it to pass-through owners varies, so ask your CPA.

What is apportionment?

It's the formula that decides what share of your profit each state can tax. Most states now use a single sales factor: sales into the state divided by total sales.

Does a remote employee create income tax nexus?

Usually yes. An employee working in a state is physical presence, and if they do more than solicit orders for physical goods, P.L. 86-272 won't help.

What is a composite return?

A single state return a pass-through business files on behalf of its nonresident owners, paying their tax so they don't each file there. Rules and rates vary by state.

The bottom line

Selling across state lines changes your income tax picture, not just your sales tax. Physical presence still creates nexus, more states now use sales thresholds too, and P.L. 86-272 only helps sellers of physical goods who stick to soliciting orders, a line states keep drawing tighter for online activity. Track sales, payroll and property by state from the start, so when your CPA works out where you file and how income is apportioned, the numbers are already there.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.