Fintrix Consulting LLC

Payroll & 1099s

Payroll for remote employees in several states

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Top-down view of a woman typing on a laptop at a wooden home desk with headphones, notebook, mug and plant
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

As a rule, you withhold state income tax for the state where the employee physically does the work, which for a remote employee is usually where they live. Two exceptions matter: reciprocity agreements between neighboring states (withhold for the home state instead), and New York's convenience of the employer rule (work-from-home days can still count as New York days). Unemployment tax goes to one state per employee, chosen by a four-step test, and you need withholding and unemployment accounts in each state before the first payroll there.

You hired your best candidate. She lives three states away and will work from her kitchen table. Your payroll provider asks for her work location, and you realize every setting assumed people walked into your office.

Multistate payroll isn't hard once you see the pattern: each employee has a state (sometimes two) for income tax withholding, exactly one state for unemployment tax, maybe a local tax, and a new-hire report somewhere. Get those four right at hiring and the rest is routine.

This post walks through each piece, the exceptions that catch people, and a worked example for a 12-person company with people in five states.

Where the work is done

The starting rule for state income tax withholding

1 state

Unemployment tax for each employee, decided by a four-step test

20 days

Federal ceiling for reporting a new hire to the state (some states are shorter)

Which state do you withhold income tax for?

Start with where the employee physically works. A remote employee working from home in Ohio is working in Ohio, even if your office, your bank and your manager are all in another state. So you withhold Ohio tax, which means you need an Ohio withholding account.

States with no wage income tax (Texas and Florida, for example) are simpler: no state income tax withholding. You still owe their unemployment tax if the employee is assigned to that state, which we'll get to below.

Then there are the two exceptions.

What is a reciprocity agreement?

Some neighboring states agree not to tax each other's residents on wages. If an employee lives in one and commutes to work in the other, the employer withholds for the home state instead of the work state.

New Jersey and Pennsylvania are a well-known pair. Under their agreement, compensation paid to Pennsylvania residents working in New Jersey isn't subject to New Jersey income tax, and the same is true the other way round. The employee gives the employer a certificate (Form NJ-165 to stop New Jersey withholding, or Pennsylvania's REV-419EX to stop Pennsylvania withholding), and the employer withholds for the home state.

Three things to know:

  • It's not automatic. No certificate on file, no change. Get it at hiring.
  • You need an account in the home state. If you withhold New Jersey tax for a commuter, you must be registered with New Jersey.
  • It covers wages only. Other income still follows normal rules.

Reciprocity matters most for commuters. A fully remote employee who lives and works in the same state doesn't need it, because there's only one state involved.

What is the "convenience of the employer" rule?

This is the one that surprises people. New York says that if a nonresident's primary office is in New York, their days telecommuting count as days worked in New York, unless the employer has set up a bona fide employer office at the telecommuting location. Working from home in Connecticut because you prefer to doesn't move the income out of New York.

So a New York company with an employee who's assigned to the Manhattan office but works from home in New Jersey three days a week may still owe New York withholding on all of their wages. The employee's home state may then give them a credit for tax paid to New York, but that happens on their personal return, not in your payroll.

A few other states have been reported to apply similar rules. Check each state where you have an office and remote staff, rather than relying on a list.

Which state gets unemployment tax?

Unlike income tax, unemployment insurance (SUTA) can't be split. Each employee's wages are covered by one state, and states use the same four tests, applied in order. The first one that fits decides it:

  1. Localization: all of the work is in one state, apart from occasional, temporary trips. That state wins. Most remote employees stop here, because all their work happens at home.
  2. Base of operations: some work is in a state and the employee's base (where they start work and return to) is there.
  3. Direction and control: some work is in the state from which the employee is directed and controlled.
  4. Residence: some work is in the employee's home state.
Which state gets an employee's unemployment tax?
  1. Test 1

    Localization

    All work in one state, except incidental trips? That state. Stop here.

  2. Test 2

    Base of operations

    Some work in the state where the employee starts and returns from? That state.

  3. Test 3

    Direction and control

    Some work in the state where the employee is managed from? That state.

  4. Test 4

    Residence

    Some work in the employee's home state? That state.

Federal unemployment tax (FUTA) sits on top: 6.0% on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, normally cut to 0.6% by the credit for state unemployment tax paid. That credit depends on paying the right state on time, which is another reason to get the SUTA state right.

Do you need to register in every state where someone works?

Yes. Before the first payroll for an employee in a new state, you usually need:

  • a withholding account with the state revenue department (if the state taxes wages)
  • an unemployment account with the state workforce or labor agency
  • any local tax registrations (see below)
  • a plan for new-hire reporting

New-hire reports are due within 20 days of hire under federal law, and some states set shorter deadlines. Multistate employers can either report each new hire to the state where they work, or register as a multistate employer and report everyone to one state where they have employees. That choice is for new-hire reporting only and doesn't change where you withhold or pay unemployment tax.

Registering in a state for payroll can also bring other obligations, such as state labor law rules on paid leave and final paychecks. And having an employee there can create income or sales tax nexus for the business. Mention new states to your CPA when you hire, not at year end. Our post on sales tax nexus explains the sales tax side.

What about local income taxes?

Some states let cities, counties or school districts tax wages. Pennsylvania is the busiest example. Under Act 32, employers withhold local earned income tax at the higher of the employee's resident rate and the nonresident rate where they work, using six-digit PSD codes for both home and work location, and remit quarterly to the local tax collection district.

Other states have city or county income taxes too. When you add an employee anywhere new, look up local taxes by the full street address, not just the state. Payroll software usually does this if the address is complete.

A worked example: a 12-person company in five states

Say you run a 12-person software company with an office in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Annual payroll is $1,075,000. Here's where everyone works:

GroupEmployeesWagesWithholding stateUnemployment stateNotes
Pittsburgh office, PA residents6$540,000PennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaPlus Pennsylvania local earned income tax
Commutes to Pittsburgh from New Jersey1$90,000New Jersey (reciprocity)PennsylvaniaNeeds REV-419EX on file and a New Jersey withholding account
Fully remote, works from home in New York1$95,000New YorkNew YorkNo New York office, so the convenience rule doesn't come into it
Fully remote, Texas2$180,000None (no state income tax)TexasStill needs a Texas unemployment account
Fully remote, Florida2$170,000None (no state income tax)FloridaStill needs a Florida reemployment tax account
Total12$1,075,000

Count the accounts: withholding in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and New York (3), unemployment in Pennsylvania, New York, Texas and Florida (4), plus Pennsylvania local tax. Eight registrations for twelve people. The work scales with states, not headcount.

Wages by unemployment state

Hypothetical 12-person company with a Pittsburgh office

$0$200k$400k$600k$800kPennsylvania · Annual wages: $630,000Texas · Annual wages: $180,000Florida · Annual wages: $170,000New York · Annual wages: $95,000PennsylvaniaTexasFloridaNew York

Hypothetical example. Pennsylvania includes the New Jersey commuter (540,000 + 90,000), whose work is all in Pennsylvania. Total 1,075,000.

Show the numbers
 Annual wages
Pennsylvania$630,000
Texas$180,000
Florida$170,000
New York$95,000

Look at the New Jersey commuter: income tax goes to New Jersey (reciprocity), but unemployment tax goes to Pennsylvania, because all their work happens there (localization). The two systems follow different rules, so look at each one separately.

Common mistakes

Using the company's address for everyone. Payroll defaults to the office. Every remote employee needs their own work location in the system.

Missing a move. An employee relocates from Ohio to Colorado and tells their manager, not payroll. Months of withholding go to the wrong state. Ask employees to report address changes to payroll, and check addresses at least once a year.

Skipping registration in no-income-tax states. No state income tax doesn't mean no state payroll tax. Texas and Florida still want unemployment tax.

Forgetting the reciprocity certificate. Without it, you withhold for the work state and the employee has to file for a refund.

Assuming remote means the home state only. If the job is assigned to a New York office, New York may still claim the wages.

Our post on common payroll mistakes covers more of these, and payroll recordkeeping covers what to keep for each state.

Before the first payroll in a new state

Decide

  • Confirm where the employee will physically work and write it in the offer letter
  • Check for reciprocity with your office state
  • Check whether your office state has a convenience rule
  • Run the four unemployment tests

Register

  • State withholding account (if the state taxes wages)
  • State unemployment account
  • Local tax accounts for the work address
  • New-hire report within the state's deadline

Set up payroll

  • Enter the employee's full home and work addresses
  • Collect the state withholding form and any reciprocity certificate
  • Add the new state's filing calendar to your close checklist

When to get help

With everyone in one state, payroll software and a careful owner can handle it. If you're setting payroll up for the first time, our step-by-step guide is a good start.

Once you have people in three or more states, or anyone affected by reciprocity or a convenience rule, a second pair of eyes pays for itself. Fintrix Consulting runs payroll and keeps the filings on schedule for teams spread across states, with you approving every payroll before it goes out.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to withhold tax for the state where my remote employee lives?

Usually yes, because that's where they physically work. The exceptions are a convenience of the employer rule in your office state (New York, for example) and reciprocity agreements for commuters.

What if an employee works in two states during the year?

Withhold for each state based on where the work was done, which means tracking days. Unemployment tax still goes to one state, decided by the four tests.

Does hiring one remote employee create tax obligations beyond payroll?

It can. An employee in a state can create income tax or sales tax nexus for the business. Tell your CPA when you hire in a new state.

Can I just pay remote workers as contractors to avoid this?

Only if they really are contractors. Worker classification depends on how the relationship works, not what you call it, and misclassifying employees costs far more than registering in a state. Our post on employee or contractor walks through the tests.

My employee moved states mid-year. What do I do?

Register in the new state if you aren't already, update their work location from the move date, and collect the new state's withholding form. Wages before the move stay with the old state.

The bottom line

Each remote employee gets a withholding state, one unemployment state, possibly a local tax and a new-hire report. Start with where the work is physically done, then check for reciprocity and convenience rules, and run the four tests for unemployment. Register before the first payroll, keep addresses current, and the extra states become routine instead of a surprise notice.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.