Fintrix Consulting LLC

Payroll & 1099s

Form I-9 basics for small employers

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Two people shaking hands across an office desk with a laptop, a sheet of paper, a pen and glasses
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Every US employer, of any size, completes a Form I-9 for each new employee. The employee fills in Section 1 no later than their first day of work; you examine their documents and complete Section 2 within three business days of that first day. The employee chooses which acceptable documents to show. You keep the form on file (it isn't sent to the government) and reverify only when certain work authorization expires.

You've just made your first hire, or your fifth. The offer letter is signed, payroll is set up, and somewhere in the onboarding pile is a two-page federal form most owners have never looked at closely. It's easy to treat the I-9 as one more signature. It isn't.

The I-9 is how you show that you checked each employee's identity and permission to work in the US. Nobody reviews it when you complete it. It sits in a folder until the day an inspector asks for it, and by then any mistakes are years old.

Day 1

Section 1 completed by the employee, no later than the first day of work

3 business days

To examine documents and complete Section 2 after the first day

Any size

There's no small-employer exemption. One employee means one I-9

Who needs a Form I-9?

Every employee you hire to work in the United States, citizens included. USCIS's handbook is plain about it: you complete a Form I-9 each time you hire any person to perform labor or services in the US. There's no minimum number of employees.

A few people are outside the rule:

  • Independent contractors. If someone is genuinely a contractor, no I-9. Make sure they are, though; see our post on employee or contractor.
  • Workers supplied by a staffing agency, where the agency is the employer.
  • Casual domestic workers in a private home, on a sporadic basis.
  • People not physically working in the US.
  • Employees hired on or before November 6, 1986 who've stayed in continuous employment.

Which edition of Form I-9 should you use?

USCIS lists the 01/20/25 edition as current. You'll find the edition date at the bottom of each page. USCIS also allows the 08/01/23 edition that carries an expiration date of 05/31/2027 at the top of the page. The 08/01/23 version marked to expire 07/31/2026 is no longer valid, and electronic I-9 systems had to move to the 05/31/2027 version by July 31, 2026.

The quick test: download the form from uscis.gov when you hire, rather than reusing a blank one from a drawer. If you use a payroll or HR system that generates I-9s, check that it updated.

What does the employee fill in, and when?

The employee completes Section 1 no later than their first day of employment. That's their name, address, date of birth, citizenship or immigration status, and signature.

Three details trip people up:

  1. Not before the offer is accepted. You can't ask someone to fill out Section 1 until they've accepted the job.
  2. Social Security number is optional, unless you use E-Verify, in which case the employee must provide it.
  3. Preparers and translators who help an employee complete Section 1 sign a separate certification (Supplement A). The employee still signs Section 1.

You're responsible for the whole form, including Section 1. Read it before you complete Section 2, and if something's missing or wrong, have the employee correct it.

What does the employer do in Section 2?

You examine the employee's original documents and complete Section 2 within three business days of the day employment begins. If someone starts on Monday, Section 2 is due by Thursday. If you hire someone for less than three business days, Section 2 is due on their first day.

A Monday start, step by step
  1. After the offer is accepted

    Send the form

    Give the employee Form I-9 and the list of acceptable documents. Don't tell them which documents to bring.

  2. Monday (day 1)

    Section 1 done

    The employee completes and signs Section 1 no later than their first day.

  3. Monday to Thursday

    Examine documents

    Look at the original documents in person, or by live video if you qualify for the remote option.

  4. By Thursday

    Section 2 signed

    The person who examined the documents completes and signs Section 2.

  5. After that

    File it

    Store the I-9 with any document copies, separately from the personnel file.

The person who looked at the documents must be the one who signs Section 2. Documents must be originals (a certified copy of a birth certificate is the one exception), unexpired, and must reasonably appear genuine and relate to the person showing them.

Which documents are acceptable?

The employee picks from three lists and shows either one List A document, or one List B document plus one List C document.

ListWhat it provesCommon examples
AIdentity and work authorizationUS passport or passport card, Permanent Resident Card, Employment Authorization Document
BIdentity onlyDriver's license or state ID card, school ID with a photo, US military card
CWork authorization onlyUnrestricted Social Security card, US birth certificate with an official seal

The rule that matters most: the employee chooses. You can't ask for a particular document, such as "bring your green card" or "we need a passport." If someone hands you a valid List A document, you don't ask for anything else. USCIS treats asking for more or different documents than the form requires as a possible form of unlawful discrimination, even when it's well-meant.

Can you check documents remotely?

Only if you use E-Verify. Employers enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing can use a DHS-authorized alternative to the in-person check:

  1. The employee sends copies of their documents (front and back if two-sided).
  2. You hold a live video call where the employee shows the same documents.
  3. You keep clear copies of the documents.
  4. You check the alternative procedure box in Section 2's Additional Information field.

If you offer remote checks at a hiring site, offer them consistently to everyone there. You can limit them to remote hires and examine documents in person for on-site staff, as long as you don't treat people differently based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin.

E-Verify itself is voluntary for most employers, but federal contracts with the E-Verify clause, and some state laws, make it mandatory. Either way, you still complete a Form I-9 for every new hire.

When do you reverify an employee?

Only when an employee's work authorization has an expiration date, such as an Employment Authorization Document. You reverify no later than the date it expires, using Supplement B, which you attach to the original form.

You never reverify US citizens or noncitizen nationals. You also don't reverify when a US passport, passport card, Permanent Resident Card or List B document expires. Asking a green card holder for a new card because theirs expired is a common, well-meant mistake.

If you rehire someone within three years of the date their original I-9 was completed, you can complete a block on Supplement B instead of a new form, or simply complete a new I-9.

A worked example: a small employer's I-9 self-check

Say you run a bakery with 24 current employees, and you decide to check every I-9 file before the year ends. Here's what you find.

What a 24-file I-9 self-check found

Hypothetical bakery with 24 current employees

Complete and correctComplete and correct: 1515Section 2 signed lateSection 2 signed late: 44Retired form editionRetired form edition: 22Document details missingDocument details missing: 22No I-9 on fileNo I-9 on file: 11

Hypothetical example. 15 + 4 + 2 + 2 + 1 = 24 files.

Show the numbers
Complete and correct15
Section 2 signed late4
Retired form edition2
Document details missing2
No I-9 on file1
FindingFilesHow to fix it
Complete and correct15Nothing to do
Section 2 completed after the three-day deadline4Can't be undone. Don't change the date. Attach a short signed note explaining what happened and fix the process
Old edition used at the time2Ask your advisor whether to leave it or complete a new form; either way, use the current edition from now on
Document title or number missing in Section 22Re-examine if needed, line through, add the correct information, initial and date it, attach an explanation
No I-9 at all1Complete one now with today's date. Never backdate. Attach an explanation

USCIS's guidance on corrections is consistent: line through the wrong entry, write the correct information, initial and date the change, and attach a written explanation. Section 1 errors are corrected by the employee; Section 2 errors by you. No white-out, no erasing, no backdating. Hidden changes look worse than honest corrections.

How long do you keep I-9s, and what about inspections?

You keep each I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Our post on payroll recordkeeping walks through the math with examples, so we won't repeat it here.

If Immigration and Customs Enforcement serves a Notice of Inspection, you get at least three business days to produce your forms. Technical or procedural errors found in an inspection generally get at least ten business days to fix before they're treated as substantive violations. Fines are assessed per form and the amounts are adjusted for inflation every year, which is why a clean drawer of I-9s is worth an afternoon now.

Common mistakes small employers make

Doing it on day five. The Section 2 clock is three business days. Make the I-9 part of the first day, not something to catch up on later.

Asking for specific documents. "We need your Social Security card" sounds harmless. It isn't allowed.

Reverifying people who don't need it. Citizens and green card holders aren't reverified.

Filing I-9s in personnel files. Keep them together in their own folder or system so you can hand them over without exposing everything else.

Using the wrong form. A blank I-9 saved years ago is probably a retired edition. Download a fresh one for each hire.

When should you get help?

If you hire a few people a year, you can handle I-9s yourself with the USCIS handbook and the steps above. Plenty of small employers do it well.

Get help from an employment attorney or HR professional if you find widespread problems in a self-check, receive a Notice of Inspection, or aren't sure whether a document is acceptable. The I-9 stays your responsibility as the employer. If payroll itself is eating your afternoons, Fintrix Consulting's payroll and AP service keeps the payroll run and filings on schedule, with you approving every payroll before it goes out. Our guide on setting up payroll covers the rest of the new-hire paperwork.

Frequently asked questions

Do I send the Form I-9 to the government?

No. You keep it on file and produce it only if an authorized agency asks for it.

Do I have to keep copies of the employee's documents?

If you use the remote option as an E-Verify employer, yes: you must keep clear copies. Otherwise, check the USCIS handbook before deciding, and if you do keep copies, store them with the I-9 and treat every employee the same way.

What if a new hire doesn't have their documents yet?

In some cases they can present an acceptable receipt instead of the document for a limited time. USCIS's handbook lists which receipts count and how long each one is valid.

Do I need an I-9 for a part-time or seasonal employee?

Yes. Part-time, seasonal and temporary employees on your payroll need one. If the job lasts less than three business days, both sections are due on the first day.

Can I fill out Section 2 using a photo the employee texts me?

Only if you're enrolled in E-Verify and follow the full remote procedure, including a live video call. Otherwise you must examine the original documents in person.

The bottom line

The Form I-9 isn't complicated, but it's unforgiving about timing. Use the current edition, have the employee complete Section 1 by their first day, examine original documents and sign Section 2 within three business days, and let the employee choose which documents to show. Reverify only when work authorization actually expires, fix errors openly rather than hiding them, and keep the forms in their own folder. An hour of checking your files this year is far cheaper than finding problems during an inspection.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.