Fintrix Consulting LLC

Payroll & 1099s

Payroll recordkeeping: what to keep and for how long

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Stack of thick ring binders packed with paper documents on an office desk
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Keep payroll tax records (W-4s, wage payments, deposits, filed 941s and W-2s) for at least 4 years after the tax was due or paid, whichever is later. Keep FLSA payroll records for 3 years and the timecards and rate tables behind them for 2 years. Keep each Form I-9 for 3 years after hire or 1 year after the person leaves, whichever is later. State rules can be longer, so the simplest safe habit is to keep everything payroll-related for at least 5 years after the year it belongs to.

A former employee emails asking for proof of her pay from three years ago. Or a state labor office sends a letter about overtime. Or the IRS asks why the Form 941 totals don't match the W-2s for a year you barely remember. Each of these is a records question, and the answer you can give depends entirely on what you kept and whether you can find it.

Most small employers don't lose this because they kept nothing. They lose it because the records are split between an old payroll provider, a shared drive with no folders and a filing cabinet in someone's garage.

Below: what federal law makes you keep, for how long, when each clock runs out, and a retention plan simple enough to follow. If you're still setting payroll up, start with how to set up payroll and come back here.

4 years

Minimum for IRS employment tax records, after the tax is due or paid

3 years

Minimum for payroll records under the Fair Labor Standards Act

3 business days

How long you have to produce Forms I-9 when an inspector asks

Which laws decide how long you keep payroll records?

At the federal level, four sets of rules overlap, and each starts its clock on a different day:

  • The IRS cares about employment taxes: what you withheld, what you deposited, what you filed.
  • The Department of Labor (FLSA) cares about wages and hours: whether non-exempt people got minimum wage and overtime.
  • USCIS cares about Form I-9, which proves each employee may work in the US.
  • FMLA and the EEOC add leave records and personnel records for employers they cover.

Then your state adds its own rules on top, for unemployment insurance, wage payment and state income tax withholding. Some states ask for longer than the federal minimums. Check with your state labor and revenue departments.

You don't get to pick the shortest rule. One pay stub is evidence for the IRS, the DOL and your state at once, so it has to survive the longest clock.

What does the IRS make you keep, and for how long?

The IRS says to keep employment tax records for at least four years after the date the tax becomes due or is paid, whichever is later, and to have them available for review. Its list:

IRS employment tax records to keep (at least 4 years)

About the business and the people

  • Your employer identification number (EIN)
  • Names, addresses, Social Security numbers and occupations of employees
  • Each employee's dates of employment
  • Forms W-4 (and W-4P, W-4S, W-4V where used)

About the pay

  • Dates and amounts of every wage payment
  • Tips employees reported to you, and any allocated tips
  • Fair market value of any wages paid in kind
  • Fringe benefits and expense reimbursements, with the substantiation
  • Pay during sickness or injury absences, including third-party sick pay

About the taxes

  • Dates and amounts of tax deposits, with EFTPS acknowledgment numbers
  • Copies of filed returns (941, 940, W-2, W-3) and their confirmation numbers
  • Employee copies of Forms W-2 and W-2c that came back undeliverable
  • Documentation for any credits you claimed

Two exceptions push the clock out. Wage records for qualified sick and family leave taken after March 31, 2021, and for employee retention credit wages paid after June 30, 2021, need to be kept for at least six years. If you claimed either, put those files in their own folder and label them.

One thing is new for 2026. Employers must now report qualified overtime compensation (the "half" in time-and-a-half that the FLSA requires) and cash tips reported to them separately on Form W-2, in box 12 with codes TT and TP. So your records need the FLSA overtime premium on its own, by employee. If your system can't produce it, fix that before December payroll.

What does the FLSA make you keep?

The Fair Labor Standards Act requires records for every non-exempt employee (anyone you owe overtime to). No particular format is required, but the information has to be accurate and complete:

RecordIncludesKeep for
Employee detailsFull name, SSN, address, birth date if under 19, sex, occupation3 years
Workweek and pay basisDay and time the workweek starts, how pay is set (hourly, weekly, piece), regular hourly rate3 years
HoursHours worked each day and each workweek3 years
EarningsStraight-time earnings, overtime earnings, additions and deductions, total wages each period3 years
Pay datesDate paid and the period it covers3 years
Supporting recordsTime cards, piecework tickets, wage rate tables, work schedules, records of additions to and deductions from wages2 years

The three-year list is the payroll register. The two-year list is what the register was built from. If a time card and the register disagree, the DOL will want to see both. Records can sit at the workplace or in a central records office, which today usually means your payroll system or a cloud folder.

How long do you keep a Form I-9?

The I-9 has its own rule. USCIS says you keep a Form I-9 for 3 years after the date of hire, or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later, and for as long as the person works for you. Any copies of identity documents you took go with the form and follow the same clock.

You only calculate the date when someone leaves. USCIS gives a shortcut:

  • If they worked for you less than two years, keep it three years from their first day.
  • If they worked more than two years, keep it one year from their last day.

You can store I-9s on paper, microfilm or electronically, onsite or offsite, but you must be able to produce them within three business days of an inspection request. We'd keep them in their own folder, apart from personnel files, so you can hand over the I-9s without handing over everything else.

What about FMLA and EEOC records?

If you're covered by the Family and Medical Leave Act (generally employers with 50 or more employees), you keep FMLA records for at least three years: basic payroll data, dates of FMLA leave, hours if leave was taken in less than full days, copies of leave notices, benefit premium payments and records of any disputes. Medical certifications go in separate confidential files, never in the regular personnel file.

The EEOC requires covered employers to keep personnel records for one year (from the termination date for someone you let go), payroll records for three years under the age discrimination law, and records explaining pay differences between men and women for at least two years. If a charge is filed, keep everything relevant until it's resolved.

A worked example: when can you shred one employee's records?

Say you run an 18-person cafe. Maria, a shift lead, was hired on March 1, 2021 and left on June 30, 2026. She was non-exempt and worked some overtime. Here's when each federal clock lets you destroy her 2026 records, counting from her last day for simplicity:

RecordRuleEarliest federal shred date
Form I-9Worked more than 2 years, so 1 year after her last dayJune 30, 2027
Time cards and schedulesFLSA supporting records, 2 yearsJune 30, 2028
Payroll register entriesFLSA payroll records, 3 yearsJune 30, 2029
W-4, wage payments, 941s, W-2IRS, 4 years after the tax is due or paidFebruary 1, 2031

The last row is the one people get wrong. Her 2026 wages are reported on the fourth-quarter 2026 Form 941, which is due February 1, 2027 (January 31 falls on a Sunday). Four years after that is February 1, 2031, more than four and a half years after she left.

Months you must keep Maria's 2026 records after her last day

Federal minimums only. State rules may be longer

Form I-9Form I-9: 1212Time cardsTime cards: 2424Payroll registerPayroll register: 3636Tax recordsTax records: 5555

Hypothetical example. Counted from June 30, 2026. Tax records run to about February 1, 2031, four years after the 2026 fourth-quarter Form 941 due date.

Show the numbers
Form I-912
Time cards24
Payroll register36
Tax records55

A "shred it after three years" habit would destroy her tax records almost two years early.

A retention plan that's simple enough to follow

Tracking four clocks per employee is how records end up kept forever or thrown out at random. A simpler rule covers the federal minimums with room to spare:

Then make it physical (or digital) enough to work:

  • One folder per year, with subfolders for registers, tax filings, time records and benefits. Not one folder per employee for tax records, because audits come by period, not by person.
  • I-9s in their own folder, with a leave date written on each former employee's form.
  • Download your reports every quarter. Your payroll provider keeps records while you're a customer. When you switch, access often ends or becomes a paid request. Quarterly 941s, the year-end W-2 and W-3 copies and the annual payroll register should live in your own storage.
  • Shred on a schedule. Each January, destroy the year that just aged out. Old records full of Social Security numbers are a risk too.

Common payroll recordkeeping mistakes

Trusting the payroll provider to be your archive. The data is there right up until you switch providers.

Keeping the register but not the time records. Overtime disputes are decided on hours, and hours live in the time records.

No record of the overtime premium. For 2026 W-2s, you need the FLSA-required overtime premium by employee. Blended "OT pay" lines that include voluntary premiums or bonuses make that number hard to produce.

Mixing medical records into personnel files. FMLA certifications and doctor's notes need confidential, separate storage. Keep I-9s apart too, so an inspector doesn't get performance reviews along with them.

For the payroll errors these records would help you defend, see common payroll mistakes. For records outside payroll, the business tax document checklist covers the rest of what your CPA will ask for.

When should you get help?

If you have a handful of employees, a reputable payroll provider and the discipline to download reports each quarter, you can run this yourself. A shared drive and a calendar reminder go a long way.

Get help when records are spread across old providers, when you've claimed payroll credits and aren't sure what supports them, when you have employees in several states, or when an agency letter arrives and nobody can find the year it asks about. At Fintrix Consulting, our payroll service keeps your payroll runs and filings on schedule, with every payroll approved by you before it goes out.

Frequently asked questions

Can I keep payroll records electronically?

Yes. The FLSA doesn't require any particular form, FMLA records can be kept in automated systems, and USCIS allows electronic I-9s. What matters is that the records are complete, readable and quick to produce.

Does my payroll provider keep the records for me?

While you're a customer, usually yes. But the legal duty to keep them is yours. Download quarterly and year-end reports to storage you control, especially before you switch providers.

What about contractors?

Contractors aren't on payroll, but keep their Form W-9, the 1099s you filed and the payment records for at least as long as your other tax records. See 1099-NEC vs 1099-MISC for the forms themselves.

The bottom line

Federal law gives you four different clocks: 2 years for time records, 3 for payroll registers, 4 after the tax is due for tax records, and the I-9's own "later of" rule. Rather than tracking them one by one, keep everything for five years after the year it belongs to, check that your state doesn't ask for longer, and download your provider's reports to your own storage every quarter. Then shred on a schedule, because old records full of Social Security numbers are a risk too.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.