Accounting standards
Allocating nonprofit expenses: program, admin and fundraising
November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Under GAAP (ASU 2016-14), every nonprofit shows its expenses by function (program services, management and general, fundraising) and by nature (salaries, rent, supplies) together in one place. Costs that clearly belong to one function go there directly. Shared costs are split with a documented, reasonable basis, usually time records for salaries and square footage for occupancy, and the method is described in the notes. Mailings that mix a program message with a donation ask can only be split if they pass the purpose, audience and content tests in ASC 958-720; otherwise they're all fundraising.
Your executive director runs the food distribution on Saturdays, meets with the finance committee on Tuesdays and spends half of every December writing appeal letters. In the books, her whole salary sits in one account. So does the rent, the software and the spring newsletter that asked for donations and explained how to sign up for meal deliveries. Then the auditor or the Form 990 preparer asks how much of all that was "program."
Below: what the standard requires, the usual allocation methods, a worked example, the joint cost rules and how it lands on Form 990.
What does GAAP actually require?
ASU 2016-14 changed nonprofit financial statements starting with calendar 2018 year ends. On expenses, it requires three things, as the Journal of Accountancy summarized when it took effect:
- Expenses by nature and by function, in one location. You can put the analysis on the face of the statement of activities, in a separate statement of functional expenses, or in the notes.
- A description of your allocation method. The notes have to explain how you split costs among program and support functions.
- Investment expenses netted against investment return. External and direct internal investment expenses are netted against the return and left out of the nature and function analysis.
The three functions mean specific things:
Your mission
Program services
- Activities that carry out the organization's purpose
- Direct staff, supplies and the space they use
- Supervisors' time spent directly running programs
Running the organization
Management and general
- Board and committee meetings
- Finance, accounting, audit and general legal
- HR and other centralized services
- General liability insurance and the annual report
Asking for support
Fundraising
- Campaigns, appeals and donor software
- Soliciting grants and bequests
- Overhead that supports fundraising
One point from BDO's review of how organizations implemented the standard: only allocate a management and general cost out to a program if it's needed for the direct conduct or supervision of that program. The CEO's time on general operations stays in management and general.
Which costs need allocating, and how?
Most expenses need no method: a case manager's salary is program, the audit fee is management and general, the donor database is fundraising. Code those directly. What's left are shared costs: multi-role salaries, occupancy, technology and mixed mailings. For these, pick a basis that reflects how the cost is really used, write it down and apply it all year.
| Shared cost | Usual basis | What you need to support it |
|---|---|---|
| Salaries, payroll taxes and benefits of multi-role staff | Time spent on each function | Timesheets or periodic time studies |
| Rent, utilities, building depreciation | Square footage used by each function | A floor plan with each area labeled |
| Software, phones, office supplies | Headcount or FTEs by function | A staff list with each person's function |
| Mixed mailings and campaigns | Physical units, relative direct cost or stand-alone cost (only if the ASC 958-720 tests are met) | Copies of the piece and the mailing list criteria |
The IRS instructions for Form 990 make the time-based point bluntly: if an employee spends 40% of her time on fundraising and 60% on program management, you allocate 40% and 60%. You can't put all of it in program because she spent most of her time there.
Square footage works the same way. CBIZ gives an example of a 3,500 square foot space where 2,500 square feet is used for programs: 71.4% of occupancy goes to program.
A worked example: a community food bank
Say you run a community food bank with about $1,000,000 of expenses in 2026. Most costs are coded directly, but $256,000 is shared:
- Executive director, $120,000 (salary, taxes and benefits). Her time log shows 50% running programs, 30% general management and 20% fundraising.
- Rent and utilities, $96,000. The warehouse and distribution floor are 80% of the space, the finance and admin offices 15%, the development office 5%.
- Technology and office, $25,000, split by FTEs: 6 program, 2.5 management and general, 1.5 fundraising, out of 10.
- The spring mailing, $15,000 of joint costs, split 40% program and 60% fundraising. More on why below.
Here's the full statement of functional expenses:
| Expense (by nature) | Program | Management and general | Fundraising | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Program staff | $300,000 | $300,000 | ||
| Executive director (time: 50/30/20) | $60,000 | $36,000 | $24,000 | $120,000 |
| Finance and admin manager | $70,000 | $70,000 | ||
| Development director | $50,000 | $50,000 | ||
| Food purchased and distributed | $210,000 | $210,000 | ||
| Rent and utilities (sq ft: 80/15/5) | $76,800 | $14,400 | $4,800 | $96,000 |
| Truck and delivery costs | $40,000 | $40,000 | ||
| Audit and accounting | $28,000 | $28,000 | ||
| Insurance (vehicle / general liability) | $10,000 | $14,000 | $24,000 | |
| Donor software and appeal advertising | $22,000 | $22,000 | ||
| Spring mailing, joint costs (40/60) | $6,000 | $9,000 | $15,000 | |
| Technology and office (FTEs: 60/25/15) | $15,000 | $6,250 | $3,750 | $25,000 |
| Total | $717,800 | $168,650 | $113,550 | $1,000,000 |
Now look at what the allocation does. Before it, the $256,000 of shared costs sits in a pile that nobody has assigned. After it, every dollar has a home:
Expenses by function, before and after allocating shared costs
Hypothetical community food bank, $1,000,000 of 2026 expenses
- Direct costs only
- After allocation
Hypothetical example. Program expense ratio after allocation: 717,800 ÷ 1,000,000 = 71.8%.
Show the numbers
| Direct costs only | After allocation | |
|---|---|---|
| Program | $560,000 | $717,800 |
| Mgmt and general | $112,000 | $168,650 |
| Fundraising | $72,000 | $113,550 |
| Shared, unallocated | $256,000 | $0 |
71.8%
Program expense ratio after allocation
$256,000
Shared costs that needed a method
$15,000
Joint mailing costs tested under ASC 958-720
If you'd left the shared costs in management and general (a common default in small organizations' books), the program ratio would have been 56%. Same work, different bookkeeping.
What are joint costs, and when can you split them?
A joint activity combines fundraising with a program or management purpose: a newsletter with a donation envelope, an event that's also a health screening, a phone campaign that also signs people up for services. Joint costs are the costs you can't tie to one piece, like the printing and postage of a single mailing that does both.
Under ASC 958-720, you can split joint costs only if the activity meets all three criteria. As the Journal of Accountancy explains them:
Purpose
- The program part calls for a specific action that helps the mission (not just "learn about us" and not "give")
- No one working on any part of the activity is paid mainly based on contributions raised (a commissioned fundraiser fails this)
Audience
- The audience was chosen because it needs or can act on the program message
- If it's prior donors or people picked for their likelihood to give, presume it's all fundraising unless there's strong evidence otherwise
Content
- The material actually supports the program or management function
- A thank-you note or token gift tucked in a donation ask doesn't count
Fail any one and every dollar is fundraising.
Back to the food bank. Its spring mailing went to 20,000 households in the three zip codes with the highest food insecurity, chosen from census data, not from the donor list. Two of the five panels told readers how to sign up for home delivery and where the weekend pantries are (a specific call to action). The other three panels asked for gifts. Nobody was paid on commission. All three tests pass, so using the physical units method (share of the piece devoted to each purpose), 2 of 5 panels, or 40%, of the $15,000 goes to program: $6,000. The remaining $9,000 is fundraising.
Send the exact same mailing to last year's donor list and the answer changes. The audience criterion presumes fundraising, and all $15,000 lands in column D.
When you do allocate joint costs, the notes disclose the types of activities involved, that joint costs were allocated, the total, and how much went to each function.
How does this flow into Form 990 Part IX?
Form 990 Part IX is the IRS version of your statement of functional expenses. A few rules from the instructions:
- Section 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) organizations must complete all four columns (total, program services, management and general, fundraising). Other exempt organizations only have to complete the total.
- Use your normal accounting method. If your system doesn't allocate, any reasonable method is allowed, but you must document the method in your records.
- Line 26, joint costs. If you put joint costs from a combined educational campaign and solicitation into program services, you report the total and the split. Only check the box if you followed ASC 958-720. For the food bank: $15,000 in column A, $6,000 in column B, $9,000 in column D.
- Investment management costs go in column C on the 990, even though GAAP nets them against investment return. That's one reason your 990 total won't always match your audited statements.
- Direct costs of fundraising events are reported in Part VIII (line 8b), not Part IX.
For a calendar-year organization the return is due May 15 (the 15th day of the 5th month after year end), so your functional split should be final well before then. Our nonprofit grant accounting post covers which 990 version you file and how restricted grants tie in.
Common mistakes
Allocating once a year from memory. If the split happens in March for the prior year, it isn't supported by anything. Use class tracking or a function field in your accounting software and apply the percentages every month.
Leaving the executive director entirely in management and general. It understates programs. The opposite is worse: putting her entirely in program because she "is the mission."
Chasing a high program ratio. CBIZ makes the point that allocating too much to programs can be viewed negatively too. A reviewer who sees 95% program spending will wonder who's doing the finance work.
Splitting a donor appeal because it has a story in it. A mailing that educates without a specific call to action, or goes to prior donors, is fundraising. Full stop, in most cases.
Forgetting the notes. GAAP requires a description of the allocation method. An unexplained split is a finding waiting to happen in an audit or review.
When should you get help?
If your organization files a Form 990-N or 990-EZ and has no audit, a simple written policy (time for salaries, square footage for rent) and monthly coding by functional expense category is enough, and you can run it yourself.
Bring someone in when you have an audit or review, a federal grant, joint activities you'd like to split, or a split that's been done by rough guess for years. Your auditor and Form 990 preparer have the final say on presentation. Fintrix Consulting's nonprofit accounting work includes fund accounting that keeps restricted and unrestricted money apart, spending tracked against each grant's budget all year, and records organized for your Form 990 preparer and auditor.
Frequently asked questions
Do small nonprofits have to report functional expenses?
If you issue GAAP financial statements, yes: ASU 2016-14 applies to all not-for-profits, with no size exemption. On the tax side, 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) organizations filing the full Form 990 must complete all four columns of Part IX. Organizations filing the 990-EZ or 990-N don't file Part IX.
What's a good program expense ratio?
There's no rule in the standards. What matters is that the number is honest and supported. A ratio pushed up by aggressive allocations is worse than a lower one you can defend line by line.
Is grant writing a fundraising expense?
Usually. The Form 990 instructions put the cost of soliciting grants in fundraising. The exception is the cost of securing a contract or grant to perform work that meets the grantor's own specific needs, which goes in program services.
Does HR count as program or management and general?
Management and general. ASU 2016-14 added human resources and benefits oversight to the examples of management and general activities, and the Form 990 instructions list it there too.
The bottom line
Functional expense reporting is mostly simple coding: put each cost where it obviously belongs. The judgment is in the shared costs, and that's where a written policy (time, square footage, FTEs), applied monthly and described in the notes, does the work. Mixed mailings get split only if they pass the purpose, audience and content tests. Get that right through the year and Part IX of your Form 990 is close to a copy of your own books.
Sources
- FASB not-for-profit financial reporting standard (Journal of Accountancy)
- Lessons Learned from Implementing ASU 2016-14: Functional Expenses (BDO)
- Optimizing Transparency: The Essentials of Functional Expense Reporting for Nonprofits (CBIZ)
- How NFPs allocate joint costs (Journal of Accountancy)
- IRS, Instructions for Form 990 (2025), Part IX Statement of Functional Expenses and line 26 joint costs
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- 100% bonus depreciation is permanent: book vs tax effects
November 20, 2026
- The AICPA's FRF for SMEs: a simpler alternative to GAAP?
November 20, 2026
- Writing a capitalization policy: the $2,500 rule and GAAP
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.