Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Gross or net? Principal vs agent revenue explained

November 19, 2026 · 9 min read

← All articles
Hands planning a trip on a world map with a passport, toy airplane, tickets and a camera nearby
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASC 606 you report revenue gross (the full amount the customer pays) if you are the principal: you control the good or service before it reaches the customer. You report net (only your fee or commission) if you are an agent who just arranges for someone else to provide it. Three indicators help decide control: who is primarily responsible for fulfilling the promise, who carries inventory risk, and who sets the price. Gross profit is the same either way; revenue and margins are not.

You sold $1.8 million of trips last year. Or did you sell $850,000? If you book flights, resell software, place ads, run a marketplace or pass costs through to clients, the answer depends on whether you were the principal or the agent in each sale. Get it wrong and your revenue can be off by half, your gross margin looks thin when it isn't (or healthy when it isn't), and a lender or buyer will notice.

This is one of the judgment calls in ASC 606 that private companies get wrong most often, usually because nobody asked the question. Here's how the test works, a worked example, and the situations where it comes up.

What's the difference between gross and net revenue?

Say a customer pays you $1,000 and you pay a supplier $950 of it.

  • Gross: revenue $1,000, cost of revenue $950, gross profit $50.
  • Net: revenue $50. The $950 never touches revenue or costs.

Your profit is the same. What changes is the size of your top line, your gross margin percentage, and any ratio or covenant built on revenue. Gross reporting makes a business look bigger. Net reporting makes it look more profitable per dollar. Neither is a choice you get to make for appearance: the standard decides.

How does ASC 606 decide principal vs agent?

The guidance sits in ASC 606-10-55-36 through 55-40. PwC's guide breaks it into two steps.

Step 1: Identify the specified good or service. What exactly is the end customer getting? A flight. A month of ad placements. A product shipped by a third-party seller. This is assessed for each distinct good or service, not for the contract as a whole, so one contract can make you a principal for one part and an agent for another.

Step 2: Do you control it before it's transferred to the customer? Under ASC 606-10-55-37A, a principal obtains control of one of these:

  • a good or other asset from the other party that it then transfers to the customer,
  • a right to a service to be performed by the other party, which gives it the ability to direct that party to provide the service on its behalf, or
  • a good or service from the other party that it combines with other goods or services to provide what the customer ordered.

If you control it, you're the principal: revenue is gross. If your promise is to arrange for another party to provide it, you're an agent: revenue is your fee or commission, net.

What are the three indicators of control?

When control isn't obvious, ASC 606-10-55-39 gives three indicators that you control the specified good or service:

Indicators of a principal vs signs of an agent

You control it

Points to principal (gross)

  • You're primarily responsible for fulfilling the promise: the customer looks to you if something goes wrong
  • You carry inventory risk before the customer buys, or after (returns), like prepaid, non-refundable stock or capacity
  • You have discretion to set the price the customer pays

You arrange it

Points to agent (net)

  • The supplier is responsible for delivering and for fixing problems
  • You only buy after the customer orders, and can cancel without cost
  • The supplier sets the price, and you earn a fixed fee or percentage

Two cautions from PwC's guide. The indicators support the control assessment; they don't replace it. And they're not a checklist: no single indicator decides it, none is weighted more than the others by default, and the facts determine which matter most. You look at contract terms and how the business actually operates.

Older US guidance also looked at credit risk (who loses if the customer doesn't pay). It isn't one of the indicators under ASC 606 any more, so "we'd be stuck with the bad debt" on its own doesn't make you a principal.

A worked example: a travel company with two kinds of sales

Say you run a hypothetical corporate travel company. Last year you had two lines of business:

  • Group packages. You pre-book hotel blocks and venues months ahead on non-refundable terms, add your own planning and on-site support, and sell the package at a price you set. Customers paid $800,000. The hotels and venues cost you $600,000.
  • Flight bookings. You book flights for clients at the airline's published fare. The airline delivers the flight and handles changes and cancellations. Clients paid $1,000,000 through you; you passed $950,000 to the airlines and kept $50,000 in booking fees and commissions.

Apply the test.

For the packages, you obtained the hotel rooms and venue space before any client bought (non-refundable, so inventory risk), you're responsible for the event as delivered, and you set the price. You're the principal. Revenue is the full $800,000.

For the flights, you never control the seat. The airline is responsible for the flight, you don't hold seat inventory, and you don't set the fare. You're an agent. Revenue is the $50,000 you kept.

Group packages (principal)Flight bookings (agent)Total
Customer billings$800,000$1,000,000$1,800,000
Revenue reported$800,000$50,000$850,000
Cost of revenue$600,000$0$600,000
Gross profit$200,000$50,000$250,000

From customer billings to gross profit

Hypothetical travel company, one year

  • Increase
  • Deducted
  • Total
$0$500k$1M$1.5M$2MCustomer billings: $1,800,000$1.8MCustomerbillingsAirline fares passed on: −$950,000−$950kAirlinefarespassed onRevenue reported: $850,000$850kRevenuereportedHotels and venues: −$600,000−$600kHotels andvenuesGross profit: $250,000$250kGrossprofit

Hypothetical example. Airline fares are excluded from revenue because the company is an agent for flights.

Show the numbers
Customer billings$1,800,000
Airline fares passed on−$950,000
Revenue reported$850,000
Hotels and venues−$600,000
Gross profit$250,000

Now compare that with booking everything gross, which is what happens by default when every client payment is coded to sales:

Same business, two ways of reporting

Gross profit doesn't change; revenue and margin do

  • Everything gross (wrong)
  • Principal vs agent applied
$0$500k$1M$1.5M$2MRevenue · Everything gross (wrong): $1,800,000Revenue · Principal vs agent applied: $850,000Cost of revenue · Everything gross (wrong): $1,550,000Cost of revenue · Principal vs agent applied: $600,000Gross profit · Everything gross (wrong): $250,000Gross profit · Principal vs agent applied: $250,000RevenueCost of revenueGross profit

Hypothetical example.

Show the numbers
 Everything gross (wrong)Principal vs agent applied
Revenue$1,800,000$850,000
Cost of revenue$1,550,000$600,000
Gross profit$250,000$250,000

Everything gross shows $1.8 million of revenue at a 13.9% gross margin. Done correctly, it's $850,000 at 29.4%. Same profit, very different business on paper. If a lender sets a covenant or a buyer prices the company on a revenue multiple, that difference is real money.

Where does this come up for small businesses?

More often than owners expect. Some common patterns, with the usual direction of the answer (your facts decide):

SituationUsuallyWhy
Online marketplace taking a cut of third-party sellers' salesAgent, netThe seller controls and ships the product; the platform arranges the sale
Same marketplace selling its own stockPrincipal, grossIt owns the inventory and sets the price
Ad agency buying media at the media owner's rate plus a feeOften agentDepends on who commits to the spend, sets the price and integrates it into the campaign
Agency buying media in advance and reselling it at its own priceOften principalIt carries the inventory risk and has pricing discretion
Travel agent booking flights or hotels at the supplier's priceAgent, netThe supplier provides the service
Tour operator selling packages it pre-buys and designsPrincipal, grossInventory risk, pricing, responsibility for the trip
Contractor using subcontractors on a job it managesPrincipal, grossIt directs the subcontractors and combines their work into what the customer bought
Reseller of software licenses fulfilled directly by the publisherDependsTurns on who supports the product and who sets the price

If you're on Amazon, Etsy or another marketplace as a seller, you're on the other side of this: you're usually the principal for your own products, and the marketplace's fee is your expense, not a reduction you net out quietly. Our posts on the five steps of ASC 606 and revenue recognition for service firms cover the rest of the model.

What about reimbursable costs billed to clients?

Consultants, agencies and contractors often bill clients for travel, materials or filing fees "at cost." Apply the same control test to each kind of cost.

If you buy the flight and hotel so your own staff can deliver your service, you're using that cost to fulfill your own promise. It's an input you control, so the reimbursement is usually revenue, and the cost is cost of revenue (gross).

If you pay a third party's bill purely on the client's behalf (a government filing fee in the client's name, say) and you have no responsibility for what's provided, that looks more like an agent arrangement: the pass-through isn't your revenue.

Whichever answer you reach, be consistent across clients and periods, and make sure your invoicing and your chart of accounts separate reimbursements from fees so the numbers can be checked.

Common mistakes

Defaulting to gross. Every client payment gets coded to sales because that's how the bank feed works. The principal vs agent question never gets asked.

Deciding at the company level. "We're a principal" isn't an answer. The test applies to each specified good or service, and one business (or one contract) can be both.

Treating the indicators as a vote. Two out of three doesn't settle it. The question is control; the indicators help you answer it.

Leaning on credit risk. It's not an ASC 606 indicator.

Not writing down the conclusion. A short memo that says what the specified good or service is, who controls it and why will save hours when an auditor, reviewer or buyer asks.

When should you get help?

If you only sell your own products and services, this probably never comes up. It's worth a careful look when you resell or broker anything, run a platform, bill reimbursable costs in meaningful amounts, or when your statements go to a lender, investor or reviewer who will compare revenue and margins year to year. Your CPA or auditor will have the final say on the conclusion.

Setting up revenue accounts that separate gross sales, commissions and pass-throughs, and applying the policy every month, is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting.

Frequently asked questions

Does gross vs net change my profit?

No. Gross profit and net income are the same either way. It changes revenue, cost of revenue, gross margin percentage and any metric built on revenue.

Can I choose to report gross because it makes revenue look bigger?

No. It's not an election. Under ASC 606 the answer follows from whether you control the good or service before it's transferred to the customer.

Can I be a principal and an agent in the same contract?

Yes. The test is applied to each specified good or service, so one contract can include goods you control and services you only arrange.

Does this matter for taxes?

The tax rules for gross receipts can differ from GAAP. Your CPA decides the tax reporting; this post is about your financial statements.

What if I'm a marketplace seller, not the marketplace?

You're usually the principal for your own products. Report the full sale price as revenue and the marketplace's fees as expenses.

The bottom line

Gross or net isn't a style choice. Identify what the customer is actually buying, ask whether you control it before they get it, and use the three indicators (responsibility, inventory risk, pricing) to support the answer. Apply it product by product, write it down, and set up your accounts so the numbers follow the conclusion. Your profit won't change, but your revenue and margins will finally mean what readers think they mean.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.