Industry guides
Your WIP schedule: what over- and underbillings really tell you
November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
A WIP schedule compares what you've billed on each job with what you've actually earned based on costs. Overbillings mean customers have paid ahead of the work, which is healthy if the cash is still there. Underbillings mean you've earned more than you've billed, and when they're large they often point to cost overruns, unapproved change orders or an estimate that's too optimistic. The most useful thing on the schedule is the change in each job's estimated profit from one month to the next.
Your bookkeeper sends the WIP schedule every month. It's a wide spreadsheet with a dozen columns per job, and you scroll straight to the bottom line to see if you're over- or underbilled in total. If the total looks small, you close it.
That's the one number on the schedule that tells you the least. The jobs underneath, and how they moved since last month, are where the warnings are. Your surety and your bank know that, which is why they read it line by line.
This post isn't about how to build the schedule. Our post on percentage of completion for contractors covers the method, and construction bookkeeping mistakes shows a schedule across three jobs. Here we read one, including a job whose margin fades over three months.
What is a WIP schedule actually telling you?
A WIP schedule lists every open job with its contract price, estimated total cost, cost to date and billings to date. From those four inputs it works out how far along each job is (cost to date divided by estimated total cost, the cost-to-cost method), how much revenue you've earned, and whether you've billed more or less than that.
Withum calls estimated total cost "the key estimate," and it is. Every other number on the schedule leans on it. If the estimate is stale, the percent complete is wrong, earned revenue is wrong, gross profit is wrong, and the over or under billing is wrong. All in the same direction: too rosy.
So read the schedule as a test of your estimates, not just a billing report.
Overbilled or underbilled: which is the warning sign?
Both can be fine. Both can be trouble. The difference is what's behind them.
Billed more than earned
Overbilled
- Normal on jobs with front-loaded pay applications or mobilization billing
- Your customer is funding the job, which is good for cash
- Trouble if the cash has already been spent on other jobs
- Trouble if overbillings exceed the job's remaining profit
Earned more than billed
Underbilled
- Can be timing: a pay app not yet sent, or work done after the billing cutoff
- Can be an approved scope change without approved pricing
- Often a sign of cost overruns pushing percent complete ahead of real progress
- Large or growing underbillings make sureties ask whether profit is overstated
Overbillings are only good news if the money is still there. Construction Business Owner says any overbilling should be represented by cash in the bank. If you've used Job A's advance billings to make payroll on Job B, you'll be short when Job A's remaining work comes due. Withum adds a sharper test: when overbillings on a job are bigger than its projected gross profit, you may be "job borrowing," and a cash crunch tends to follow.
Underbillings get more suspicion, and for good reason. EisnerAmper's guidance on bonding says substantial underbillings are typically a red flag that profit may be overstated. Here's why. Under cost-to-cost, every extra dollar of cost moves the job further toward "complete." If a job is running over budget, costs pile up faster than real progress, so earned revenue runs ahead of what your customer will approve on the pay application. The gap shows up as an underbilling. Persistent underbillings are often just cost overruns that nobody has admitted to in the estimate yet.
What is profit fade, and why does it matter more than the totals?
Profit fade is a drop in a job's estimated gross profit from one period to the next. A rise is a gain. Withum describes gain/fade analysis as comparing last period's estimated gross profit on each open job with the current estimate, or with the final profit once the job closes.
A little fade on a job here and there is normal. A pattern isn't. Construction Business Owner notes that a contractor who fades consistently is likely to get unfavorable treatment from sureties and lenders, and EisnerAmper warns that repeated fade can make a surety lose confidence in management and cut bonding capacity.
CLA lists the usual causes: optimistic production or unit-cost estimates, labor or equipment rates set too low, extra work the client won't pay for, weak subcontractor or supplier performance, thin field supervision and bad weather. Most were knowable before the job started, which is why fade reflects on your estimating, not just the job.
A worked example: one job, three months of fade
Say you're a general contractor with a $2,000,000 contract for a commercial tenant build-out. You bid it at an estimated cost of $1,700,000, a gross profit of $300,000 (15%). Here's the job on the WIP schedule at three month ends:
| Jul 31 | Aug 31 | Sep 30 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract price | $2,000,000 | $2,000,000 | $2,000,000 |
| Estimated total cost | $1,700,000 | $1,760,000 | $1,840,000 |
| Estimated gross profit | $300,000 (15%) | $240,000 (12%) | $160,000 (8%) |
| Cost to date | $340,000 | $792,000 | $1,196,000 |
| Percent complete | 20% | 45% | 65% |
| Revenue earned to date | $400,000 | $900,000 | $1,300,000 |
| Billed to date | $460,000 | $940,000 | $1,250,000 |
| Overbilled (underbilled) | $60,000 | $40,000 | ($50,000) |
| Gross profit to date | $60,000 | $108,000 | $104,000 |
| Gross profit this month | $60,000 | $48,000 | ($4,000) |
| Estimated cost to complete | $1,360,000 | $968,000 | $644,000 |
In August, the project manager raised the cost estimate by $60,000 after drywall and framing labor ran heavy. In September, another $80,000 went on: overtime to hold the schedule and rework after a subcontractor's mistake.
Tenant build-out: estimated profit vs profit earned so far
Hypothetical $2,000,000 job, month-end WIP schedule
- Estimated gross profit at completion
- Gross profit recognized to date
Hypothetical example. Margin at completion fades from 15% to 12% to 8%. Profit to date falls by $4,000 in September even though 20% more of the job was done.
Show the numbers
| Estimated gross profit at completion | Gross profit recognized to date | |
|---|---|---|
| Jul | $300,000 | $60,000 |
| Aug | $240,000 | $108,000 |
| Sep | $160,000 | $104,000 |
Where the job's profit went
Estimated gross profit at completion, bid to September 30
- Adds profit
- Profit fade
- Total
Hypothetical example.
Show the numbers
| Bid profit | $300,000 |
| August fade | −$60,000 |
| September fade | −$80,000 |
| Current estimate | $160,000 |
Now read it the way a surety would.
The billing position flipped. In July and August the job was overbilled, which felt comfortable. By September it was underbilled by $50,000. Your billing didn't change. The overruns pushed percent complete to 65% faster than the work your customer will pay for.
September lost money on paper. The job did $400,000 of revenue in September ($1,300,000 less $900,000) against $404,000 of cost. When an estimate catches up, the whole correction for prior months lands in the current one. That's the profit fade becoming visible in your P&L.
Half the margin is gone with a third of the job left. $644,000 of cost to complete is now standing between you and an 8% margin.
If the estimate ever rises above the $2,000,000 contract price, the rule changes. Withum notes that GAAP requires the entire expected loss on the contract to be recognized as soon as it's identified, not spread over the rest of the job.
How do sureties and banks read your WIP schedule?
As evidence of how good your estimates are, compared over time.
- Gain and fade on every job, every period. Construction Business Owner says sureties and lenders run their own gain/fade analysis at each date they have statements for, usually year end, sometimes quarterly.
- In-progress margins against completed jobs. Withum suggests comparing estimated margins on open jobs with actual margins on completed jobs of similar size and scope. If your finished jobs averaged 10% and every open job still shows 15%, expect questions.
- Underbillings. Large ones get treated as possible overstated profit until you explain them.
- Overbillings against cash. If you're heavily overbilled but cash is thin, someone spent money they owe in future work.
The completed-contract schedule is the other half of that picture. It lists jobs that closed during the year with their original estimated gross profit and final gross profit. It's the report card for your estimating. A surety can see that a job bid at 15% finished at 6%, and can check whether the same estimator's open jobs still show 15%.
What red flags should you look for every month?
Estimates
- Has estimated cost to complete been updated by the project manager this month, on every job?
- Is cost to complete unchanged for two months while labor keeps posting?
- Did any job's estimated margin move more than a couple of points? Why?
Billing
- Which jobs are underbilled, and is each one timing, an unsigned change order or an overrun?
- Are overbillings covered by cash on hand?
- Is any job overbilled by more than its remaining gross profit?
Margins
- Do open job margins look like margins on similar completed jobs?
- Is any job projecting a loss that hasn't been recognized in full?
- Are unapproved change orders sitting in contract price?
On that last point: EisnerAmper's advice is to add a change order to the contract price only once it's signed. Withum allows unapproved change orders only when approval is probable. Either way, an unapproved change order padding the contract price makes a fading job look healthier than it is.
Common mistakes
Reading only the total. A $10,000 net overbilling can hide one job $150,000 overbilled and another $140,000 underbilled. They're different problems.
Letting accounting own the estimate. The bookkeeper can't know cost to complete. The project manager has to update it every month, in writing, job by job.
Treating an underbilling as money in the bank. It's an asset on the balance sheet, but it's only worth something if your customer will actually pay for that work.
Spending overbillings. The cash feels like profit. It's a liability until the work is done.
Waiting for year end. If your surety finds fade in December that you never saw in October, nobody was watching.
When should you get help?
If you run one or two jobs at a time and update estimates yourself, a simple WIP schedule you review monthly is enough.
Get help when you carry several jobs at once, when a surety or bank wants the schedule quarterly, or when fades keep surprising you at closeout. Then you need a month-end close that ties the WIP to the books. Fintrix Consulting sets up job costing so every job has its own running profit; see how we work with real estate and construction businesses.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to be overbilled or underbilled?
Modestly overbilled is usually healthier, because your customer is funding the work, as long as the cash is still in the bank. Large or growing underbillings raise questions about cost overruns and overstated profit.
What does profit fade mean on a WIP schedule?
It's a drop in a job's estimated gross profit from one period to the next. Occasional fade is normal. A pattern of fade across jobs suggests your estimates are too optimistic, and sureties notice.
How often should the estimated cost to complete be updated?
Every month, for every open job, by the project manager. A WIP schedule built on last quarter's estimates will overstate profit on any job that's running over.
Where do over- and underbillings go on the balance sheet?
Overbillings are a liability (billings in excess of costs and estimated earnings). Underbillings are an asset (costs and estimated earnings in excess of billings). Under ASC 606 they're often presented as contract liabilities and contract assets.
The bottom line
The total at the bottom of your WIP schedule is the least useful number on it. Read each job: is the estimate current, is the over or under billing explained, and did the margin move since last month? In our example, a 15% job quietly became an 8% job in two months, and the first clear signal was an underbilling. Catch that in the month it happens and you can still act. Catch it at year end and your surety will have caught it first.
Sources
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Chart of accounts for agencies and consultancies
November 19, 2026
- Getting your books ready for Form 990
November 19, 2026
- Monthly financial reports for medical and dental practices
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.