Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Do you have to consolidate your real-estate LLC?

November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Gray metal warehouse building with large blue loading doors on a paved forecourt
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Usually not, if you're a private company and you make the election. Under ASU 2018-17, a private company can choose not to apply the variable interest entity (VIE) rules in ASC 810 to entities under common control, like the LLC you own that holds the building your company rents. Without a controlling voting stake, there's nothing left to consolidate. You still disclose your exposure, such as a guarantee of the LLC's mortgage, in the notes.

You own the operating company. You also own the building it runs from, but not through the company: a separate LLC holds the property and the mortgage, and the company pays that LLC rent every month. Then your company's first reviewed financial statements come back with a question from the CPA: "Have you elected the private company alternative for the property LLC?" Or a new lender asks why the building isn't on the balance sheet when the company guarantees the mortgage.

Both are fair questions. Below: why consolidation comes up at all, the election that usually takes it off the table, a worked example with the numbers, and what you still have to disclose.

Why would my company consolidate an LLC it doesn't own?

Normally, a company consolidates another entity because it owns a majority of the voting interest. Your operating company doesn't own any of the property LLC. You do. So under the ordinary voting interest model, there's no consolidation.

The complication is the second model in ASC 810: variable interest entities. A VIE is, roughly, an entity whose own equity can't carry it, so it depends on support from someone else, or whose owners don't really make the decisions. A property LLC with a thin slice of equity, a large mortgage and a guarantee from the tenant company can easily fit that description.

If the LLC is a VIE, the question becomes who its primary beneficiary is. Per PwC's consolidation guide, that's the party with both:

  1. the power to direct the activities that most significantly affect the VIE's economic performance, and
  2. the obligation to absorb losses, or the right to receive benefits, that could be significant to it.

When the owner and the operating company are related parties, the analysis looks at them as a group. And historically, the operating company (the tenant, the guarantor, the reason the building exists) often came out as the one that had to consolidate. That's how a lot of small companies ended up with a building and a mortgage they didn't own on their balance sheets.

What did ASU 2014-07 change?

Private company owners and their lenders pushed back. As the FASB's basis for conclusions in ASU 2014-07 records, users of private company statements said consolidating a commonly controlled lessor wasn't relevant to them. They focused on the tenant's own cash flows and tangible net worth, and the lessor's assets weren't available to the tenant's creditors anyway. Owners said they set up these LLCs for tax, estate planning and legal liability reasons, not to hide debt.

So in 2014 the FASB gave private companies an election: a tenant didn't have to apply the VIE rules to a lessor under common control if four conditions held. The two companies were under common control, they had a lease, substantially all the activity between them related to leasing, and any guarantee or collateral the tenant provided on the lessor's debt didn't exceed the value of the leased asset.

It was useful, but narrow. It only covered leasing arrangements.

What does ASU 2018-17 allow?

ASU 2018-17 replaced the leasing-only election with a broader one. A private company can elect not to apply the VIE guidance to a legal entity when all four of these are true (ASC 810-10-15-17AD):

CriterionWhat it means for an owner with a property LLC
The reporting entity and the legal entity are under common controlYou control both companies
They aren't under common control of a public business entityYour parent isn't a public company
The legal entity isn't a public business entityThe property LLC isn't public
The reporting entity doesn't hold a controlling financial interest under the general (voting) rulesYour operating company doesn't own the LLC's voting interests

A few details matter here.

It isn't limited to leases. Any qualifying entity under common control is covered.

Common control is judged on voting interests only. Per the ASU, you look at the common parent's direct and indirect voting interests.

It's all or nothing. The election is an accounting policy that applies to every current and future entity under common control that meets the criteria. You can't pick the LLC you'd like off the balance sheet and keep another one consolidated through the VIE rules.

It's been effective for years. For private companies it applied to fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2020. If your statements have been reviewed or audited since then, the question has probably already been answered once. Check your accounting policies note.

If the criteria stop being met later (say the operating company buys a majority of the LLC), you apply the VIE guidance from that point forward.

A worked example: one owner, two companies

Say you own 100% of a 40-person HVAC contractor (OpCo) and 100% of a property LLC (PropCo) that owns its shop and offices. OpCo pays PropCo $22,000 a month in rent and has guaranteed PropCo's $2.6 million mortgage. At year end the numbers look like this (simplified, hypothetical):

  • OpCo on its own: total assets $6.0 million, including a $1.0 million right of use asset for the lease. Total liabilities $3.5 million, including the matching $1.0 million lease liability. Equity $2.5 million.
  • PropCo: building (net of depreciation) $3.0 million and cash $0.1 million, so total assets $3.1 million. Mortgage $2.6 million. Your equity $0.5 million.

If OpCo had to consolidate PropCo, the intercompany lease disappears (the $1.0 million right of use asset and lease liability come off) and PropCo's building and mortgage come on. Because OpCo doesn't own PropCo, PropCo's $0.5 million of equity shows as a noncontrolling interest.

LineOpCo aloneRemove the leaseAdd PropCoConsolidated
Total assets$6,000,000($1,000,000)$3,100,000$8,100,000
Total liabilities$3,500,000($1,000,000)$2,600,000$5,100,000
OpCo's equity$2,500,000$2,500,000
Noncontrolling interest$500,000$500,000
Total equity$2,500,000$3,000,000

OpCo's balance sheet, alone vs. consolidated with PropCo

Year end, simplified

  • OpCo alone
  • Consolidated
$0$2.5M$5M$7.5M$10MTotal assets · OpCo alone: $6,000,000Total assets · Consolidated: $8,100,000Total liabilities · OpCo alone: $3,500,000Total liabilities · Consolidated: $5,100,000Total equity · OpCo alone: $2,500,000Total equity · Consolidated: $3,000,000Total assetsTotal liabilitiesTotal equity

Hypothetical example. Consolidated equity includes $500,000 of noncontrolling interest (your equity in PropCo).

Show the numbers
 OpCo aloneConsolidated
Total assets$6,000,000$8,100,000
Total liabilities$3,500,000$5,100,000
Total equity$2,500,000$3,000,000

Look at what a lender sees. Liabilities to OpCo's own equity go from 1.4 ($3.5M / $2.5M) to about 2.0 ($5.1M / $2.5M). If your loan agreement has a debt to equity covenant written around the standalone numbers, consolidation could put you close to a breach without anything in the business changing. (Our post on what happens when you breach a loan covenant covers that conversation.) The income statement shifts too: rent expense is replaced by PropCo's depreciation and mortgage interest, and part of the profit belongs to the noncontrolling interest.

With the ASU 2018-17 election, OpCo stays at $6.0 million of assets and $3.5 million of liabilities. The lease stays on its books under ASC 842, and the mortgage guarantee goes in the notes.

If I elect it, what do I still have to disclose?

The election takes the property LLC off the balance sheet, not out of the statements. Unless the entity is consolidated under the voting interest rules, ASU 2018-17 requires the reporting company to disclose:

Disclosures under the private company election

The relationship

  • The nature of your involvement with the entity and the risks it brings
  • How that involvement affects your financial position, results and cash flows

The numbers

  • The carrying amounts and classification of assets and liabilities related to the entity (for example, the lease balances)
  • Your maximum exposure to loss, or a statement that it can't be quantified

Beyond the balance sheet

  • If the exposure exceeds the carrying amounts, information about the excess, such as a guarantee of the mortgage or an implicit commitment to cover shortfalls
  • The related party disclosures under ASC 850 and the guarantee disclosures under ASC 460, which apply on top of these

In the example, OpCo's maximum exposure is at least the $2.6 million guarantee, far more than the $1.0 million lease liability on its balance sheet. That gap is exactly what the note has to explain.

The related party side (rent paid, amounts owed, the relationship) is covered in our post on related party disclosures under ASC 850. For the lease itself, private companies can account for a common control lease using its written terms under ASU 2023-01; see related-party leases and ASU 2023-01.

Should I elect it or consolidate anyway?

For most owner-operated businesses, the election gives the more useful picture. But it's a choice, and the reader of the statements matters.

Elect the alternative or apply the VIE rules?

Most private companies

Elect ASU 2018-17

  • Balance sheet shows only what the company owns and owes
  • Covenants based on the operating company stay meaningful
  • Lease stays on the books under ASC 842
  • Exposure (like a mortgage guarantee) explained in the notes
  • Applies to every qualifying common control entity

Apply the VIE rules

  • Requires a VIE and primary beneficiary analysis, every year
  • May bring the building, mortgage and a noncontrolling interest onto the balance sheet
  • Intercompany rent eliminated
  • Sometimes preferred when a surety or lender wants the whole group in one set of numbers
  • More work at every close

If a lender really wants to see both companies together, some ask for combined financial statements of the commonly owned companies, separate from the operating company's own statements. Ask what the loan agreement actually requires before changing your accounting policy.

Common mistakes

Assuming the election is automatic. It's an accounting policy election. If nobody made it, your reviewer or auditor may expect a VIE analysis. Make sure the policy note says it.

Electing it for one entity only. The election covers every qualifying common control entity. You can't keep the LLC with the big mortgage off the balance sheet and consolidate the one with the nice cash balance.

Skipping the guarantee disclosure. The building disappears from the balance sheet; the risk doesn't. A $2.6 million guarantee with no note is the first thing a credit analyst will find.

Forgetting about the lease. Not consolidating doesn't mean ignoring the rent. Under ASC 842 the operating company still records the related party lease. See ASC 842 for small businesses.

When should you get help?

If your statements are only for you and your tax preparer, this rarely comes up. It matters once a bank, surety, investor or buyer relies on your GAAP statements, especially if they're reviewed or audited (see audit, review or compilation). Your CPA or auditor will form the final view on the election and the note wording.

What makes it go smoothly is clean books on both sides: the lease recorded properly at the operating company, intercompany rent and balances that agree between the two companies, and property-level numbers for the LLC. Property-level books and a lender-ready reporting pack are part of what Fintrix Consulting does for real estate and construction businesses, alongside monthly accounting and financial statements.

Frequently asked questions

What is a variable interest entity in plain English?

An entity that can't stand on its own equity, so it relies on someone else's support (a guarantee, a loan, a lease), or whose owners don't really make its key decisions. The party with both the power and the economic exposure, the primary beneficiary, consolidates it.

Does ASU 2018-17 apply to public companies?

No. It's a private company alternative. It isn't available if the common parent or the entity being evaluated is a public business entity.

Can I make the election for one LLC and not another?

No. It's an accounting policy that applies to all current and future legal entities under common control that meet the criteria.

If I elect it, does my company still record the lease?

Yes. The election only affects consolidation. The operating company still accounts for the lease under ASC 842 and discloses the related party relationship.

Does this affect my taxes?

No. Consolidation under GAAP is a financial reporting question. How each LLC is taxed depends on its own tax classification, which your CPA handles.

The bottom line

If you own the operating company and, separately, the LLC that holds its building, GAAP's VIE rules could once push that building and its mortgage onto your company's balance sheet. Private companies can elect out under ASU 2018-17, as long as the entities are under common control and none of them is public. The election covers every qualifying entity, and it doesn't remove the duty to explain your exposure, like a mortgage guarantee, in the notes. Confirm the policy with your CPA, and keep the books of both companies in step.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.