Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Renting from your own LLC? What ASU 2023-01 changes for your lease

November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Two-story brick office building with a parking lot at dusk
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

If your company rents its building from an LLC you also own, ASU 2023-01 gives private companies a practical expedient: you can account for the lease using its written terms and conditions, without first deciding whether those terms are legally enforceable. It also changed leasehold improvements for every company leasing from a common-control lessor: they're amortized over their useful life to the common control group, not the shorter lease term, as long as the tenant controls the use of the property. It's been effective since fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2023.

It's one of the most common setups in small business. You own the building through one LLC and run the business through another. The operating company pays rent to the property LLC, the property LLC pays the mortgage, and the lease is either a template downloaded years ago or a conversation you had with yourself.

Then ASC 842 arrived, and that arrangement had to go on the balance sheet like any other lease. The problem was that ASC 842 asked you to account for related-party leases based on their legally enforceable terms. When the same person signs on both sides, working out what's enforceable is a legal question, not an accounting one, and private companies told the FASB it was costly and a little absurd.

ASU 2023-01 was the answer. This post covers what it allows, the leasehold improvement change (which matters more than people expect), and a worked example of an owner's real estate LLC leasing to the operating business. For the basics of putting a lease on the books, see ASC 842 for small businesses.

What does ASU 2023-01 actually change?

The FASB issued ASU 2023-01, Leases (Topic 842): Common Control Arrangements, on March 27, 2023. It deals with two issues.

The two parts of ASU 2023-01

Private companies and most NFPs

Issue 1: written terms

  • Elective practical expedient
  • Use the written terms and conditions to decide whether a lease exists and how to classify and account for it
  • No need to determine legal enforceability
  • Elected arrangement by arrangement
  • Not available if there's nothing in writing

All entities, public and private

Issue 2: leasehold improvements

  • Applies to a lessee in a lease with a common-control lessor
  • Amortize improvements over their useful life to the common control group
  • Only while the lessee controls the use of the underlying asset
  • When control ends, the remaining balance moves through equity

Who can use the written-terms expedient?

Grant Thornton's summary sets out who's eligible: entities that aren't public business entities, except not-for-profits that have securities traded on an exchange or over the counter (or are conduit bond obligors for such securities) and employee benefit plans that file with the SEC. For a typical owner-managed company, you're eligible.

It applies to both sides (the property LLC as lessor and the operating company as lessee) and you can elect it arrangement by arrangement.

The key limit is the word written. The FASB didn't prescribe a form, so it doesn't have to be a 40-page lease drafted by a lawyer. But if there's no written document at all, the expedient isn't available and you're back to evaluating the legally enforceable terms. A handshake lease means more judgment, not less.

What your written related-party lease should say

The basics

  • Which entity is the landlord and which is the tenant
  • The property or space being leased
  • Start date and term, including any renewal options
  • Rent amount, payment timing and any escalations

What often gets forgotten

  • Who pays property taxes, insurance and maintenance
  • Who owns improvements the tenant makes
  • What happens if the tenant leaves early
  • Signatures and a date, even if you sign on both sides

Why does the leasehold improvement change matter so much?

Under the general rule, a tenant amortizes leasehold improvements over the shorter of their useful life or the remaining lease term. That makes sense between strangers: when the lease ends, the tenant walks away and the improvements stay with the landlord.

Between entities you control, it often doesn't make sense. Owners commonly sign short related-party leases, three or five years, and renew them indefinitely. Meanwhile the operating company spends real money on the building. Amortizing a 15-year build-out over a 5-year lease front-loads expense and makes profit look worse than the economics.

ASU 2023-01 fixes this for all entities, public and private: if the lessor is under common control and the lessee controls the use of the asset, amortize over the useful life to the common control group, regardless of the lease term. There's one exception: if the property LLC itself leases the building from an outside party (so it's subleasing to you), the improvements' life generally can't run past the property LLC's own lease term, unless that outside lease transfers ownership or has a purchase option the property LLC is reasonably certain to exercise.

A worked example: a vet clinic renting from the owner's property LLC

Say you own a veterinary clinic with 20 people. You also own the building, through a separate property LLC. You hold 100% of both, so they're under common control.

At the start of the year the clinic signs a written five-year lease with the property LLC:

  • Rent: $90,000 a year, paid once a year at year end (to keep the math simple)
  • No purchase option; no renewal the clinic is reasonably certain to take
  • The clinic's incremental borrowing rate is 7%
  • It's an operating lease

The same month, the clinic spends $240,000 building out surgery suites and kennels. Those improvements will last about 15 years.

The lease. Because there's a signed lease, the clinic elects the expedient and uses the written terms: five years at $90,000. Discounted at 7%, the clinic records a lease liability and a right-of-use asset of $369,018.

Year endOpening liabilityInterest at 7%PaymentClosing liability
1$369,018$25,831$90,000$304,849
2$304,849$21,339$90,000$236,188
3$236,188$16,533$90,000$162,722
4$162,722$11,391$90,000$84,112
5$84,112$5,888$90,000$0
Total$80,982$450,000

On the P&L the lease cost is a straight-line $90,000 a year. (If you'd rather skip estimating a borrowing rate, private companies can use a risk-free rate instead, but it makes the liability bigger. See the risk-free rate election.)

The improvements. Here's where ASU 2023-01 changes the numbers:

  • Under the general rule, the $240,000 is amortized over the 5-year lease term: $48,000 a year.
  • Under ASU 2023-01, it's amortized over the 15-year useful life to the common control group: $16,000 a year.

That's $32,000 a year less expense in each of the first five years, and $160,000 less over the lease term. Total occupancy cost (rent plus amortization) drops from $138,000 to $106,000 a year.

Book value of the $240,000 build-out

Amortized over the 5-year lease term vs the 15-year useful life to the common control group

  • Over useful life (ASU 2023-01)
  • Over lease term (general rule)
$0$100k$200k$300kStart · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $240,000Y1 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $224,000Y2 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $208,000Y3 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $192,000Y4 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $176,000Y5 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $160,000Y6 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $144,000Y7 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $128,000Y8 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $112,000Y9 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $96,000Y10 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $80,000Y11 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $64,000Y12 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $48,000Y13 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $32,000Y14 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $16,000Y15 · Over useful life (ASU 2023-01): $0Start · Over lease term (general rule): $240,000Y1 · Over lease term (general rule): $192,000Y2 · Over lease term (general rule): $144,000Y3 · Over lease term (general rule): $96,000Y4 · Over lease term (general rule): $48,000Y5 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y6 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y7 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y8 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y9 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y10 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y11 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y12 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y13 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y14 · Over lease term (general rule): $0Y15 · Over lease term (general rule): $0StartY1Y2Y3Y4Y5Y6Y7Y8Y9Y10Y11Y12Y13Y14Y15

Hypothetical example. $16,000 a year over 15 years vs $48,000 a year over 5 years. Assumes the clinic keeps using the building.

Show the numbers
 Over useful life (ASU 2023-01)Over lease term (general rule)
Start$240,000$240,000
Y1$224,000$192,000
Y2$208,000$144,000
Y3$192,000$96,000
Y4$176,000$48,000
Y5$160,000$0
Y6$144,000$0
Y7$128,000$0
Y8$112,000$0
Y9$96,000$0
Y10$80,000$0
Y11$64,000$0
Y12$48,000$0
Y13$32,000$0
Y14$16,000$0
Y15$0$0

What if the clinic moves out? Say after year 5 the clinic relocates and the property LLC rents the building to someone else. The clinic no longer controls the use of the building, and $160,000 of improvements is still on its books. ASU 2023-01 treats that as a transfer between entities under common control: the clinic removes the $160,000 through equity, as a distribution to the property LLC, not as an expense on the P&L. It makes sense economically: the improvements now benefit the property LLC, which you also own.

When did it take effect, and what about transition?

Key dates for ASU 2023-01
  1. March 27, 2023

    ASU issued

    Early adoption permitted in statements not yet issued or made available for issuance.

  2. FY beginning after Dec 15, 2023

    Effective for all entities

    Annual and interim periods. For a calendar-year company, that's 2024.

  3. Dec 31, 2026

    Your next year end

    It's simply current GAAP now. New related-party leases and improvements follow it from day one.

Companies that had already adopted ASC 842 could apply the written-terms expedient prospectively (to arrangements that start or are modified after adoption) or retrospectively to when they adopted ASC 842, and could put existing unwritten terms in writing before issuing the statements. For leasehold improvements, the options were prospective (new improvements only, or new and existing) or retrospective, with any reversal of past amortization going to opening retained earnings.

If you've been issuing GAAP statements since 2024 and still amortize related-party improvements over the lease term, raise it with your auditor or CPA. How to fix it depends on what was elected at transition and how material it is.

Common mistakes

No written lease. The expedient needs written terms. Without them, you're judging enforceability, which is harder, not easier.

Writing a lease you don't follow. If the paper says $90,000 a year but the clinic paid $40,000 and the owner "forgave" the rest, the accounting gets complicated. Ask your auditor before year end.

Applying the improvement rule after control ends. The longer life only holds while the tenant controls the use of the property. Moving out triggers the equity transfer.

Missing the sublease exception. If the property LLC leases the building from an outside landlord, the improvements' life is generally capped by that outside lease.

Forgetting the other related-party questions. ASU 2023-01 covers lease accounting only. Whether the operating company must consolidate the property LLC is a separate question, and so is how the rent is treated for tax. Both are worth a conversation with your auditor and CPA.

When should you get help?

If you have one written lease with your property LLC, no major build-out and no outside readers of your statements, the accounting is manageable: one lease schedule and a clear note.

Get help when your statements are reviewed or audited, when the operating company has spent heavily on the building, when the lease exists only as a handshake, or when a lender is underwriting both entities. Talk to your auditor about the elections and the consolidation question before year end. Setting up related-party lease schedules and improvement amortization is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting. If you're in property or building trades yourself, see how we work with real estate and construction businesses.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a lease between my two LLCs at all?

If the operating company issues GAAP financial statements and uses the building, the arrangement is very likely a lease under ASC 842. A written lease lets a private company use the ASU 2023-01 expedient and makes the accounting much simpler.

Can a public company use the written-terms expedient?

No. It's for entities that aren't public business entities, and most not-for-profits. The leasehold improvement change applies to everyone, public companies included.

What counts as common control?

Generally, the same person or group controls both entities, like an owner with 100% of both LLCs. Partial or shared ownership can be harder to judge; ask your auditor.

Does this change my taxes?

No. ASU 2023-01 is a financial reporting rule. Tax depreciation of improvements and the rent deduction follow tax rules. Ask your CPA how book and tax differ.

We renew the lease every five years. Does that change the amortization?

Under ASU 2023-01, the improvements are amortized over their useful life to the common control group regardless of the lease term, as long as the clinic (the lessee) keeps controlling the use of the building. Renewals don't reset it.

The bottom line

If you rent from your own LLC, put the lease in writing and sign it. That's what makes the ASU 2023-01 expedient available for a private company. Then look at your leasehold improvements: if they're on a lease-term schedule, ASU 2023-01 likely moves them to their useful life to the common control group, with less expense each year. Keep track of whether the business still controls the property, and talk to your auditor about the consolidation and tax questions that sit next to this one.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.