Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

The risk-free rate election: why it makes your lease liability bigger

November 18, 2026 · 9 min read

← All articles
Hand pointing a pen at a printed table of interest rates by decade, with a calculator nearby
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

If you're a private company, ASC 842 lets you discount a lease at a risk-free rate (a Treasury rate for a similar term) instead of working out your incremental borrowing rate, and since ASU 2021-09 you can make that choice by class of asset. It's less work. But a risk-free rate is almost always lower than what you'd pay to borrow, and a lower rate means a bigger lease liability, bigger current liabilities and less room under your loan covenants. Use it where the leases are small; run the numbers before using it for real estate.

When private companies first put leases on the balance sheet, a lot of them reached for the simplest option on the menu: discount everything at a Treasury rate and skip the work of estimating a borrowing rate. Nobody had to call the bank or write a memo.

Then the statements came out, and the lease liability was bigger than anyone expected. For a long warehouse or office lease, the gap can be tens of thousands of dollars, and it lands right where your lender looks.

This post explains what the risk-free rate election is, what ASU 2021-09 changed, and how much the choice moves your numbers, using one seven-year lease discounted both ways. If you need the basics of lease accounting first, start with ASC 842 for small businesses.

What is the risk-free rate election?

Your lease liability is the present value of the lease payments you've committed to. ASC 842 sets the discount rate in this order:

  1. The rate implicit in the lease, if you can readily determine it. As a tenant you usually can't, because you don't know the landlord's figures.
  2. Otherwise, your [incremental borrowing rate](/glossary#incremental-borrowing-rate) (IBR): roughly what you'd pay to borrow, on a secured basis, over a similar term, to buy something of similar value.
  3. If you're not a public business entity, you can elect a risk-free rate instead of the IBR, determined using a period comparable with the lease term. In practice that means a US Treasury yield for a similar maturity at the lease start date.

The election replaces only step 2. If the implicit rate is readily determinable, you still have to use it, election or not. The ASU text and Grant Thornton both say this plainly.

What did ASU 2021-09 change?

The FASB issued ASU 2021-09 on November 11, 2021, after private companies said the original election was all or nothing. Before it, choosing the risk-free rate meant using it for every lease. Few companies wanted that, because the lower rate inflated their biggest leases.

The update made two changes for lessees that aren't public business entities (private companies, not-for-profits and employee benefit plans):

The risk-free election before and after ASU 2021-09

All or nothing

Before ASU 2021-09

  • One entity-wide policy election
  • Applied to every lease, from copiers to headquarters
  • Many companies avoided it because it inflated their biggest leases

By class of asset

After ASU 2021-09

  • Elect by class of underlying asset (real estate, vehicles, equipment)
  • Use the risk-free rate for some classes and the IBR for others
  • Must use the implicit rate whenever it's readily determinable
  • Disclose the election and the classes it covers

Effective date. Companies that hadn't adopted ASC 842 by November 11, 2021 applied the amendments when they adopted ASC 842. Companies that had already adopted applied them for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2021, on a modified retrospective basis. Either way, for 2026 year ends it's simply part of current GAAP.

A worked example: one warehouse lease, two discount rates

Say you run a 25-person specialty food manufacturer and sign a seven-year warehouse lease at the start of 2027. The facts:

  • Rent: $96,000 a year for 7 years, $672,000 in total
  • One payment a year at year end (to keep the math readable)
  • No purchase option, no renewal you're reasonably certain to take, no incentives
  • It's an operating lease
  • Your bank would lend you money for seven years, secured, at about 7.5%. That's your IBR
  • The seven-year Treasury yield at lease start is 4.0% (an assumed figure for the example)

Discount the same seven payments at each rate:

Year endLiability at 7.5% IBRLiability at 4.0% risk-freeDifference
Start$508,474$576,197$67,723
Year 1$450,609$503,245$52,636
Year 2$388,405$427,375$38,970
Year 3$321,535$348,470$26,935
Year 4$249,650$266,409$16,759
Year 5$172,374$181,065$8,691
Year 6$89,302$92,308$3,006
Year 7$0$0$0

Same lease, same rent, same building. Elect the risk-free rate and you book $67,723 more lease liability (and the same extra amount of right-of-use asset) on day one. That's 13% more.

Lease liability over the term at each discount rate

Seven-year warehouse lease, $96,000 a year

  • 4.0% risk-free rate
  • 7.5% incremental borrowing rate
$0$200k$400k$600kStart · 4.0% risk-free rate: $576,197Year 1 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $503,245Year 2 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $427,375Year 3 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $348,470Year 4 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $266,409Year 5 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $181,065Year 6 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $92,308Year 7 · 4.0% risk-free rate: $0Start · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $508,474Year 1 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $450,609Year 2 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $388,405Year 3 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $321,535Year 4 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $249,650Year 5 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $172,374Year 6 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $89,302Year 7 · 7.5% incremental borrowing rate: $0StartYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6Year 7

Hypothetical example. Payments once a year at year end. Rounded to the nearest dollar.

Show the numbers
 4.0% risk-free rate7.5% incremental borrowing rate
Start$576,197$508,474
Year 1$503,245$450,609
Year 2$427,375$388,405
Year 3$348,470$321,535
Year 4$266,409$249,650
Year 5$181,065$172,374
Year 6$92,308$89,302
Year 7$0$0

The gap shrinks every year and closes at the end, because the total paid is $672,000 either way. What differs is how much of that is treated as interest: $163,526 at 7.5% and $95,803 at 4.0%. The lower rate leaves more of each payment as "principal", which is why the liability starts higher.

Does the P&L change?

For an operating lease, no. The expense is straight-line rent, $96,000 a year, under either rate. The rate changes the balance sheet, not operating expense.

For a finance lease (common for equipment and vehicles), yes. The rate drives the interest expense, and a bigger asset means bigger amortization. The rate can also change the classification itself: one of the finance lease tests asks whether the present value of the payments is substantially all of the asset's fair value. A lower rate pushes that present value up, so a lease that was operating at your IBR can tip into finance at a risk-free rate. Grant Thornton flags this as one reason companies avoided the original election.

How does the choice hit your loan covenants?

Here's where it starts to matter. Say before signing the lease your food company has:

  • total liabilities of $1,050,000 and equity of $700,000
  • current assets of $900,000 and current liabilities of $500,000
  • a bank covenant capping total liabilities at 2.5 times equity

The lease adds the same amount to assets and liabilities on day one, so equity doesn't change. Liabilities do. And the part of the liability due within the next year (the year 1 principal) gets added to current liabilities: $57,865 at 7.5%, but $72,952 at 4.0%.

RatioBefore the leaseWith lease at 7.5% IBRWith lease at 4.0% risk-free
Total liabilities$1,050,000$1,558,474$1,626,197
Liabilities to equity (covenant max 2.5x)1.50x2.23x2.32x
Room left under the covenant$700,000$191,526$123,803
Current ratio1.801.611.57

$67,723

Extra lease liability on day one from choosing the risk-free rate

35%

Less room under the 2.5x liabilities-to-equity covenant ($123,803 vs $191,526)

$0

Change to annual operating lease expense ($96,000 either way)

Nothing about the business changed, and you've given up a third of your covenant room with a policy choice. Some loan agreements define debt to leave operating lease liabilities out, and some don't, so read the definitions in yours before assuming either way.

Which classes should get the risk-free rate?

The by-class election is the useful part of ASU 2021-09. A sensible split for many small companies:

A practical way to decide, class by class

Leans toward the risk-free rate

  • Many small leases (copiers, vehicles, forklifts) where estimating an IBR for each isn't worth it
  • Short terms, where the rate barely moves the liability
  • No recent borrowing to anchor an IBR, and covenants with plenty of room

Leans toward the IBR

  • Long, large leases (real estate, major equipment) where the rate moves the liability by tens of thousands
  • Tight debt or current ratio covenants
  • Recent secured borrowing that makes the IBR easy to support
  • Equipment leases close to the finance lease line

Before you decide

  • Run one big lease both ways, like the table above
  • Check whether your covenants include operating lease liabilities
  • Think about whether you might become a public business entity

That last point is easy to miss. Grant Thornton notes that a company that later becomes a public business entity would have to reverse the expedient, which means estimating IBRs retroactively. If an IPO or a public acquirer is realistic, that's a reason to do the IBR work now.

How hard is it to support an incremental borrowing rate?

Less hard than people fear. Start with a real number: the rate on your most recent secured term loan or line, or a written quote from your bank for a loan matching the lease term. Then adjust for the differences (term, collateral, the size of the amount). Write it down in a one-page memo, update it once or twice a year, and use it for every new lease in that class.

What an auditor will ask is where the rate came from and why it fits the lease term. A bank quote plus a short explanation usually answers both.

Common mistakes

Assuming the election is still all or nothing. It hasn't been since ASU 2021-09. Pick by class of asset.

Using the risk-free rate when the implicit rate is known. If the lease or the lessor tells you the implicit rate (common in equipment leases with a stated fair value and residual), you must use it.

Picking the wrong Treasury term. The rate should match the lease term. A one-year rate for a seven-year lease is wrong in either direction.

Switching back and forth. Changing the election later is a change in accounting policy, which needs to be justified as preferable. Choose deliberately once.

Forgetting the disclosure. If you use the election, disclose it and the classes of assets it covers.

When should you get help?

If you have a few vehicle or equipment leases and lots of covenant room, the risk-free rate is a reasonable, low-effort choice. Use it and move on.

Get help when you have a long real estate lease, tight covenants, equipment leases near the finance lease line, or a lender or auditor who reads your statements closely. Talk to your auditor before you commit to an election, and to your lender if covenants are close. Setting up lease schedules, supporting the discount rate and running the comparison is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting. You can also check where you stand today with our debt-to-equity calculator.

Frequently asked questions

Can a public company use the risk-free rate?

No. The election is only for lessees that aren't public business entities: private companies, not-for-profits and employee benefit plans.

Which Treasury rate do we use?

A risk-free rate for a period comparable with the lease term, measured at the lease commencement date. For a seven-year lease, that's roughly a seven-year Treasury yield on the start date.

Can we use the risk-free rate for real estate and the IBR for vehicles?

Yes. Since ASU 2021-09, the election is made by class of underlying asset, so you can mix. Disclose which classes use it.

Does the discount rate affect our taxes?

No. ASC 842 is a book rule. For tax, rent on an operating lease is generally deducted under tax rules, and your CPA tracks book and tax differences.

Our leases are already on the books at the risk-free rate. Can we switch to the IBR?

Possibly, but it's a change in accounting policy that has to be justified as preferable. Talk to your auditor before changing anything.

The bottom line

The risk-free rate election trades effort for a heavier balance sheet. On small leases that trade is usually worth it. On a long real estate lease it can add tens of thousands of dollars of liability and eat into covenant room for no economic reason. ASU 2021-09 lets you choose by class of asset, so run your biggest lease both ways, read your covenants, and make the election on purpose.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.