Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Forgivable loans: debt or grant on your books?

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Hand signing a printed agreement on a white table while two other people look on, with a calculator and folder nearby
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Today, most US businesses book a forgivable government loan as debt under ASC 470 and record a gain only when the lender legally releases them. Some instead treat it as a grant by analogy (to IAS 20 or the not-for-profit rules) once forgiveness is probable. ASU 2025-10 settles it: forgivable loans are treated as government grants once it's probable you'll meet the forgiveness terms. Private companies must adopt it for years beginning after December 15, 2029, and may adopt early.

A state agency lends your company $300,000 to expand. There's no repayment if you keep at least 40 people employed in the state for three years. Your bank calls it a loan. The agency's press release calls it an incentive. And your bookkeeper wants to know which account it goes in.

The answer has been "it depends on your policy" for years. Businesses had no specific US GAAP guidance on government grants, so forgivable loans got booked several different ways. That's changing with ASU 2025-10, but not overnight, and the old choices still matter for statements you issue now.

Why is a forgivable loan hard to classify?

Because its legal form and its likely outcome point in different directions.

Legally, it's debt. You signed a note. If you miss the conditions, you owe the money back, sometimes with interest. Economically, if you fully expect to meet the conditions, it behaves like a grant: cash from a government that you'll never repay, in return for doing something the government wants.

GAAP has rules for debt. Until ASU 2025-10, it had no recognition rules for grants to businesses. So accountants either followed the legal form or borrowed grant guidance from elsewhere.

What does the debt model look like?

The debt model is the default, and it's the one auditors rarely question. Grant Thornton and BDO both describe it for PPP loans:

  • Record the cash and a loan payable when you receive it
  • Accrue interest at the stated rate, if any
  • Keep the liability until you repay it or are legally released by the lender (ASC 405-20)
  • On release, take the loan off the books and record a gain on extinguishment for the forgiven amount, including any forgiven interest

In the cash flow statement, the proceeds are a financing inflow and the forgiveness is a noncash item. For more on when a debt counts as extinguished, see our post on debt modification vs extinguishment.

The downside: income lands when the paperwork lands, often a year or more after you actually earned it by keeping the jobs. And a large loan sitting on the balance sheet can make a debt covenant look worse than reality. (If that's already a problem, read what to do about a loan covenant breach.)

What were the grant alternatives?

For PPP loans, the AICPA's nonauthoritative Q&A (TQA 3200.18) set out four approaches, and practice has applied the same thinking to other forgivable government loans. Sikich summarizes them this way:

ModelInitial entryWhen the income is recognized
Debt (ASC 470)Loan payableWhen legally released by the lender
Grant by analogy to IAS 20Deferred incomeOver the periods the related costs are incurred, once it's probable you'll meet the conditions
Conditional contribution by analogy to ASC 958-605Refundable advanceWhen the conditions are substantially met, or explicitly waived
Gain contingency (ASC 450-30)Loan payableOnly when all contingencies are resolved, including lender approval

Grant Thornton notes two limits on the IAS 20 route. It's an election, not a requirement, and you need support that you're probable to meet both the eligibility and the forgiveness conditions. If you can't support that, it's debt. And under IAS 20 by analogy, the income is never presented as revenue: it's shown separately (usually as other income) or as a reduction of the related expenses.

BDO adds a caution about ASC 958-605: that guidance is written for not-for-profits and excludes transfers from governments to businesses, so a business can only use it by analogy. Pick one model, write it in your accounting policies and apply it the same way to similar loans.

What does ASU 2025-10 change?

ASU 2025-10, issued December 4, 2025, gives business entities their first recognition guidance for government grants. We cover the full standard in our post on government grants under ASU 2025-10; here's the part that matters for loans.

Forgivable loans before and after ASU 2025-10

Today, for most private companies

Before adoption

  • No specific US GAAP rule for businesses
  • Debt model by default; grant models only by analogy
  • Practice differs from company to company
  • Income timing depends on the model chosen

Required for private companies in years beginning after Dec 15, 2029

After adoption

  • Forgivable loan proceeds can be a government grant
  • Recognized as a grant once it's probable you'll meet the forgiveness terms
  • Until then, it stays a liability
  • The benefit of a below-market interest rate is out of scope

BDO's summary says a business can recognize forgivable loan proceeds as a government grant when it's probable it will meet the grant's conditions and the forgiveness terms. Receiving the cash isn't enough by itself. RSM confirms the scope: all business entities, but not not-for-profits or employee benefit plans, with exchange transactions, income taxes, below-market rate loans and government guarantees excluded.

Once it's a grant, the general ASU 2025-10 rules apply. A loan forgiven for keeping jobs or paying certain costs is a grant related to income, recognized over the periods you incur the related costs. A loan forgiven for buying equipment is related to an asset.

Effective dates: public business entities for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2028; everyone else for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2029. Early adoption is allowed for statements not yet issued or made available.

A worked example: a $300,000 state job-retention loan

Say you run a 45-person contract manufacturer. On January 2, 2026, a state economic development agency lends it $300,000 at no interest. One-third ($100,000) is forgiven for each calendar year 2026, 2027 and 2028 in which the company keeps at least 40 full-time employees in the state. The agency confirms each year's headcount and issues a written release the following February. Miss a year, and that year's third is repayable. All numbers are hypothetical.

Headcount has been 44 to 48 for three years, the company has no plans to cut, and management concludes it's probable it will meet the condition each year.

Under the debt model, the full $300,000 sits as a loan payable at the end of 2026. Each February release produces a $100,000 gain: in 2027, 2028 and 2029.

As a grant (by analogy today, or under ASU 2025-10 after adoption), the company recognizes $100,000 in each year it keeps the jobs: 2026, 2027 and 2028. Until it's earned, the unearned portion sits as a liability.

Income from the forgivable loan by year

$300,000 state loan, one-third forgiven per year of job retention

  • Debt model
  • Grant model
$0$25k$50k$75k$100k2026 · Debt model: $02026 · Grant model: $100,0002027 · Debt model: $100,0002027 · Grant model: $100,0002028 · Debt model: $100,0002028 · Grant model: $100,0002029 · Debt model: $100,0002029 · Grant model: $02026202720282029

Hypothetical example. Both models recognize $300,000 in total.

Show the numbers
 Debt modelGrant model
2026$0$100,000
2027$100,000$100,000
2028$100,000$100,000
2029$100,000$0

Total income is the same either way: $300,000. The grant model puts it in the years the company actually earned it. The debt model puts it a year later and leaves the balance sheet showing $300,000 of debt at the end of 2026, versus $200,000 of remaining liability under the grant model.

If headcount later drops below 40 in 2027 under the grant model, that year's $100,000 becomes repayable. Any grant income booked for 2027 is reversed and the amount goes back to a loan payable; Grant Thornton describes this kind of change as a change in estimate. Under ASU 2025-10, BDO describes a repayment as reducing any remaining deferred amount first, with the rest hitting earnings.

Do forgivable loans still exist after PPP?

Yes. PPP is finished, but forgivable loans are a common tool for state and local economic development: loans forgiven for creating or keeping jobs, relocating a facility, investing a set amount in equipment, or staying in a downtown district for a number of years. Some are run by state agencies, some by cities or counties, some through local development corporations.

The terms vary widely, so read the agreement before you pick a model:

  • What exactly triggers forgiveness? A headcount, a payroll total, a capital spend, a date?
  • Is it forgiven all at once or in pieces? Tranches change the timing of income under both models.
  • Who decides, and when? A required certification or audit by the agency affects when you're legally released.
  • What happens if you miss? Full repayment, partial, or with interest? A clawback can reach back years.
  • Is it really from a government? Money passed through a private nonprofit may not be a government grant at all.

And don't assume the tax answer matches the book answer. Whether forgiveness is taxable depends on the program and the law, so ask your CPA.

Common mistakes

Booking the cash as revenue. A forgivable loan is never sales revenue. It's debt, deferred income, or other income (or a cost reduction) once earned.

Recognizing income at signing. Under every grant model, you need probable compliance and costs incurred. Day one isn't the day you earn it.

Switching models loan by loan. Choose a policy and apply it consistently to similar arrangements. Inconsistency is what reviewers flag.

Forgetting the clawback after forgiveness. If an agency can claw back for a later failure, your notes should say so, and a later breach may need a liability.

Ignoring covenants. A large forgivable loan under the debt model can push a debt ratio over its limit. Ask your bank in advance whether it will exclude the balance.

When should you get help?

If your statements are internal only and the loan is small, the debt model is simple and defensible. Book it as a loan, track the conditions in a spreadsheet and record the gain when released.

Get help when the statements go to a bank, investors or a buyer, when the loan is large enough to move a covenant, or when you're considering early adoption of ASU 2025-10. Agree the model with your CPA or auditor before year end. Having balance sheet accounts, loan balances included, reconciled and explained every month is part of the accounting work Fintrix Consulting does.

Frequently asked questions

Can a private company use the grant model before ASU 2025-10 takes effect?

Yes, two ways: by analogy to IAS 20 if you can support that forgiveness is probable, or by adopting ASU 2025-10 early, which is allowed for statements not yet issued. Either way, discuss it with your auditor or reviewer first.

Is forgiven loan income revenue?

No. Under the debt model it's a gain on extinguishment. Under a grant model it's other income or a reduction of the related expenses. It shouldn't be presented as revenue from customers.

What about the interest-free part of the loan?

ASU 2025-10 excludes the benefit of a below-market interest rate loan from its scope, so the forgivable principal follows the grant rules but the low rate itself isn't recognized as a grant.

Do not-for-profits follow ASU 2025-10?

No. Not-for-profits and employee benefit plans are outside its scope. Nonprofits follow their own contribution guidance.

We booked our loan as debt. Do we have to change now?

Not until you adopt ASU 2025-10, which for private companies is required for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2029. Loans fully recognized before adoption may not need restating, depending on the transition method you choose.

The bottom line

A forgivable government loan is debt until something tells you otherwise. Today, most businesses keep it as a loan until the lender releases them, and some use a grant model by analogy when forgiveness is probable. ASU 2025-10 turns that grant approach into the rule for business entities, required for private companies from 2030 for calendar years. Whatever you choose now, read the agreement, document why forgiveness is or isn't probable, and apply one policy consistently.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.