Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Folding customer relationships and noncompetes into goodwill

November 19, 2026 · 8 min read

← All articles
Two people shaking hands over a desk with a laptop showing financial charts and printed reports
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Yes. Under ASU 2014-18, a private company (or not-for-profit) can elect not to recognize two kinds of intangibles separately in an acquisition: customer-related intangibles that can't be sold or licensed on their own, and noncompete agreements. Their value stays inside goodwill instead, so they don't need separate valuations. The catch: you must also amortize goodwill under ASU 2014-02, and the election applies to every future acquisition.

You've just bought a competitor. The deal team has gone home, and now someone has to split the purchase price across everything you acquired. The valuation firm sends a scope that includes the customer relationships, the seller's noncompete, the trade name, the equipment and the working capital. Each intangible needs its own model, its own useful life and its own amortization schedule.

For a private company, two of those can often be skipped. FASB's private company alternative lets you fold most customer relationships and all noncompetes into goodwill, which simplifies the purchase price allocation and the years of accounting after it.

Here's what the alternative covers, what still has to be valued, a worked example both ways, and when you'd rather not elect it.

What does ASU 2014-18 allow?

When a private company elects the alternative, it no longer recognizes separately from goodwill:

  1. Customer-related intangible assets, unless they're capable of being sold or licensed independently from the other assets of the business
  2. Noncompetition agreements

Those amounts are simply included in goodwill. As PwC's guide describes it, you don't recognize or measure them at all, so no fair value estimate is needed for them.

The election isn't limited to business combinations. Per PwC and Baker Tilly, it also applies wherever you'd otherwise measure those intangibles at fair value: basis differences in an equity method investment, fresh-start reporting, and joint venture formations.

2 types

Customer intangibles that can't be sold separately, and noncompetes, fold into goodwill

Required

Electing it means you must also amortize goodwill (ASU 2014-02)

All future deals

A one-time election that applies to every acquisition after you adopt it

Which customer intangibles still have to be valued?

This is where people get tripped up. "Customer-related" doesn't mean "anything to do with customers."

Folded into goodwill: customer contracts and customer relationships that can't be transferred on their own, whatever their length or terms. PwC's example is a five-year service agreement that can't be assigned without the customer's consent. It goes into goodwill.

Still recognized separately:

  • Customer lists or customer information you could legally sell or license, for example where customers consented to sharing. Information you can't sell because of privacy restrictions goes into goodwill
  • Items like mortgage servicing rights, commodity supply contracts and core deposits, which can be sold independently
  • Contract assets under ASC 606. PwC says they aren't eligible to be subsumed
  • Leases, including favorable or unfavorable lease terms. The alternative doesn't apply to them
  • Unfavorable customer contracts, which are still recorded as liabilities at fair value
  • Every other identifiable intangible, such as trade names, technology and software

So a trade name still needs a valuation. A sellable customer list still needs one. What drops out is usually the biggest and hardest piece for a service business: the value of relationships with customers who aren't locked into transferable contracts.

What's the catch?

Two of them.

You must amortize goodwill. Electing ASU 2014-18 requires the goodwill alternative in ASU 2014-02: straight-line amortization over 10 years or less, with impairment testing only when something happens. The reverse isn't required; you can amortize goodwill without electing the intangibles alternative. Our post on private company goodwill amortization covers that election in detail.

It's a one-way door for every future deal. PwC calls it an unconditional, one-time election that applies prospectively to all later acquisitions. You don't pick deal by deal. And if you later go public or sell to a public company, the private company alternatives generally have to be reversed retrospectively, which means rebuilding the purchase accounting as if you'd never elected them.

Intangibles already on your books when you adopt it aren't affected. They keep their existing accounting and aren't moved into goodwill.

A worked example: a landscaping company acquisition

Say you own a commercial landscaping company with a December year-end. You already amortize goodwill under ASU 2014-02. On January 1, 2026 you buy a smaller competitor for $4,000,000. The valuation would show:

ItemWithout ASU 2014-18With ASU 2014-18
Accounts receivable$300,000$300,000
Trucks and equipment$900,000$900,000
Trade name (10 years)$250,000$250,000
Customer relationships, non-transferable service contracts (8 years)$1,000,000In goodwill
Seller's noncompete (3 years)$150,000In goodwill
Liabilities assumed($200,000)($200,000)
Net identifiable assets$2,400,000$1,250,000
Goodwill (10 years)$1,600,000$2,750,000
Total price$4,000,000$4,000,000

With the election, goodwill is $1,600,000 plus the $1,000,000 of customer relationships and the $150,000 noncompete: $2,750,000. The customer contracts here can't be assigned without consent, so they qualify.

Now the amortization. Without the election you run four schedules:

  • Customer relationships: $1,000,000 ÷ 8 = $125,000 a year for 8 years
  • Noncompete: $150,000 ÷ 3 = $50,000 a year for 3 years
  • Trade name: $250,000 ÷ 10 = $25,000 a year
  • Goodwill: $1,600,000 ÷ 10 = $160,000 a year

That's $360,000 a year in 2026 to 2028, $310,000 in 2029 to 2033 once the noncompete is done, and $185,000 in 2034 and 2035.

With the election you run two: trade name $25,000 plus goodwill $275,000 ($2,750,000 ÷ 10), a flat $300,000 a year for ten years.

Annual amortization from the acquisition

$4.0M landscaping company acquired January 1, 2026, goodwill amortized over 10 years either way

  • Without ASU 2014-18
  • With ASU 2014-18
$0$100k$200k$300k$400k2026 · Without ASU 2014-18: $360,0002027 · Without ASU 2014-18: $360,0002028 · Without ASU 2014-18: $360,0002029 · Without ASU 2014-18: $310,0002030 · Without ASU 2014-18: $310,0002031 · Without ASU 2014-18: $310,0002032 · Without ASU 2014-18: $310,0002033 · Without ASU 2014-18: $310,0002034 · Without ASU 2014-18: $185,0002035 · Without ASU 2014-18: $185,0002026 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002027 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002028 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002029 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002030 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002031 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002032 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002033 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002034 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002035 · With ASU 2014-18: $300,0002026202720282029203020312032203320342035

Hypothetical example. Both total $3,000,000 over ten years.

Show the numbers
 Without ASU 2014-18With ASU 2014-18
2026$360,000$300,000
2027$360,000$300,000
2028$360,000$300,000
2029$310,000$300,000
2030$310,000$300,000
2031$310,000$300,000
2032$310,000$300,000
2033$310,000$300,000
2034$185,000$300,000
2035$185,000$300,000

Over ten years, both add up to the same $3,000,000 of amortization. The election doesn't create or remove expense. It changes the shape (flat instead of front-loaded), cuts two valuations and two schedules, and removes two asset classes you'd otherwise test for impairment separately.

Does it change taxes?

No. Book and tax are separate here. For federal tax, goodwill, customer-based intangibles and noncompetes entered into with the purchase of a business are generally section 197 intangibles, amortized over 15 years whatever you do in your GAAP statements. The tax allocation of the price follows its own rules, so your CPA's numbers will differ from your book purchase price allocation anyway. Buying a business: the ASC 805 checklist covers the tax side of a deal.

Should you elect it?

For most owner-managed private companies that plan to stay private, it's a sensible simplification, especially if you're buying service businesses where most of the value sits in relationships and the seller's promise not to compete.

Elect ASU 2014-18 or not?

Simpler

Usually elect

  • You already amortize goodwill, or are happy to
  • Customer contracts can't be transferred without consent
  • Lenders and owners care about cash and EBITDA, not intangible detail
  • No realistic plan to go public or sell to a public company

Keep options

Think twice

  • An IPO or sale to a public company is a real possibility
  • Buyers or investors want customer intangibles shown separately
  • You want customer relationships amortized faster than goodwill
  • You'd rather not amortize goodwill at all

Decide before the valuation is ordered. Once the firm has built a customer relationship model, you've paid for the work the election would have saved.

What do the financial statements still disclose?

PwC notes the alternative adds no new disclosure requirements, but the normal ASC 805 disclosures still apply. You still describe the nature of the intangibles you acquired, including the customer relationships and noncompete folded into goodwill, though you don't give their fair value. Your CPA will usually also want the election described in the accounting policies note.

Common mistakes

Folding in a sellable customer list. If the list could be sold or licensed on its own, it stays separate. Check consent and privacy terms before deciding.

Electing ASU 2014-18 without goodwill amortization. You can't. They come as a pair, so decide both together.

Moving old intangibles into goodwill. Intangibles recognized before you elect stay where they are.

Treating it as a deal-by-deal choice. It applies to every acquisition after you adopt it. A later deal where you'd prefer separate intangibles doesn't get a different answer.

Forgetting contract assets and leases. Unbilled contract revenue and favorable lease terms still get recorded separately, even with the election.

When should you get help?

Before you sign the valuation engagement, ideally before closing. The election shapes what gets valued, how goodwill is amortized, and what happens if you sell to a public buyer later. If your statements are reviewed or audited, your CPA will want the decision and the reasoning documented.

Day to day, the work is booking the amortization each month and keeping the goodwill and intangible balances reconciled and explained, which is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting. The valuation itself comes from a valuation specialist.

Frequently asked questions

Who can elect the private company intangibles alternative?

Private companies and not-for-profit entities. Public business entities and employee benefit plans can't.

Does ASU 2014-18 mean I never value customer intangibles?

No. Customer-related intangibles that can be sold or licensed on their own, like a customer list with consent to transfer, are still recognized separately. Contract assets, leases and unfavorable customer contracts also stay separate.

Can I elect it for one acquisition and not the next?

No. It's a one-time election that applies to all acquisitions after you adopt it.

Do I have to amortize goodwill if I elect it?

Yes. Electing ASU 2014-18 requires the goodwill amortization alternative in ASU 2014-02, over 10 years or less. You can amortize goodwill without electing ASU 2014-18, but not the other way around.

Does it reduce my total expense?

Not over the life of the assets. The same amount gets amortized; it just runs through goodwill instead of separate intangibles, usually on a flatter schedule.

The bottom line

ASU 2014-18 lets a private company leave non-transferable customer relationships and noncompetes inside goodwill instead of valuing and amortizing them separately. It comes bundled with goodwill amortization, applies to every future deal, and has to be unwound if you ever go public. For most owner-managed businesses that will stay private, that's a fair trade for a simpler allocation. Make the call before the valuation starts.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.