Accounting standards
Profits interests in LLCs: are they stock compensation? (ASU 2024-01)
November 18, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Often, yes. ASU 2024-01 says a profits interest is in the scope of stock compensation (ASC 718) if it's an equity interest in the company, or if any cash it pays is based at least partly on the value of the company's units. A plan that just pays a share of yearly profits, with no stake in the company's value, usually falls under bonus-style accounting (ASC 710) instead. Private companies apply the ASU for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2025, so calendar 2026 statements are the first.
You run a growing LLC and you want to keep two or three key people for the long haul. Your attorney suggests profits interests: units that share in future growth above today's value, usually without a tax bill on day one. Everyone signs, the team is happy, and then your auditor asks the question nobody priced in: "Is this ASC 718 or ASC 710?"
That question decides when the cost hits your statements, how big it is, and whether you need a valuation. ASU 2024-01 doesn't change the rules, but it adds four worked cases showing how to apply them, and private companies apply it starting with 2026 year-ends.
Mar 2024
FASB issued ASU 2024-01 on March 21, 2024
FY 2026
Private companies: fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2025. Early adoption allowed
Scope only
It clarifies which guidance applies. Recognition and measurement rules didn't change
What is a profits interest?
A profits interest is an ownership stake in a partnership, or an LLC taxed as one, that's issued for services. The holder gets nothing if the business were liquidated the day the interest is granted. They only share in value above a threshold, often called a hurdle, usually set at the company's value on the grant date.
Say your LLC is worth $8 million today and you grant a key employee 5% of the growth above $8 million. If you sell for $12 million in five years, their share is 5% of $4 million, or $200,000. If you never grow, they get nothing.
That design is what makes them attractive for tax, and what made the accounting confusing.
What does ASU 2024-01 actually clarify?
ASC 718 covers share-based payment awards. An award is in scope if it's settled in the company's equity, or if it's a liability where:
- the amounts paid are based, at least in part, on the price of the company's shares or other equity instruments (for an LLC, its units), or
- the award requires or may require settlement in equity.
If neither is true, ASC 718 doesn't apply, and you usually account for it like any other compensation arrangement, often under ASC 710 (compensation, general), the way you'd handle a cash bonus or profit-sharing plan.
The ASU adds an example with four cases. In all of them, a partnership grants incentive units to employees for services.
| Case | What the award looks like | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| A | Real units (profits interests) that cliff vest after three years of service, or immediately on a sale. Vested holders share in the residual value of the company | ASC 718 |
| B | Real units that share in operating distributions from the grant date, but only vest on a sale and are forfeited before then | ASC 718 |
| C | Phantom units, not equity. On a sale they vest and pay cash based on the price of the company's units, if the holder still works there | ASC 718 (the cash is based at least partly on unit value) |
| D | Phantom units that pay 1% of prior-year net income after three years of service, with no share in sale proceeds, forfeitable at any time | Not ASC 718 (it's based on an operating metric, not unit value) |
The pattern is simple once you see it. Labels don't matter. Calling something a "profits interest" or "phantom unit" doesn't decide anything. What matters is whether it's equity, or whether what it pays depends on what the company is worth.
Cases A, B, C
ASC 718 (stock compensation)
- Real equity units in the LLC
- Or cash payouts tied at least partly to the value of the units
- Usually needs a fair value estimate at grant
- Expense recognized over the service period, or when a sale becomes probable for sale-contingent awards
- Specific ASC 718 disclosures
Case D
Other guidance, often ASC 710
- Not equity, and never settled in equity
- Pays based on an operating metric such as net income or revenue
- No unit valuation needed
- Accrue the expected payout as employees earn it
- Accounted for much like a bonus or profit-sharing plan
Does this change how the award is measured?
No. ASU 2024-01 is a scope update only. Once you know which topic applies, the existing rules of that topic do the rest. In broad strokes:
- ASC 718 equity awards (like Case A) are generally measured at fair value on the grant date and expensed over the period the employee has to work to earn them. For a private LLC, that usually means getting a valuation of the units.
- ASC 718 awards that pay cash (like Case C) are liabilities and are remeasured until they settle.
- Awards that only vest on a sale (like Case B or C) generally aren't expensed until the sale is probable, which in practice often means when it happens.
- ASC 710 arrangements (like Case D) are accrued as the employees earn the expected payout.
This is where your auditor's judgment matters most.
A worked example: two plans, two very different P&Ls
Say you run a 30-person engineering consultancy organized as an LLC taxed as a partnership, with a December year-end. On January 1, 2026 the business is worth about $8 million, and you want to reward three senior engineers. Your attorney drafts two options.
Plan 1: Class B profits interests. The three engineers receive real LLC units worth, together, 10% of any value above $8 million. The units vest 25% a year over four years of service and share in distributions and sale proceeds above the hurdle. This looks like Case A, so it's ASC 718. A valuation puts the grant-date fair value of all the units at $480,000. With service-only vesting and a straight-line expense policy, that's $120,000 a year from 2026 to 2029.
Plan 2: profit-share units. No equity. Each year, the three engineers split 5% of the prior year's net income (before this plan), paid in March if they're still employed. They get nothing on a sale. This looks like Case D, so it's outside ASC 718. You accrue 5% of each year's net income as the year goes.
Here's what each plan costs on the P&L if net income before the plan is $1.2 million in 2026, $1.4 million in 2027, $1.6 million in 2028 and $1.8 million in 2029:
| Year | Net income before plan | Plan 1 expense (ASC 718) | Plan 2 expense (5% accrual) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $1,200,000 | $120,000 | $60,000 |
| 2027 | $1,400,000 | $120,000 | $70,000 |
| 2028 | $1,600,000 | $120,000 | $80,000 |
| 2029 | $1,800,000 | $120,000 | $90,000 |
| Total | $480,000 | $300,000 |
Annual compensation expense from each plan
Same three engineers, two plan designs
- Plan 1: Class B units (ASC 718)
- Plan 2: profit-share units (ASC 710)
Hypothetical example. Plan 1: $480,000 grant-date fair value ÷ 4 years. Plan 2: 5% of net income before the plan.
Show the numbers
| Plan 1: Class B units (ASC 718) | Plan 2: profit-share units (ASC 710) | |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $120,000 | $60,000 |
| 2027 | $120,000 | $70,000 |
| 2028 | $120,000 | $80,000 |
| 2029 | $120,000 | $90,000 |
Notice what's going on. Plan 1's expense is fixed at the grant-date value, and it's non-cash: no money leaves the company until there's a distribution or a sale. Plan 2's expense moves with profit, and every dollar of it is cash paid each March. Plan 1 also needs a valuation and more disclosures. Plan 2 doesn't.
Neither is "better". The mistake is picking one without knowing which column it lands in.
What changes for the people who receive real units?
A quick, high-level note on tax, because it affects payroll. When a profits interest meets the IRS safe harbor in Rev. Proc. 93-27 (clarified by Rev. Proc. 2001-43 for unvested interests), the grant generally isn't taxable to the employee. There are exceptions, for example interests tied to a substantially certain and predictable stream of income, interests sold within two years, or interests in publicly traded partnerships. Many advisors recommend a protective Section 83(b) election, which has to be filed within 30 days of the grant.
The bigger practical change: the holder generally becomes a partner for tax purposes. They get a Schedule K-1, and their pay is usually treated as a guaranteed payment rather than W-2 wages. That changes payroll, withholding and benefits. Settle this with your tax advisor before the grant, not after.
And keep the two worlds apart: a $0 value for tax doesn't mean $0 expense under ASC 718.
What should you do before your 2026 year-end?
Inventory
- List every incentive unit, phantom unit, profit-share and sale bonus plan
- Collect the signed agreements and the operating agreement
- Note vesting terms, what happens on termination, and what holders get on a sale
Classify
- For each plan, ask: is it equity, or does any payout depend on unit value?
- Map it to the closest of the FASB's Cases A to D
- Agree the conclusion with your auditor or reviewer
Measure and record
- Get a valuation at grant for ASC 718 equity awards
- Book the monthly expense over the service period
- Accrue bonus-style plans as they're earned
- Pick prospective or retrospective transition for ASU 2024-01
Tax and payroll
- Confirm safe harbor treatment and any 83(b) elections with your tax advisor
- Move new partners from W-2 payroll to guaranteed payments if required
Common mistakes
Deciding by the name of the plan. "Phantom equity" can be ASC 718 (Case C) and a "profits interest" can come with surprises. Read the payout terms.
Assuming no tax means no expense. The tax safe harbor and ASC 718 answer different questions. Most real profits interests still create book compensation expense.
Skipping the valuation. If the award is in ASC 718, you need a fair value. Estimating it after the fact is harder and less convincing than doing it at grant.
Forgetting sale-contingent awards. Awards that only vest on a sale usually wait until the sale is probable, then the expense can land all at once.
When to get help
If your plan is a simple cash bonus based on profit, you may be able to handle it in your normal close. Once real units, sale bonuses or a valuation are involved, get your auditor or reviewer involved before you grant, and bring your tax advisor in at the same time.
Our accounting service at Fintrix Consulting can help classify existing plans, set up the monthly entries and prepare the support your auditor will ask for, while your CPA handles the tax side through tax support. If you'd like to talk through a plan you're drafting, book a call. For how owners of LLCs are paid more generally, see how to pay yourself from an LLC or S corp.
Frequently asked questions
We don't have audited financial statements. Does ASU 2024-01 matter?
It matters if you prepare GAAP financial statements for a lender, investor or reviewer. If your statements are tax-basis or for internal use only, the GAAP classification may not come up, though the economics of the plan still do.
Do we have to restate past years?
No. You can apply it prospectively to awards granted or modified on or after adoption, with a short disclosure. Retrospective application is also allowed.
What if our plan pays both a share of profits and a share of sale proceeds?
The sale-proceeds part generally depends on the value of the company, which points to ASC 718. Mixed plans need careful reading, so review them with your auditor.
Is a profits interest taxable when it's granted?
Usually not, if it meets the IRS safe harbor in Rev. Proc. 93-27 and 2001-43. There are exceptions, and the holder generally becomes a partner. Confirm the details with your tax advisor.
The bottom line
ASU 2024-01 didn't change the stock compensation rules. It made the scope question easier to answer: if an award is equity or pays based on what the company is worth, it's ASC 718; if it pays based on profit alone, it's usually a bonus-style plan. For private companies it applies starting with 2026 statements, so list your plans now, classify each one with your auditor, and get valuations in place for anything that lands in ASC 718. Keep the tax conversation running alongside, because the people receiving the units will feel that part first.
Sources
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- Writing a capitalization policy: the $2,500 rule and GAAP
November 19, 2026
- Should you capitalize sales commissions? (ASC 340-40)
November 19, 2026
- Refinanced your loan? Modification vs extinguishment
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.