Accounting standards
When a deferred tax asset needs a valuation allowance
November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Quick answer
Under ASC 740, a deferred tax asset needs a valuation allowance when it's more likely than not (more than 50%) that some or all of it won't be realized. You decide by weighing positive and negative evidence about future taxable income from four sources: reversing taxable differences, future earnings, carrybacks and tax planning strategies. A cumulative pretax loss over the last three years is strong negative evidence that's hard to overcome, which is why many young C corporations carry a full or large allowance.
Your C corporation lost money for three years. On paper, all those losses created something valuable: a net operating loss carryforward that will cut future tax bills. Your balance sheet might show it as a deferred tax asset worth a few hundred thousand dollars.
Then the reviewer asks the obvious question. Will you actually make enough taxable income to use it? If the honest answer is "probably not, or not soon," GAAP says you can't carry the full asset. You reduce it with a valuation allowance.
This post covers how the test works, the evidence that counts, how the post-2017 NOL rules change the math, a worked example, and what happens when the business turns around and the allowance comes off.
What is a valuation allowance, in plain terms?
A deferred tax asset (DTA) represents future tax savings. Common ones in a small C corp are NOL carryforwards, tax credit carryforwards, and expenses booked now but deductible later, like accrued bonuses or a reserve for bad debts. If you need a refresher on where these come from, start with our post on deferred taxes for C corporations.
Tax savings only exist if there's taxable income to save tax on. The valuation allowance is a contra account that reduces the DTA to the amount that's more likely than not to be realized. PwC's income tax guide defines the threshold precisely: a likelihood of more than 50 percent.
It's not a write-off of the NOL itself. The carryforward still exists for tax purposes and still shows up on the corporate return. The allowance just says the financial statements won't count on it yet.
Who needs to think about this?
Only entities that record deferred taxes under GAAP. That means C corporations issuing GAAP financial statements, typically because a lender, investors or a buyer requires them. S corporations and partnerships generally don't record federal deferred taxes, since income passes through to the owners.
The question gets serious when the company has:
- Losses in the current year or recent years
- Large NOL or credit carryforwards
- A history of carryforwards expiring unused
- Uncertain prospects: a key contract ending, a lawsuit, a market shift
A consistently profitable company with modest DTAs usually clears the test without much paperwork.
What are the four sources of taxable income?
ASC 740 lists four places future taxable income can come from. RSM's summary puts them like this:
More objective
- Future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences. Deferred tax liabilities, such as bonus depreciation on equipment, will create taxable income when they reverse.
- Taxable income in prior carryback years, if tax law allows a carryback. For most corporations today it doesn't (see below).
More judgmental
- Future taxable income apart from reversing differences and carryforwards: your projections.
- Tax planning strategies you would actually carry out to avoid a carryforward expiring unused, such as accelerating taxable income or selling appreciated assets.
You don't need all four. If one source alone supports the whole DTA, you can stop there. But when evidence is mixed, the objective sources carry more weight, because ASC 740 weights evidence according to how much it can be objectively verified. A DTL that will reverse on a schedule is hard evidence. A forecast showing a turnaround next year is soft evidence.
Why are cumulative losses so hard to overcome?
Because the standard says so directly. Both PwC and RSM quote ASC 740: a cumulative loss in recent years is a significant piece of negative evidence that is difficult to overcome.
Practice usually measures "recent years" as the current year plus the two before it, a three-year cumulative pretax loss. PwC notes this is a starting point, not a bright line, and there's no authoritative requirement for exactly three years.
Here's how the evidence typically lines up:
| Negative evidence | Positive evidence |
|---|---|
| Cumulative pretax losses in recent years | A strong earnings history apart from the loss that created the DTA |
| Carryforwards that have expired unused before | Existing contracts or a firm backlog that will produce enough taxable income |
| Losses expected in the next few years, even if profitable now | Assets worth more than their tax basis, enough to realize the DTA if sold |
| Unsettled matters that could hurt results if they go badly | Taxable temporary differences that reverse in the right years |
| A carryforward period too short to use a large deduction | Tax planning strategies that are prudent and feasible |
Management's belief that the company will turn profitable doesn't settle it. PwC is explicit that it isn't sufficient by itself. You need evidence a skeptical reviewer can check.
How do the post-2017 NOL rules affect the analysis?
The tax rules set how fast an NOL can be used, so they feed straight into the valuation allowance.
For corporations, NOLs arising in tax years beginning after 2017:
- Can't be carried back if they arose after 2020. The 2025 Form 1120 instructions say only farming losses and losses of certain insurance companies can be carried back. So the carryback source of taxable income is usually empty.
- Carry forward indefinitely. RSM notes post-2017 NOLs don't expire, which removes one classic piece of negative evidence (losses expiring unused).
- Can only offset 80% of taxable income in any year (computed before certain deductions), per the Form 1120 instructions. NOLs from before 2018 aren't subject to the 80% limit but can still expire.
The 80% limit has a practical effect. Even if a DTL will reverse and create $100,000 of taxable income, the NOL can absorb only $80,000 of it. RSM points out that this is why you have to schedule reversals of DTLs and DTAs, rather than simply netting them. The same logic applies to a DTL from an indefinite-lived asset, such as tax-deductible goodwill: it can support an indefinite-lived NOL, but only up to the 80% cap.
A worked example: a three-year-old manufacturer
Say you run a hypothetical C corporation that makes specialty equipment. It lost money in each of its first three years and has a three-year cumulative pretax loss. At December 31, 2026, using the 21% federal rate only:
| Item | Temporary difference | Deferred tax at 21% |
|---|---|---|
| NOL carryforward (post-2017) | $1,200,000 | $252,000 DTA |
| Accrued expenses | $200,000 | $42,000 DTA |
| Allowance for credit losses | $100,000 | $21,000 DTA |
| Gross deferred tax assets | $1,500,000 | $315,000 |
| Bonus depreciation on equipment | $400,000 | $84,000 DTL |
Given the cumulative loss, you don't rely on projections. The only objective source is the $400,000 DTL reversing over the next four years. Assume the accrued expenses and credit losses also reverse (become deductible) in those same years.
- The $400,000 of reversing taxable income first absorbs the $300,000 of reversing deductions. That supports $300,000 × 21% = $63,000 of DTAs.
- That leaves $100,000 of taxable income. Because of the 80% limit, the NOL can offset only $80,000 of it. That supports $80,000 × 21% = $16,800 of the NOL DTA.
- Total DTAs supported: $63,000 + $16,800 = $79,800. The valuation allowance is $315,000 − $79,800 = $235,200.
From gross DTA to net DTA after the allowance
Hypothetical manufacturer, December 31, 2026, 21% federal rate
- Deferred tax asset
- Allowance
- Total
Hypothetical example. Assumes the deductible differences and the DTL reverse in the same future years.
Show the numbers
| NOL carryforward | +$252,000 |
| Accrued expenses | +$42,000 |
| Credit loss reserve | +$21,000 |
| Gross DTA | $315,000 |
| Valuation allowance | −$235,200 |
| Net DTA | $79,800 |
Now net it against the $84,000 DTL (same jurisdiction, so they're netted, and all of it is noncurrent). The balance sheet shows a net deferred tax liability of $4,200: $84,000 less $79,800.
That surprises owners. The company has $1.2 million of losses to carry forward and still shows a small deferred tax liability. The reason is the 80% limit: $20,000 of the future taxable income ($100,000 less the $80,000 the NOL can offset) will be taxed no matter what, and $20,000 × 21% is exactly $4,200.
What happens when you release a valuation allowance?
You reassess the allowance at every reporting date. When the evidence shifts, the allowance changes, in whole or in part. It doesn't have to be all or nothing: a company might release the part supported by a firm contract and keep the rest.
A release reduces income tax expense in the period you change the judgment, often by a large amount. Two practical points:
- Expect questions. A large tax benefit in a year of modest pretax profit is the first thing a reader notices. Explain it in your note to the statements and in the cover note to your lender.
- Watch the disclosures. The new income tax disclosure rules change how tax items are broken out; see our post on ASU 2023-09 income tax disclosures for what applies to you.
Common mistakes
Carrying a full DTA on a loss-making company. Booking the NOL benefit with no allowance and no analysis is one of the first things a reviewer or a buyer's diligence team challenges.
Netting DTLs against DTAs without scheduling. Since the 80% limit, a DTL doesn't automatically support an equal amount of NOL DTA. Schedule the reversals.
Leaning on forecasts. Projections are the weakest evidence when there's a history of losses. If your case rests on next year's budget alone, it probably won't hold.
Forgetting state taxes. States have their own NOL rules and limits. A federal conclusion doesn't automatically carry over.
Not documenting the judgment. Write a short memo each year: the evidence on each side, the sources you relied on, and the conclusion. It saves hours at year end.
When should you get help?
If your C corp only produces tax-basis statements, you may never book deferred taxes or a valuation allowance. Your CPA tracks the NOL on the return.
Once GAAP statements are required, the allowance becomes a real judgment call with real numbers attached, and your CPA or auditor will want to see the support. Your books need to provide it: a fixed asset register with book and tax columns, accruals split by type, and reserves you can explain. Keeping those balance sheet accounts reconciled and explained each month is part of the accounting work Fintrix Consulting does.
Frequently asked questions
Does a valuation allowance mean I lose my NOL?
No. The NOL still exists for tax purposes and can still reduce taxable income on future returns. The allowance only affects the financial statements: it says the benefit isn't more likely than not to be realized yet.
Is a three-year cumulative loss an automatic full allowance?
Not automatic, but it's strong negative evidence. You'd need objective positive evidence to outweigh it, such as reversing deferred tax liabilities, a firm backlog or a strong earnings history apart from an unusual loss.
Can a corporation carry an NOL back to get a refund?
Generally not for losses arising after 2020. The current Form 1120 instructions allow carrybacks only for farming losses and certain insurance company losses. Most corporate NOLs now carry forward indefinitely, limited to 80% of taxable income each year.
How often should the allowance be reassessed?
At every reporting date you issue financial statements. For most private companies that's at least annually, and quarterly if a lender requires quarterly statements.
Do S corporations need a valuation allowance?
Generally not for federal tax, because S corporations don't record federal deferred taxes. A state that taxes the entity directly, or a conversion between S and C status, can change that, so ask your CPA.
The bottom line
A deferred tax asset is only worth what you can use. When losses pile up, ASC 740 asks you to prove, with evidence a reviewer can check, that the company will earn enough taxable income to use them. Start with the objective sources, schedule reversals with the 80% NOL limit in mind, and document the judgment every year. When the business turns around, the allowance comes off, and you'll want to explain that one-time benefit before anyone asks.
Sources
This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.
More articles
- 100% bonus depreciation is permanent: book vs tax effects
November 20, 2026
- The AICPA's FRF for SMEs: a simpler alternative to GAAP?
November 20, 2026
- Writing a capitalization policy: the $2,500 rule and GAAP
November 19, 2026
Have a question about this article?
Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.
Ready for books you can trust?
Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.