Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Earnouts: purchase price or compensation?

November 19, 2026 · 9 min read

← All articles
Close-up of a handshake across a wooden meeting table over a stack of papers, a folder and a pen
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASC 805, an earnout is part of the purchase price (contingent consideration) unless it's really pay for the seller's work after closing. The deciding factor is whether the seller loses the payment if they stop working for you: if it's automatically forfeited when employment ends, it's compensation expense, not purchase price. Purchase-price earnouts go on the books at fair value on closing day, and if they're cash-settled liabilities, every later change in their value runs through profit and loss.

You're buying a business and the price gap won't close. The seller thinks next year will be huge. You're not so sure. So you agree on an earnout: $3 million at closing, plus up to $1 million more if revenue hits a target in two years.

It's a sensible deal tool. But it creates an accounting question that catches a lot of buyers: is that extra $1 million part of what you paid for the business, or is it what you're paying the seller to keep working for you? The answer moves hundreds of thousands of dollars between goodwill and your income statement, and it's mostly decided by how the purchase agreement is worded.

This post covers how ASC 805 treats a purchase-price earnout, the tests that turn an earnout into compensation, how asset acquisitions differ, and a worked example showing both versions of the same deal.

What is an earnout, in accounting terms?

An earnout is a promise to pay the seller more later if something happens: revenue or EBITDA hits a target, a big contract renews, a product gets approved. In a business combination, ASC 805 calls it contingent consideration when it's part of the price for the business.

Our guide to buying a business covers the whole acquisition method. This post zooms in on the earnout, because it's the piece that keeps moving after closing.

How is a purchase-price earnout recorded at closing?

At fair value on the acquisition date. Not the maximum, and not zero because you hope you'll never pay it.

Fair value here means what the earnout is worth today given the odds of each outcome and the time until payment. In practice, valuers use either a scenario approach (probability-weight the possible payouts and discount them) or an option-pricing technique when the payout depends on something volatile, as PwC's fair value guide describes. Our post on fair value under ASC 820 explains the framework.

That fair value is added to the cash and any seller note to get the total consideration. Total consideration minus the fair value of the net assets you bought is goodwill. So a purchase-price earnout makes goodwill bigger on day one.

Is the earnout a liability or equity?

It depends on how it's settled.

  • Paid in cash, it's a liability. That's most small and mid-size deals.
  • Paid in the buyer's shares, it might be equity, but only if it meets the conditions in the liabilities vs equity guidance (ASC 480 and ASC 815-40). A share earnout where the number of shares varies to hit a dollar amount usually ends up as a liability anyway.

The classification matters because it decides what happens next. A liability gets remeasured to fair value at every reporting date, with the change going through earnings, until it's settled. An equity-classified earnout isn't remeasured, and its settlement is recorded in equity.

What happens to the earnout after closing?

This is the part that surprises owners. For a liability-classified earnout:

  • Changes from events after closing go to profit and loss. If the acquired business has a great first year and the earnout becomes more likely to pay, the liability goes up and you record an expense. A strong year can produce a loss line.
  • Measurement period adjustments go to goodwill. If, within the measurement period (at most one year from the acquisition date), you get better information about facts that existed at closing, you adjust the opening fair value and goodwill instead. Hitting or missing a target after closing never counts. PwC's guide is explicit that information about events after the acquisition date isn't a measurement period adjustment.
  • Settlement. When you pay, the liability is cleared. If it was remeasured correctly at the last reporting date, there's little left to record.

Goodwill doesn't move when the earnout's value changes after the measurement period. That's the trade-off the FASB chose: the price is fixed at closing, and later surprises show up in earnings.

When is an earnout really compensation?

When it pays the seller for working, not for selling. ASC 805-10-55-25 lists eight indicators. One of them settles the question on its own.

ASC 805-10-55-25: consideration or compensation?

Decisive on its own

  • Continuing employment. If payments are automatically forfeited when the seller's employment ends, it's compensation for postcombination services. Full stop.

Weigh the rest together

  • Duration of employment. A required service period as long as the earnout period points to compensation
  • Level of pay. If the seller's salary is reasonable next to other key people, the earnout looks more like extra price
  • Incremental payments. Sellers who stay get more per share than sellers who don't
  • Shares owned. Sellers with small stakes getting large earnouts
  • Link to the valuation. An earnout bridging a gap between valuations points to price
  • The formula. A multiple of earnings suggests price; a percentage of profits suggests a profit-sharing bonus
  • Other agreements. Noncompetes, consulting deals, leases and the tax treatment

PwC's guide says the forfeiture indicator is decisive, and it stays decisive even when forfeited amounts are reallocated to the other sellers who stay.

If the earnout is compensation, it isn't part of the consideration at all. It's left out of the goodwill calculation and recognized as expense in the periods after closing while the seller works.

Here's the practical part. Buyers often add "the seller must still be employed on the payment date" without thinking about it, as a retention tool. That one clause can move the whole earnout out of the purchase price and onto the income statement.

A worked example: one earnout, two contracts

Say you buy a hypothetical marketing agency on January 1, 2026. You pay $3,000,000 in cash. The fair value of the identifiable net assets (receivables, equipment, customer relationships, less liabilities) is $2,100,000. The earnout pays the seller, who'll stay on as managing director at a market salary, up to $1,000,000 at the end of 2027 depending on 2027 revenue. On closing day, a valuer puts its fair value at $400,000.

Version A: the seller gets paid even if they leave. The earnout is cash-settled contingent consideration, a liability.

  • Total consideration: $3,000,000 + $400,000 = $3,400,000
  • Goodwill: $3,400,000 − $2,100,000 = $1,300,000
  • End of 2026: strong bookings push the earnout's fair value to $650,000. You record $250,000 of expense.
  • End of 2027: revenue hits the top tier. The payout is $1,000,000, so you record another $350,000 of expense and pay it.

Version B: the payment is forfeited if the seller leaves before the end of 2027. It's compensation under ASC 805-10-55-25(a).

  • Total consideration: $3,000,000
  • Goodwill: $3,000,000 − $2,100,000 = $900,000
  • The earnout is accrued as compensation over the two years of service. At the end of 2026 the expected payout is $650,000, and half the service period has passed, so you record $325,000.
  • In 2027 the payout turns out to be $1,000,000, so you record the remaining $675,000.
Version A: purchase priceVersion B: compensation
Earnout at closing$400,000 liabilityNothing recorded
Goodwill$1,300,000$900,000
2026 expense$250,000$325,000
2027 expense$350,000$675,000
Total expense from the earnout$600,000$1,000,000
Cash paid at end of 2027$1,000,000$1,000,000

Same $1,000,000 earnout, two accounting answers

Hypothetical marketing agency acquisition

  • Version A: purchase price
  • Version B: compensation
$0$500k$1M$1.5MGoodwill at closing · Version A: purchase price: $1,300,000Goodwill at closing · Version B: compensation: $900,0002026 expense · Version A: purchase price: $250,0002026 expense · Version B: compensation: $325,0002027 expense · Version A: purchase price: $350,0002027 expense · Version B: compensation: $675,000Goodwill at closing2026 expense2027 expense

Hypothetical example. Version A: $400,000 in goodwill plus $600,000 of expense. Version B: all $1,000,000 is expense.

Show the numbers
 Version A: purchase priceVersion B: compensation
Goodwill at closing$1,300,000$900,000
2026 expense$250,000$325,000
2027 expense$350,000$675,000

Same check, same seller, same performance. In Version A, $400,000 of the payout sits in goodwill (which you may amortize under the private company goodwill alternative) and $600,000 hits earnings. In Version B, all $1,000,000 is expense, and if your lender's covenants use EBITDA, that difference matters.

How is an earnout handled in an asset acquisition?

If what you bought isn't a business (say, one building or a single product line with no processes), it's an asset acquisition, and the rules differ:

Earnouts: business combination vs asset acquisition

Business combination (ASC 805)

  • Recorded at fair value on the acquisition date
  • Part of the consideration that sets goodwill
  • Liability changes after closing go to earnings
  • Measurement period adjustments go to goodwill

Asset acquisition

  • Generally recorded when payment is probable and reasonably estimable
  • Added to the cost of the assets acquired
  • Later changes generally adjust the assets' cost basis
  • No goodwill; derivatives follow their own rules

PwC notes practice varies on the depreciation catch-up when a later earnout adjustment increases an asset's cost. Ask your auditor which approach they expect.

What about taxes?

Only briefly, because tax follows its own rules, not ASC 805. For an asset purchase, an earnout paid as purchase price changes the price allocated to the assets, and the IRS instructions for Form 8594 require a supplemental form for each year the consideration goes up or down. Payments treated as compensation can be taxed very differently for both buyer and seller. Your CPA should look at the earnout structure before the agreement is signed, not after.

Common mistakes

Booking the earnout at the maximum or at zero. It goes on at fair value, then gets remeasured.

Adding a stay-employed clause casually. It can turn the entire earnout into compensation expense.

Adjusting goodwill when targets are hit. After closing, performance-driven changes go through earnings, not goodwill.

Forgetting to remeasure. A liability earnout needs a fresh fair value at every reporting date, including quarterly GAAP statements for a lender.

Treating every acquisition the same way. An asset acquisition earnout follows different rules.

When should you get help?

Before you sign. The purchase agreement decides most of the accounting, and changing a clause later is far harder than getting it right in the draft. Get a valuation specialist for the closing-date fair value and a CPA for the tax side. Once the deal closes, the earnout liability needs a schedule, a fair value update each reporting period and clear support for your reviewer or auditor. Keeping balance sheet accounts like that reconciled and explained each month is part of the accounting service at Fintrix Consulting.

Frequently asked questions

Does an earnout increase goodwill?

If it's purchase price, yes: its closing-date fair value is part of the consideration, so goodwill goes up. If it's compensation, it's excluded and goodwill is lower. Changes in value after closing don't change goodwill, except for measurement period adjustments.

Why did a good year create an expense on my income statement?

Because the earnout liability became more likely to pay. For a cash-settled purchase-price earnout, the increase in fair value after closing is recorded in earnings.

If the seller stays on as an employee, is the earnout automatically compensation?

No. Staying on isn't the test. The decisive question is whether the earnout is automatically forfeited if their employment ends. If it isn't, you weigh the other indicators, like whether their salary is reasonable and how the formula works.

What if the target is missed and nothing is paid?

For a purchase-price liability earnout, the fair value falls to zero and the decrease is recorded as a gain in earnings. Goodwill stays where it was.

Can a private company skip fair value for the earnout?

No. The private company alternatives simplify goodwill and some intangibles, but contingent consideration in a business combination is still measured at fair value.

The bottom line

An earnout is purchase price unless it pays the seller for working after closing, and an automatic forfeiture on leaving makes it compensation. A purchase-price earnout goes on at fair value at closing, adds to goodwill and, if it's a cash liability, gets remeasured through earnings every reporting date. A compensation earnout skips goodwill and becomes expense while the seller works. Read the employment clauses before you sign, because they decide which story your financial statements will tell.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.