Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Fair value in accounting is not the price you'd haggle for (ASC 820)

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Three small wooden model houses standing on printed pie and bar charts
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASC 820, fair value is the price you would receive to sell an asset (or pay to transfer a liability) in an orderly transaction between market participants on the measurement date. It's an exit price, measured in the asset's principal market, using the assumptions any typical buyer would use, not your own plans and not what you paid. Quoted prices for identical items (Level 1) come first; your own estimates (Level 3) come last.

You buy a smaller competitor and the purchase agreement says the trucks are "worth" $48,000 each. Your banker wants the interest rate swap on your term loan "at fair value." Your reviewer asks how you got the number for the building you wrote down last year. Three people, three uses of the same two words.

In everyday business, "fair value" sounds like a fair price, something two sides would agree to after some back and forth. In accounting it means something narrower and more mechanical. ASC 820, Fair Value Measurement, is the standard that defines it and tells you how to measure it whenever another standard asks for fair value.

Below: the definition, the market, the levels and approaches, where you'll meet it, and a worked example.

What does fair value mean under ASC 820?

PwC's guide quotes the definition: fair value is "the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date."

Each phrase does work:

  • "Received to sell" makes it an exit price. What you paid to get the asset (the entry price) isn't the measure, even if the two are often close on day one.
  • "Orderly transaction" means a normal sale with usual marketing time, not a fire sale or a forced liquidation.
  • "Market participants" are the typical, independent, knowledgeable buyers who'd be willing and able to buy. PwC stresses that fair value "is not an entity-specific measurement." Your synergies, your discount from a friendly supplier and your plan for the asset don't count unless any buyer would see them too.
  • "At the measurement date" means today's conditions, not last year's price and not where you think the market is heading.

So the price you'd haggle for, the seller's asking price and the price you'd love to get someday are all different from fair value, even when the numbers land close together.

Which market sets the price?

ASC 820-10-35-5 says to assume the sale happens in the principal market for the asset, meaning the market with the greatest volume and level of activity for it. Only if there's no principal market do you use the most advantageous market, the one that would leave you with the most money after transaction and transport costs.

Two cost rules trip people up:

  • Transaction costs (auction fees, broker commissions) are not deducted from fair value (ASC 820-10-35-9B). They only matter when you're choosing the most advantageous market.
  • Transport costs are deducted when location is a characteristic of the asset, such as the cost to get a truck to the auction yard.

What is highest and best use?

For nonfinancial assets (buildings, land, equipment, intangibles), fair value assumes the asset is put to its highest and best use by market participants. Under ASC 820-10-35-10B, that's a use that is physically possible, legally permissible and financially feasible.

Your intended use doesn't decide it. PwC's guide gives the example of a site a company runs as a bowling alley that would be valued as a parking lot if market participants would pay more for that use and zoning allows it. In practice, ASC 820-10-35-10C presumes your current use is the highest and best use unless market or other factors suggest otherwise, so for most small businesses this matters mainly for land and buildings in changing neighborhoods.

Highest and best use doesn't apply to financial assets like stocks, receivables or swaps.

What are Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3?

The fair value hierarchy ranks the inputs used in a measurement, not the asset itself. PwC's summary of the levels:

LevelInputsSmall business examples
Level 1Quoted prices (unadjusted) for identical assets or liabilities in active marketsShares of a listed company or an exchange-traded fund in a brokerage account
Level 2Other inputs observable for the asset or liability, directly or indirectlyAn interest rate swap valued from market interest rate curves; used trucks priced from recent auction sales of similar trucks
Level 3Unobservable inputs, such as the entity's own dataA minority stake in a private company; customer relationships valued from your own forecast; a specialized machine with no resale market

Two rules go with the table. You must maximize relevant observable inputs and minimize unobservable ones. And a measurement is categorized in its entirety by the lowest-level input that's significant to it, so one significant Level 3 assumption makes the whole number Level 3.

Level 3 isn't wrong or suspicious. It just needs more support and more disclosure, and auditors will spend more time on it.

How is fair value estimated: market, income or cost?

ASC 820 describes three valuation approaches (ASC 820-10-55-3A to 3F):

The three valuation approaches

What similar things sold for

Market approach

  • Uses prices from market transactions for identical or comparable items
  • Typical for listed securities, vehicles, real estate with good comparables

Future cash, discounted

Income approach

  • Converts future cash flows or earnings into one current amount
  • Typical for swaps, customer relationships, a business or reporting unit

Cost to replace

Cost approach

  • What it would cost today to replace the asset's service capacity, adjusted for wear and obsolescence
  • Typical for specialized equipment with no active resale market

Where do small businesses actually meet fair value?

Not every company needs ASC 820 every year. PwC's scope list shows the topics that call for fair value. The ones that come up most for private companies:

  • Buying a business. Under ASC 805, the assets acquired and liabilities assumed are generally recorded at fair value, with the rest going to goodwill. Our post on buying a business covers the purchase price allocation.
  • Impairment. When a long-lived asset fails the recoverability test, the write-down is to fair value. See long-lived asset impairment under ASC 360. Goodwill impairment also compares to fair value.
  • Investments. Equity securities with a readily determinable fair value are carried at fair value with changes in net income (ASC 321). A private company stake without one can use the measurement alternative: cost minus impairment, adjusted when you see an orderly transaction in the same or a similar investment of that issuer.
  • Interest rate swaps. Derivatives are measured at fair value, though many private companies can elect simpler hedge accounting and use settlement value instead. Our post on interest rate swaps for private companies walks through it.
  • Crypto assets. In-scope crypto is now held at fair value under ASU 2023-08 (our post).
  • Nonprofit gifts in kind. Donated goods are recorded at fair value when received.

A worked example: the trucks in an acquisition

Say you run a landscaping company and you buy a smaller competitor. Among the assets are 8 used pickup trucks of similar age and mileage. The seller's schedule values them at $48,000 each, which is roughly what a dealer would charge you to buy a comparable truck off the lot. That's an entry price.

To find fair value, you look at where trucks like these actually sell. Your research turns up two markets:

Per truckDealer auctionPrivate sale through a broker
Price received$42,000$44,000
Transaction costs (fees, commission)$2,500$4,500
Transport cost$800$300
Net cash you'd keep$38,700$39,200

Commercial trucks like these trade in volume at dealer auctions, so the auction is the principal market. Fair value is the auction price less transport: $42,000 minus $800 = $41,200 per truck. The $2,500 auction fee isn't deducted, because transaction costs aren't part of fair value.

Notice the trap. The private sale would leave you with more cash ($39,200 against $38,700), but that doesn't matter when a principal market exists. The most advantageous market only comes into play if there is no principal market. If there weren't one here, the private sale would be the most advantageous market and fair value would be $44,000 minus $300 = $43,700.

From the seller's number to fair value, per truck

Used pickup truck, principal market is the dealer auction

  • Increase
  • Reduces value
  • Total
$0$20k$40k$60kDealer retail price: $48,000$48kDealerretailpriceDealer margin: −$6,000−$6kDealermarginAuction price: $42,000$42kAuctionpriceTransport to auction: −$800−$800Transportto auctionFair value: $41,200$41kFair value

Hypothetical example. Auction fees of $2,500 are not deducted: transaction costs aren't part of fair value.

Show the numbers
Dealer retail price$48,000
Dealer margin−$6,000
Auction price$42,000
Transport to auction−$800
Fair value$41,200

For all 8 trucks, fair value is 8 × $41,200 = $329,600, not the $384,000 (8 × $48,000) on the seller's schedule. That $54,400 difference doesn't disappear: in an acquisition it ends up in goodwill instead of equipment, which changes your depreciation going forward.

Because the auction prices are for similar trucks rather than identical ones, adjusted for mileage and condition, this measurement is often Level 2. If the adjustments were large and based on your own judgment, it could slide to Level 3.

Common mistakes

Using what you paid. The purchase price is a starting point. It isn't fair value if the deal was with a related party, if the seller was under duress, or if one price covered a bundle of assets.

Deducting transaction costs. Fees and commissions shape which market is most advantageous, but they never come off the fair value itself.

Using your own plans. "We'd never sell it" or "it's worth more to us" doesn't change fair value. Market participants set it.

Calling everything Level 1. A broker statement price for a thinly traded bond, or a price for a similar (not identical) asset, isn't Level 1.

Treating an appraisal as final without reading it. You own the number in your financial statements. Read the appraiser's assumptions and make sure they describe an exit price, in the right market, at the right date.

When should you get help?

If your only fair value item is a brokerage account of listed funds, you can pull the year-end statement and you're done. That's Level 1 and simple.

Bring in specialists when you buy a business, test an asset or goodwill for impairment, hold private company stakes, or carry a derivative. The valuation itself comes from an independent appraiser or valuation firm, and your CPA or auditor will review it. Keeping the fixed asset schedule current and every balance sheet account reconciled and explained each month, so the appraiser starts from clean numbers, is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting.

Frequently asked questions

Is fair value the same as market value?

Close, but not identical. Fair value under ASC 820 is specifically an exit price in the principal market, using market participant assumptions, not adjusted for transaction costs. Everyday "market value" is looser and might mean an asking price or a retail price.

Is fair value the same as fair market value for taxes?

No. Fair market value is a tax concept with its own definition and case law. The two numbers are often close, but they come from different rules, so don't assume a tax appraisal answers an ASC 820 question.

Do private companies have to follow ASC 820?

Yes, whenever a GAAP standard requires or permits fair value, the measurement follows ASC 820. Private companies have some reduced disclosures and some alternatives, such as settlement value for qualifying swaps, but the definition is the same.

Does my balance sheet need to show everything at fair value?

No. Most assets of a typical small business, like equipment, inventory and receivables, are carried at cost or amortized cost. Fair value comes in only where a specific standard calls for it, such as acquisitions, impairments, certain investments and derivatives.

The bottom line

Fair value in accounting is a disciplined estimate of what a typical buyer would pay you today in the main market for the asset. It ignores what you paid, what you'd like to get and what you plan to do with it. Pick the principal market, don't deduct transaction costs, use observable inputs wherever you can, and keep the support with the number. Do that and the appraiser's report, the reviewer's questions and your balance sheet will all tell the same story.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.