Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

What auditors check in a nonprofit's leases

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
One person handing a bunch of keys into another person's open palm
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

When auditors test a nonprofit's leases under ASC 842 they mostly check four things: that the lease list is complete (including leases hidden in program and service contracts), that the discount rate is supported or the risk-free rate election is documented, that the schedules tie to the general ledger, and that below-market or free space is split correctly between the lease and a contribution. Nonprofits also need to watch how grant terms treat lease costs.

The auditors' request list arrives in late summer. Somewhere between "bank confirmations" and "board minutes" is a line that reads Lease schedule and supporting agreements. You send the office lease, the copier lease, and a spreadsheet someone built when ASC 842 first came in. Two weeks later the questions start. What about the room the county lets you use for a dollar a year? Why does the van in the transportation contract have a VIN on it? Where did the 3.9% discount rate come from?

Nonprofits follow the same lease standard as businesses (ASC 842 for small businesses covers the basics). This post is about what's different for a nonprofit, and what an auditor will pull apart.

What do auditors test in a nonprofit's leases?

The Journal of Accountancy calls lease completeness "a critical 'completeness test' that auditors need to perform," and that matches what you'll see in the field. Expect requests in roughly this order:

What the auditor will ask for

Completeness

  • A list of every lease, with start date, term, payments and renewal options
  • Rent and equipment expense detail, so they can look for payments that aren't on the list
  • Recurring vendor payments that might hide a lease (vehicles, storage, IT hardware, dedicated space in a partner's building)
  • Program and service contracts that use a specific asset

Measurement

  • Support for each discount rate, or the policy memo for the risk-free rate election and which asset classes it covers
  • Your reasoning on renewal options you counted or ignored
  • Lease schedules (liability and right-of-use asset) that tie to the general ledger at year end

Nonprofit items

  • Fair rental value support for any below-market or free space
  • The contribution entries and how they sit in net assets
  • Grant terms that cover rent, and how lease costs were charged to each grant

Disclosures

  • Lease cost by type, weighted average term and rate, and a maturity table
  • The ASU 2020-07 disclosures for contributed use of facilities

Completeness is where most surprises come from. Auditors work backwards from expense accounts and contracts to see whether anything is missing, and a lease that never made the list is a missing liability.

Can a nonprofit use the risk-free rate?

Yes. Every nonprofit can. ASU 2021-09 says its amendments affect lessees that are not public business entities, "including all not-for-profit entities," and the update text makes clear that includes nonprofits that are conduit bond obligors (organizations that have borrowed through tax-exempt bonds issued by a government conduit).

Three rules come with it:

  • You can make the election by class of underlying asset, such as real estate or vehicles, rather than for every lease.
  • If the rate implicit in a lease is readily determinable, you must use that rate anyway.
  • You must disclose which asset classes use the risk-free rate.

It saves you from building an incremental borrowing rate, which is hard when you rarely borrow. But a lower rate means a bigger lease liability and can push more leases into finance lease classification. Our post on the risk-free rate election runs one lease both ways; do that comparison first if you have a line of credit with a covenant.

Either way, the auditor wants a dated memo: which rate, where it came from (for a Treasury rate, the term that matches the lease), and which classes it applies to.

How do you account for below-market or donated space?

This is the most nonprofit-specific part of lease accounting, and the one most often done wrong.

If you pay something, but less than market rent, PwC's not-for-profit guide splits the arrangement in two. The cash payments you actually make are a lease under ASC 842. The difference between those payments and the fair rental value of the space is a contribution under ASC 958-605. For a multi-year promise, you record contribution revenue and a contribution receivable, measured at present value, and the guide says the receivable can be combined with the right-of-use asset on the balance sheet, with proper disclosure.

If you pay nothing at all, it isn't a lease. PwC is direct about it: when no consideration is paid, the arrangement "does not meet the definition of a lease under ASC 842 and should be accounted for entirely as a contribution." You record the fair value of the use as contribution revenue, and occupancy expense as you use the space.

Both are contributed nonfinancial assets, so the ASU 2020-07 presentation and disclosure rules apply. We covered those, and how gifts in kind flow to Form 990, in reporting donated goods and services. The short version: show them as a separate line in the statement of activities and disclose how you valued them.

Three ways a nonprofit gets space

Plain lease

Market rent

  • ASC 842 only
  • Lease liability and right-of-use asset for the payments
  • No contribution

Split it

Below-market rent

  • Cash payments: ASC 842 lease
  • Fair rental value minus payments: contribution under ASC 958-605
  • Multi-year: contribution receivable at present value

Not a lease

Free use

  • No consideration, so outside ASC 842
  • Whole fair value is a contribution
  • Occupancy expense recorded as you use it

A worked example: a youth center in a city-owned building

Say you run a youth center. The city leases you a building for five years at $1,000 a month. A broker's letter puts the fair rental value at $5,000 a month. No renewal option, no implicit rate, and you've elected the risk-free rate for real estate. Assume a five-year Treasury rate of 4% at the start of the lease.

Over the term, the space is worth $300,000. You'll pay $60,000. The other $240,000 is a contribution from the city.

Day one entries (rounded):

  • Lease: right-of-use asset and lease liability of $54,299, the present value of 60 payments of $1,000 at 4%.
  • Contribution: contribution receivable of $217,196 and contribution revenue of $217,196, the present value of 60 months of $4,000 of donated use. Because the gift is use of space over five years, the revenue goes into net assets with donor restrictions (an implied time restriction).

Each year after that:

  • Operating lease cost of $12,000, straight line.
  • Donated rent expense of $48,000, as you use the space, charged against the receivable and released from restriction.
  • The discount on the receivable unwinds as extra contribution revenue: $7,959 in year one, falling to $1,024 in year five, for $22,804 in total.

Occupancy cost each year: cash rent vs donated rent

Hypothetical youth center, $5,000 a month of space for $1,000 a month

  • Lease cost (cash rent)
  • Donated rent (fair value minus rent)
$0$20k$40k$60kYear 1 · Lease cost (cash rent): $12,000Year 1 · Donated rent (fair value minus rent): $48,000Year 2 · Lease cost (cash rent): $12,000Year 2 · Donated rent (fair value minus rent): $48,000Year 3 · Lease cost (cash rent): $12,000Year 3 · Donated rent (fair value minus rent): $48,000Year 4 · Lease cost (cash rent): $12,000Year 4 · Donated rent (fair value minus rent): $48,000Year 5 · Lease cost (cash rent): $12,000Year 5 · Donated rent (fair value minus rent): $48,000Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5

Hypothetical example. Together the two equal the $60,000 a year fair rental value.

Show the numbers
 Lease cost (cash rent)Donated rent (fair value minus rent)
Year 1$12,000$48,000
Year 2$12,000$48,000
Year 3$12,000$48,000
Year 4$12,000$48,000
Year 5$12,000$48,000

Here's how the contribution receivable runs down. The auditor will want a schedule like this, tied to the ledger:

YearOpening receivableDiscount unwound (revenue)Donated rent used (expense)Closing receivable
1$217,196$7,959$48,000$177,155
2$177,155$6,328$48,000$135,483
3$135,483$4,630$48,000$92,113
4$92,113$2,863$48,000$46,976
5$46,976$1,024$48,000$0
Total$22,804$240,000

Two things to notice. First, $217,196 of revenue lands in year one, which can look like a windfall, so explain it in the board pack. Second, the statement of activities now shows the full $60,000 a year the building really costs, which your functional expense allocation then spreads across programs.

What happens when a grant pays the rent?

Grant budgets think in cash rent; GAAP thinks in lease cost. For an operating lease with level payments the two are close, but they drift apart with finance leases, rent holidays or escalations.

For federal awards, the cost principles in 2 CFR 200.465 matter:

  • Rental costs are allowable to the extent the rates are reasonable.
  • Payments on a lease that is a right-of-use operating lease under FASB standards are allowable.
  • For a lease that must be accounted for as a finance lease, allowable costs are capped at what you could have charged if you owned the asset (depreciation, maintenance, taxes, insurance), and interest is allowable only if it meets the separate interest rule.
  • "Less-than-arm's-length" leases, such as space rented from a board member or an affiliate under common control, get the same ownership-cost cap.

So keep two numbers per lease: the GAAP expense, and the cost you charged each grant. If they differ, keep the reconciliation. Auditors who test a grant will ask for it, and the nonprofit grant accounting post shows how to track spending by grant all year.

Where do embedded leases hide in nonprofit contracts?

Program contracts are the usual hiding place. A contract is or contains a lease when it conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period, in exchange for payment. Look for:

  • A transportation vendor that supplies a specific van, with your logo, for your routes only
  • A partner agency's MOU that gives you a named room for a monthly fee
  • A supplier that installs a dedicated freezer or machine at your site
  • Storage units and parking spaces paid monthly by card

Any of these may need to go on the lease list, unless the term is 12 months or less and you've elected the short-term exemption. The judgment calls (is the asset identified, who directs its use, how to split out the service part) are covered in our embedded leases post.

Common mistakes

Recording below-market rent at the cash amount. It's the easiest error to make and the auditor will find it. The contribution is real revenue and real expense, and it changes your program cost.

Treating free space as a lease. No payment means no lease. It's a contribution, start to finish.

No fair value support. "The landlord said it's worth about $5,000" won't hold up. Get a broker's letter or comparable listings.

A discount rate with no paper trail. Even with the risk-free election, write down which Treasury term you used and why.

Charging grants the GAAP number without checking the award. Finance leases and related-party space have their own caps.

When should you get help?

If you have one office lease and a copier, you can maintain the schedule yourself with a decent template and a reminder to update it when something changes.

Get help when you have donated or below-market space, a grant that pays rent, a related-party landlord, or an audit coming with no lease schedule anyone trusts. Your auditor can't build the schedule for you and then audit it. At Fintrix Consulting, keeping restricted and unrestricted money apart and having records organized for your Form 990 preparer and auditor is part of how we work with nonprofits.

Frequently asked questions

Do nonprofits have to follow ASC 842?

Yes. Nonprofits that issue GAAP financial statements follow ASC 842 like businesses do. The differences are in the details, such as the risk-free rate election being open to every nonprofit and the contribution accounting for below-market or donated space.

Can a nonprofit that issued tax-exempt bonds use the risk-free rate?

Yes. ASU 2021-09 says the election applies to all not-for-profit entities, whether or not they are conduit bond obligors. You can make it by class of asset, but you must still use the rate implicit in a lease when it's readily determinable.

We use a church's building for free. Is that a lease?

No. With no consideration paid, the arrangement doesn't meet the ASC 842 definition of a lease. It's a contribution of the use of the space, recorded at fair value, with the ASU 2020-07 disclosures for contributed nonfinancial assets.

How do we prove the fair rental value of donated space?

A letter from a commercial real estate broker, or listings for comparable space in the same area, is the usual support. Keep it with the lease file and refresh it when a new arrangement starts.

The bottom line

A nonprofit's lease audit goes well when three things are ready: a complete lease list that includes the space and equipment hidden in other contracts, a written basis for every discount rate, and a fair value file for any space you get cheap or free. Split below-market rent into a lease and a contribution, keep free space out of ASC 842 entirely, and keep a reconciliation for any grant that pays rent. Do that, and the lease section of the request list stops being the part everyone dreads.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.