Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Recording an ERC refund (and the risk of clawback)

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Silver desk calculator and black reading glasses on a white office desk beside a fanned stack of black binders with colored index tabs
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

US GAAP has no rule written for the ERC, so businesses borrow one: usually a grant model (IAS 20 or ASC 958-605) or the gain contingency model in ASC 450-30. Income tax accounting doesn't fit, because the ERC is a payroll tax credit. Under any of these, a refund in the bank isn't income yet. If you can't show you were probably eligible, record the cash as a deferred liability and move it to income when the IRS confirms the claim or the assessment period closes. For Q3 and Q4 2021 claims, that period can now run six years from the date you filed.

The ERC refund finally landed. Maybe it took 18 months, maybe the check was larger than a good month of revenue. The firm that filed the claim took its cut, and the rest is sitting in your operating account.

Then your accountant says something unwelcome: that money may not belong on your profit and loss yet. The IRS paid most claims without checking eligibility first, and it can still come back for the money, with interest and possibly penalties. Lenders, buyers and reviewers know that too.

Below: how to record the refund under US GAAP, why the timing can stretch years past the deposit, what ASU 2025-10 changes, and the tax side.

Why is there no clear GAAP rule for the ERC?

The ERC is a refundable credit against employer payroll taxes. It isn't an income tax credit, so ASC 740 (income taxes) doesn't apply, a point Grant Thornton and Plante Moran both make. And until recently, US GAAP had no general guidance for government grants received by businesses.

So companies pick a model by analogy. Grant Thornton describes three acceptable choices:

Three ways to account for an ERC under current GAAP

Grant model

IAS 20 by analogy

  • Recognize when there's reasonable assurance you'll receive it and you met the conditions (in practice, that you'd pass an IRS exam)
  • Present as other income, or net against payroll tax expense
  • Usually recognized in full once the threshold is met, since the wages are already paid

Grant model

ASC 958-605 by analogy

  • Recognize when the eligibility barriers are substantially met, or the statute of limitations runs out
  • Present as other income, not as revenue and not as an expense offset
  • The IRS's right to examine works like a donor's right of return

Gain contingency

ASC 450-30

  • Recognize only when realized or realizable: the IRS confirms eligibility or the assessment period closes
  • Present as a gain
  • The most conservative timing of the three

Whichever you choose, apply it consistently and disclose it. Grant Thornton adds that a third-party ERC specialist's report on its own may not be enough evidence that you were eligible.

Does getting the refund mean you were eligible?

No. This is the mistake behind most of the problems.

On original claims, the IRS generally issued refunds without reviewing eligibility. Plante Moran puts it plainly: receiving payment is not evidence of eligibility. The IRS FAQ says anyone who claimed the credit incorrectly and got a refund must pay it back, possibly with penalties and interest.

So the question isn't "did the cash arrive?" It's "can we document that we qualified for each quarter we claimed?" That usually means one of two paths: a gross receipts decline you can show from your own records, or a full or partial suspension of operations caused by a government order. The second one is harder to support, especially when it rests on general supply chain problems rather than an order that applied to you.

If the answer is "probably yes, and here's the file," you can likely recognize the credit. If it's "the promoter said we qualified," treat the cash as a liability.

How long can the IRS claw back an ERC?

Longer than most owners assume, and the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made it longer for late-2021 claims.

According to Plante Moran's summary of the assessment deadlines:

  • 2020 quarters: April 15, 2024
  • Q1 and Q2 2021: April 15, 2025
  • Q3 and Q4 2021: the later of April 15, 2028, or six years after the claim was filed

Fraud has no time limit. So for a typical Q3 2021 claim filed in 2023, exposure runs into 2029.

The same law also cut off late claims. Per IRS Fact Sheet 2025-07, section 70605(d) bars the IRS from allowing or refunding Q3 and Q4 2021 ERCs after July 4, 2025, if the claim was filed after January 31, 2024. A claim filed after that date but already paid before July 4, 2025 isn't caught by the cutoff, though the IRS notes other compliance work can still produce a bill. Claims for 2020 and the first half of 2021 aren't affected by these changes.

A worked example: an ERC refund with one quarter still open

Say you run a 12-person landscaping company with a calendar year. In June 2023 a promoter filed amended Forms 941-X for you, claiming the 2021 ERC for eight employees in two quarters. In 2021 the credit was 70% of up to $10,000 of qualified wages per employee per quarter, so $7,000 per employee per quarter (IRS comparison chart):

  • Q2 2021: 8 × $7,000 = $56,000
  • Q3 2021: 8 × $7,000 = $56,000
  • Total refund received in 2024: $112,000 (ignore IRS interest to keep it simple)
  • Promoter's contingent fee: 20%, or $22,400

The eligibility argument was a partial suspension from a local order plus supply delays. Your CPA reviews it and says the documentation is thin. You can't say eligibility is probable. You use a grant model and defer the cash.

WhenEntryDebitCredit
2024, refund arrivesCash / Deferred ERC liability$112,000$112,000
2024, fee paidProfessional fees expense / Cash$22,400$22,400
April 15, 2025, Q2 window closesDeferred ERC liability / Other income, ERC$56,000$56,000
June 2029, Q3 window closesDeferred ERC liability / Other income, ERC$56,000$56,000

The fee is a separate cost. Grant Thornton notes promoter fees are generally expensed as the services are performed, not netted against the credit. If you later recover part of the fee from the promoter, that's its own gain contingency.

Here's the effect on reported income compared with booking the whole refund the day it arrived:

ERC income recognized by year

Landscaping company, $112,000 refund received in 2024

  • Booked when cash arrived
  • Deferred until window closes
$0$50k$100k$150k2024 · Booked when cash arrived: $112,0002024 · Deferred until window closes: $02025 · Booked when cash arrived: $02025 · Deferred until window closes: $56,0002026 · Booked when cash arrived: $02026 · Deferred until window closes: $02027 · Booked when cash arrived: $02027 · Deferred until window closes: $02028 · Booked when cash arrived: $02028 · Deferred until window closes: $02029 · Booked when cash arrived: $02029 · Deferred until window closes: $56,000202420252026202720282029

Hypothetical example. Both total $112,000; only the timing differs.

Show the numbers
 Booked when cash arrivedDeferred until window closes
2024$112,000$0
2025$0$56,000
2026$0$0
2027$0$0
2028$0$0
2029$0$56,000

Now suppose the IRS examines Q3 in 2027 and disallows it. With the deferral, the entry is simple: debit the deferred liability $56,000, credit cash, and expense the interest and any penalties. Your 2024 profit was never overstated. Had you booked the full $112,000 in 2024, you'd now be explaining a $56,000 reversal to the bank.

What does ASU 2025-10 change for the ERC?

ASU 2025-10 gives business entities their first US GAAP topic on government grants (ASC 832). We cover the standard in detail in our post on ASU 2025-10. For the ERC, three points matter.

It's in scope. BDO lists refundable tax credits not accounted for under ASC 740 among the transactions the ASU covers. That describes the ERC.

The threshold is "probable." You don't recognize a grant until it's probable you'll comply with its conditions and receive it. For an ERC that's already paid, the hard part is the first half: probable that you met the eligibility rules.

Private companies have time. It's required for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2029, with early adoption allowed. Under the modified prospective transition, the guidance applies to grants not complete at adoption. An ERC still sitting in a deferred liability in 2030 may fall into that bucket, so agree the treatment with your auditor before adopting.

How does the ERC affect your income tax return?

The ERC reduces the wage expense you can deduct for the year the qualified wages were paid, per the IRS FAQ. For most claimants that's a 2021 deduction, claimed years before the refund arrived.

The IRS updated its FAQ in March 2025 to make the fix easier. If the credit was paid in a later year and you never reduced the 2021 wage deduction, you can generally include the overstated amount in income in the year you received the ERC, under the tax benefit rule, instead of amending the 2021 return. Amending is optional. And if a claim is later disallowed after you reduced the deduction, you can increase wage expense by the same amount in the year the disallowance becomes final.

In our example, how the $112,000 hits the tax return is your CPA's call, and it's separate from GAAP timing. If you're a C corporation, the book-tax difference belongs in your income tax accounting.

What disclosures do you need?

Grant Thornton points to the existing government assistance disclosures in ASC 832 for annual statements, whichever model you use:

ERC disclosure and documentation checklist

In the notes

  • The nature of the ERC and that you received cash
  • The accounting policy you chose (grant model or gain contingency)
  • Which balance sheet and income statement lines are affected, with amounts
  • Significant terms and contingencies: the IRS's right to examine and recapture, and how long it lasts

In your files

  • Quarter-by-quarter eligibility support: gross receipts calculations or the government orders you relied on
  • Copies of every Form 941-X and IRS notice
  • The promoter agreement and fee calculation
  • A schedule of each claimed quarter with its assessment closing date

If you've applied but haven't met the recognition threshold, you still disclose. Model-specific disclosures apply on top: under ASC 450-30, describe a gain contingency carefully so it doesn't suggest the money is secure. Our post on lawsuits and contingencies under ASC 450 explains that wording.

Common mistakes

Booking the refund as revenue. The government isn't your customer. It's other income, a gain, or a reduction of payroll tax expense, depending on your model.

Netting the promoter fee. Record the full credit and the fee separately.

Recording a receivable for a claim that can't be paid. If your Q3 or Q4 2021 claim was filed after January 31, 2024 and wasn't paid by July 4, 2025, the IRS is barred from paying it.

Using the old three-year clock for late-2021 quarters. Six years from the claim date is now the floor for Q3 and Q4 2021.

Forgetting the closing dates. When a quarter's window passes, move its balance to income. Similar logic applies to forgivable loans.

When should you get help?

If your statements are for internal use only and the claim was solid (a clear gross receipts decline, documented), recording the credit is straightforward and you can likely handle it with your CPA's sign-off.

Get help if the claim was prepared by a promoter, if eligibility rests on a suspension-of-operations argument, if you've received an IRS letter, or if your statements go to a lender, investors or a buyer (a reviewer or auditor will ask about it; see audit, review or compilation). Questions about eligibility, appeals or repayment belong with your CPA or tax attorney. Having every balance sheet account, a deferred ERC balance included, reconciled and explained each month is part of the accounting work we do at Fintrix Consulting.

Frequently asked questions

Is an ERC refund taxable income?

Not directly. The ERC reduces the wage deduction for the year the qualified wages were paid. Under the IRS's March 2025 FAQ, if you didn't reduce that deduction, you can generally include the overstated amount in income in the year you received the credit instead of amending. Your CPA decides which route fits.

When can I move a deferred ERC to income?

When your eligibility becomes probable (for example, the IRS examines the quarter and accepts it) or when the assessment period for that quarter closes without an exam. For Q3 and Q4 2021 claims, that's at least six years after you filed the claim.

Does ASU 2025-10 apply to the ERC?

Likely yes. It covers refundable tax credits not accounted for under ASC 740, which describes the ERC. Private companies must adopt it for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2029, and may adopt early.

The bottom line

An ERC refund in the bank isn't income until you can show you were probably eligible, or until the IRS's window to take it back closes. Choose a model, write down why, and keep each claimed quarter on its own schedule with its own closing date. For late-2021 claims, expect that window to run about six years from when you filed. Book it carefully now and a later IRS letter becomes a balance sheet entry, not a restatement.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.