Fintrix Consulting LLC

Accounting standards

Forming a joint venture: the new fair-value rules (ASU 2023-05)

November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

← All articles
Several people fitting large white puzzle pieces together on a dark wooden table
Photo via Pexels

Quick answer

Under ASU 2023-05 (ASC 805-60), a joint venture formed on or after January 1, 2025 records the assets and liabilities its owners contribute at fair value on the formation date, not at the owners' old book values. Total net assets equal the fair value of 100% of the venture's equity right after formation; any excess over the identifiable net assets is goodwill, and any shortfall goes to equity, not income. The rules apply to the joint venture's own financial statements; the owners' equity method accounting doesn't change.

Two companies shake hands on a joint venture. One puts in a warehouse it bought fifteen years ago. The other puts in cash, trucks and a book of customer contracts. A new LLC opens a bank account, and somebody has to write the opening balance sheet.

For years, nobody agreed on how. Some ventures carried over each owner's book values; others stepped everything up to fair value. The FASB closed that gap with ASU 2023-05, Business Combinations, Joint Venture Formations, and for ventures formed from 2025 on, the answer is fair value.

Here's who it applies to, how the opening balance sheet is built, a worked example with numbers, and what it means for the owners.

What problem does ASU 2023-05 solve?

Before this update, US GAAP had no specific guidance on how a newly formed joint venture should account for what its owners contribute. As CohnReznick puts it, that gap produced diversity in practice.

The most common approach was carryover basis: the venture recorded a contributed warehouse at whatever it was worth on the contributing owner's books, often a tiny number after years of depreciation. Internally built assets, like a customer list the owner never paid for, didn't show up at all. Lenders ended up reading statements that badly understated what the venture owned.

ASU 2023-05 replaces that with a new basis of accounting. The venture borrows the measurement rules from business combination accounting (ASC 805), but adapted: there's no acquirer, because nobody controls a joint venture alone.

Which entities does it apply to?

It applies to the separate financial statements of the joint venture itself, not to the companies that own it. RSM's summary sets out the edges:

  • In scope: a legal entity that meets the definition of a joint venture or corporate joint venture in the Master Glossary. The ASU didn't change that definition, so you still have to assess it. In broad terms that means an entity run as a separate business for the mutual benefit of a small group of owners who control it jointly.
  • Out of scope: joint ventures that one or more owners proportionately consolidate, not-for-profit formations under Topic 958, and collaborative arrangements under Topic 808 unless part of the arrangement sits in a separate legal entity that meets the joint venture definition.

In practice, this hits real estate partnerships, energy and infrastructure ventures, and companies that pool operations with a partner. If one owner controls the entity, it isn't a joint venture, and the controlling owner consolidates it instead. If you own a stake without joint control, you're probably looking at equity method accounting under ASC 323 from the investor's side, which this update leaves alone.

Opening balance sheet of a new joint venture

Mixed practice

Before ASU 2023-05

  • Often carryover basis: each owner's old book values
  • Internally built intangibles (customer lists, know-how) usually left off
  • Goodwill rarely recorded
  • Two similar ventures could look very different

ASC 805-60

Formed on or after Jan 1, 2025

  • New basis: identifiable assets and liabilities at fair value
  • Contributed intangibles recognized if they meet ASC 805 criteria
  • Goodwill = fair value of the venture minus identifiable net assets
  • Negative goodwill goes to equity, never to income

How is the opening balance sheet measured?

The steps look like a business combination, without an acquirer.

  1. Find the formation date. That's the date the entity first meets the definition of a joint venture. RSM warns it isn't necessarily the legal formation date or the dates the owners hand over assets. Every piece of the formation is measured on this one date.
  2. Value the venture as a whole. Measure the fair value of 100% of the venture's equity immediately after formation, including any noncontrolling interest. This usually takes a valuation, and the fair value rules in ASC 820 apply.
  3. Recognize and measure identifiable assets and liabilities under ASC 805-20, with the same exceptions used in business combinations (deferred taxes, for example, follow their own rules). This applies even if what was contributed isn't a business.
  4. Plug the difference. If the fair value of the venture exceeds identifiable net assets, the excess is goodwill. If identifiable net assets exceed the venture's fair value, the shortfall is booked to additional paid-in capital (or members' equity in an LLC), not to a gain.

That's a real difference from a business combination, where a bargain purchase produces a gain.

If the valuation isn't finished when the first financial statements are due, the venture uses provisional amounts and applies the ASC 805-10 measurement period guidance, which allows adjustments for up to one year from the formation date as better information about formation-date facts comes in.

A worked example: a logistics joint venture

Say two companies form Harbor Logistics LLC on March 1, 2026, each owning 50% and sharing control under the operating agreement. This is a hypothetical example.

  • Company A contributes a warehouse with a fair value of $5.3 million (land $1.3 million, building $4.0 million). The venture assumes the $1.2 million mortgage on it. On A's books, the warehouse sits at $2.9 million (land $0.9 million, building $2.0 million).
  • Company B contributes $2.4 million of cash, delivery equipment with a fair value of $1.3 million (book value $0.8 million), and a set of customer relationships valued at $0.4 million that B built itself and never recorded.
  • An independent valuation puts the fair value of 100% of the venture's equity right after formation at $8.5 million.

Identifiable net assets: $5.3 million + $2.4 million + $1.3 million + $0.4 million − $1.2 million = $8.2 million. The venture is worth $8.5 million, so goodwill is $0.3 million, which reflects things like the assembled workforce and the value of combining the two operations.

LineCarryover basis (old practice)New basis (ASU 2023-05)
Cash$2,400,000$2,400,000
Warehouse land$900,000$1,300,000
Warehouse building$2,000,000$4,000,000
Delivery equipment$800,000$1,300,000
Customer relationships$0$400,000
Goodwill$0$300,000
Total assets$6,100,000$9,700,000
Mortgage assumed($1,200,000)($1,200,000)
Members' equity$4,900,000$8,500,000

The $3.6 million difference in equity breaks down like this:

From carryover equity to new-basis equity

Harbor Logistics LLC at formation, March 1, 2026

  • Adds to equity
  • Decrease
  • Total
$0$2.5M$5M$7.5M$10MCarryover equity: $4,900,000$4.9MCarryoverequityWarehouse step-up: +$2,400,000+$2.4MWarehousestep-upEquipment step-up: +$500,000+$500kEquipmentstep-upCustomer relationships: +$400,000+$400kCustomerrelationshipsGoodwill: +$300,000+$300kGoodwillNew-basis equity: $8,500,000$8.5MNew-basisequity

Hypothetical example. Warehouse step-up = land $400,000 + building $2,000,000.

Show the numbers
Carryover equity$4,900,000
Warehouse step-up+$2,400,000
Equipment step-up+$500,000
Customer relationships+$400,000
Goodwill+$300,000
New-basis equity$8,500,000

The step-up doesn't stop at formation. If the building is depreciated over 40 years, annual depreciation is $100,000 on the new $4.0 million basis, double the $50,000 it would have been on a $2.0 million carryover amount. The customer relationships, amortized over an assumed 8 years, add $50,000 a year. So the venture reports about $100,000 more expense each year than it would have under carryover basis, and lower profit for the owners to share. Our post on depreciation basics covers the mechanics.

What does the joint venture have to disclose?

In the period it's formed, RSM lists these disclosures:

Formation-period disclosures under ASC 805-60

The deal

  • Formation date
  • Purpose of the joint venture
  • Fair value of the joint venture as a whole at formation

The balance sheet

  • Description of the assets and liabilities recognized
  • Amounts for each major class of assets and liabilities, on the face or in the notes
  • A qualitative description of the factors that make up any goodwill

If the accounting isn't finished

  • Why the initial accounting is incomplete
  • Which assets, liabilities or equity items are provisional
  • The nature and amount of measurement period adjustments made later

Can a private joint venture use the private company alternatives?

Yes. A private company joint venture can elect the Private Company Council alternatives. CohnReznick notes that a venture can fold certain customer-related intangibles and noncompete agreements into goodwill, but making that election also requires electing to amortize goodwill.

In the Harbor Logistics example, that would mean the $0.4 million of customer relationships joins the $0.3 million of goodwill, and the combined $0.7 million is amortized (often over 10 years). For a small venture, that can save a lot of valuation and impairment work. See our posts on the private company intangibles alternative and goodwill amortization before you decide.

What does it mean for the owners?

Less than you might think. RSM confirms the update doesn't change how the venturers account for their equity method investment, and it doesn't change accounting for contributions made after formation.

What owners do feel:

  • Basis differences. If an owner's investment balance doesn't match its share of the venture's new-basis equity, that difference has to be tracked and amortized in the owner's equity method accounting.
  • Lower reported profit at the venture. Higher depreciation and amortization flow through the venture's income, so the owners' share of earnings drops.
  • Operating agreements. Profit-sharing and distribution clauses written around book income may behave differently once depreciation doubles. Read them before you sign.

When does it take effect?

ASU 2023-05 applies prospectively to joint ventures with a formation date on or after January 1, 2025. Early adoption was allowed. A venture formed before 2025 can choose to apply it fully retrospectively if it has the information to do so, but it isn't required.

Common mistakes

Using the legal formation date by default. The measurement date is when the entity first meets the joint venture definition. If assets were contributed in stages, work out which contributions are part of the formation and which come later.

Booking a gain for negative goodwill. It goes to paid-in capital or members' equity. A gain on day one is always wrong here.

Leaving off internally built intangibles. Customer relationships, technology or trade names an owner never recorded can still meet the ASC 805 recognition criteria at formation.

Valuing the pieces but not the whole. Goodwill is the difference between the venture's total fair value and its identifiable net assets. Without the top-down valuation, you can't measure it.

When should you get help?

If the venture's statements are going to a lender or an auditor, you'll need a valuation specialist and a CPA comfortable with ASC 805. The first financial audit post explains what auditors will ask for. A small venture formed with cash only, and no contributed assets, usually has little to step up and can be handled in-house.

Once the opening balance sheet is set, someone has to keep the new basis alive month after month. Keeping a fixed assets and depreciation schedule and audit- and tax-ready workpapers current is part of the accounting work Fintrix Consulting does.

Frequently asked questions

Does ASU 2023-05 change how I account for my investment in a joint venture?

No. It applies to the joint venture's own financial statements. Venturers keep using the equity method (or other applicable guidance) for their investment, though the venture's new basis can create basis differences the owner has to track.

Our joint venture was formed in 2023. Do we have to restate it?

No. The update is required only for joint ventures with a formation date on or after January 1, 2025. Ventures formed earlier may choose full retrospective application if they have enough information, but it's optional.

What if the owners' contributions are worth more than the venture as a whole?

That's negative goodwill. Under ASU 2023-05 it's recorded as an adjustment to additional paid-in capital, or members' equity for an LLC, not as a gain in the income statement.

Does it apply if the contributed assets aren't a business?

Yes. Identifiable assets and liabilities are recognized and measured under ASC 805-20 even when the contributed assets aren't a business. Goodwill in that case is usually small.

Is a 50/50 LLC automatically a joint venture?

Not automatically. You have to assess the Master Glossary definition, which centers on joint control by the owners and running the entity for their mutual benefit. Ask your auditor to agree the conclusion early.

The bottom line

A joint venture formed from 2025 on starts life at fair value. Value the whole venture, record each identifiable asset and liability at fair value, and treat the difference as goodwill (or as an equity adjustment if it's negative, never a gain). The owners' own accounting barely changes, but the venture's depreciation, profit and disclosures do. Pin down the formation date and order the valuation before the paperwork is signed, not after.

This article is general information, not advice for your situation. Rules change and details matter, so talk to us or your CPA before acting on it.

Have a question about this article?

Ask us. A real person will reply by email within one business day. Your question isn’t published.

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Google’s Privacy Policy and Terms apply.

Ready for books you can trust?

Book a free 30-minute consultation. We'll review where your finances stand today and show you exactly how we'd help.